4 ms·
Let's count Ballmer's winners: - MSN search vs. google? - hotmail vs. gmail? - xbox vs. wii? - zune vs. ipod? - Silverlight vs. AJAX? - Windows vs. linux?
by edw519 19y ago
Let's count Ballmer's winners:
- MSN search vs. google?
- hotmail vs. gmail?
- xbox vs. wii?
- zune vs. ipod?
- Silverlight vs. AJAX?
- Windows vs. linux?
- Vista vs. OSX?
- .net vs. anything that works?
At what point do you stop blaming the soldiers and hold the general acountable?
- JohnN 19y agoBallmer's performance has been questionable but its not wise to fire a CEO without a ready replacement....I dont think Microsoft have anyone.
- edw519 19y agoAll the more reason to go outside. How many more buses are they willing to miss?
- aneesh 19y agoGood points. But I'm pretty sure hotmail still has higher market share than GMail. And though I use Ubuntu over Windows, but the world is still all about Windows. From a revenue perspective, Windows made more money this year than in any previous year. That's good news for Ballmer. And Surface is really cool. MS Research does incredible work. Office is still king, and no one has come up with anything close to an Outlook-killer yet. I don't actually use any of the products you or I mentioned, but MS has plenty of strengths and smart people to balance it's blatant failures. Edit: Photosynth is yet another highly impressive product from MS Live Labs.
- edw519 19y agoNow. <rhetorical question> Do you think Microsoft's board is smart enough to know how fast the tech world is changing? </rhetorical question>
- Hexstream 19y agoI think you should ask if they're informed enough. More data (informed) beats better algorithms (smart).
- mattmaroon 19y agoI think this is the problem. The c-suite at MSFT is full of people who were in the software industry in 1980. I don't really know who all is on the board, but they definitely need to get some fresh blood in the executive offices.
- davatk 19y agoThe problem with products like Photosynth and and Surface is that they don't really address the things Microsoft has problems with (like search). The Office/OS cash cow was really created during the 1990s. I just don't see Ballmer as doing anything except maintain the status quo - which isn't sustainable over the long term.
- wumi 19y agohalf of these arguments are of the Facebook vs. Myspace variety -- or the Yang should be outed argument as well 1. Same could be said for Yahoo vs. Google 2. Hotmail/Live mail has more users than Gmail (ditto with MSN messenger and Gchat, or Yahoomail/Yahoo messenger vs. Gmail/Gchat) 3. How many years did the iPod have on the Zune? You should be making an argument why Ballmer/ MSFT didn't release a Zune Phone, not comparing the iPod to the Zune. 4. Xbox v. Wii? Are you serious? Wii is heavily targeting a casual gamer market, while Xbox is more geared towards a more hard-core gamer, which is OK. Apples and Oranges. Wii outsells in systems, but not in games -- many dont even buy one game but just play what comes on the system. I've had both the Wii and the Xbox/Xbox 360, btw, and I know many who do, just as I know many who have an Xbox and a PS3 for the game variety (i.e. Gears of War, Halo, Tom Clancy games on one and MGS, FF, etc. on the PS3) Don't know any non-hackers who use Linux. what about synch, surface, or photosynth? You think OSX has Vista beat in the business world? Nice try. Most consumers and businesses buy machines not for the OS, but for the brand name of the machine --- Apple, Dell, HP, etc. so I'm not sure I see how OSX is a big winner over Vista. Gaining market share, sure, but Vista as a non-winner? you obviously dislike MSFT but aren't really making any logical arguments why Ballmer should be outed other than that you prefer competing products.
- mattmaroon 19y agoYou're right on number 4. You really can't compare things to the Wii. The Wii is a black swan of sorts. Nintendo is really firing on all cylinders right now. You can't expect MSFT to be able to beat a company entirely focused on gaming, with over 100 years of experience in the industry, in their own arena in that short of a time. In fact, given the number of large companies that have tried and failed to make a dent in the console gaming industry over the last couple decades, the fact that MSFT has become a viable contender in such a short time period is actually quite impressive. The Xbox360 would be my vote for the most intelligent thing they've done in a very long time. They embraced the web before their opponents and did it in a better way with Xbox Live. Features they added first (downloadable games or movies for instance, or the ability to stream media from a computer) are becoming standard elsewhere. In a lot of ways, they're ahead of the curve.
- 19y ago
- mattmaroon 19y agoIn fairness, he's been with them since 1980. Who knows what role he has played in their many successes over that time period. Also, hotmail is far larger than gmail. That one belongs on a non-ironic winners list. If you want to make fun of him, go with hotmail vs. yahoo mail. It might be best for all involved if he moves on though.
- nkohari 19y agoI'll agree that Microsoft hasn't had a stellar record for the past 10 years or so, but this is just ridiculous. + I'll give you MSN search vs. Google, which is of course what the whole Yahoo bid was about. - Hotmail was the first widely-used web mail client, and still has a very significant market share vs. Gmail and Yahoo Mail. - The xbox has a very good market share of consoles, particularly considering the history of its competition in Sony and Nintendo. + The Zune is admittedly an also-ran. Then again, there are a lot of also-rans to the iPod. Microsoft isn't the only company who tried to mimic it and failed. - Silverlight is still extremely new, and is more a competitor to Flash than AJAX. It has potential, but the jury is still very out. - You're kidding, right? Maybe in the server market, but the desktop market is still completely dominated by Windows. + Vista was a huge mistake, and OSX beats the crap out of it. - .NET works just fine as a competitor to Java. You need to substantiate this more if you want to make sweeping claims like that. I'm no Microsoft fan, but it irks me when people blindly bash them. I know it's trendy to be anti-Microsoft (it has been for years), but it's tunnel vision.
- edw519 19y agoI didn't intend to "bash" them. (Well, maybe a little.) I'm just playing stockholder's advocate, questioning the people who are supposed to represent my best long term interests. $40B on the left side of the balance sheet covers for a lot of missteps, but sooner or later, someone's gotta start asking the hard questions like, "What is our focus?", "How do we position ourselves for the massive tech shifts about to happen", "What business are we going to be in in 10 years?", and "Why should I keep my dollars here?" Bullys have a tough time with those questions. Visionaries don't.
- trevelyan 19y ago- xbox vs. wii? Microsoft is doing extremely well with the XBox. It has produced a leading product across multiple generations of the console market and ensured that commercial game development uses DirectX instead of migrating to OpenGL.
- breck 19y agoYes, but let's not forget the most important part of any business, making money. I think he's won where it matters most. MSFT (billions) Mar '08 2007 2006 Revenue: $14.4 $51 $44.3 Net Inc: $4.4 $14 $12.6