3 ms·
An Apple Arm laptop would compete with Chromebook & Surface Go, both of which are "locked down" and optimized for Arm, similar to iPads. - iOS is Apple's pri
by walterbell 8y ago
An Apple Arm laptop would compete with Chromebook & Surface Go, both of which are "locked down" and optimized for Arm, similar to iPads.
- iOS is Apple's primary revenue focus
- iOS is already optimized for Arm
- iOS itself was derived from MacOS
- iOS new derivative can support KB/mouse
- Arm + macOS = no 3rd-party apps compiled for Arm
- Arm + iOS = million existing apps
- Arm + iOS does not conflict with expensive MacBook Pros
- saagarjha 8y ago> iOS is Apple's primary revenue focus > iOS is already optimized for Arm > iOS itself was derived from MacOS All true… > iOS new derivative can support KB/mouse iOS can support the keyboard currently, but not very well. And it can't support the mouse at all. > Arm + macOS = no 3rd-party apps compiled for Arm That's what an emulation layer is for. > Arm + iOS = million existing apps That's a nice bonus. > Arm + iOS does not conflict with expensive MacBook Pros Apple is no stranger to cannibalizing itself. So, overall, I'm still not sold that they won't just make a ARM MacBook that runs macOS, rather than iOS.
- walterbell 8y agoApple controls MacOS and iOS. They can make iOS support kb & mouse, even if initially focused on Apple apps like Terminal, Mail & office. Windows on Arm is forced to use an emulation layer because the majority of Windows apps are x86. The majority of Apple apps are already on Arm. Cannibalization is done to a smaller market in order to reach a larger market. Which market is larger for Apple? Apple can do both: low-cost 2018 Arm iOS laptop and premium 2019 Arm MacOS Macbook (when Marzipan is ready to bring iOS apps to x86).
- eloisant 8y agoSomehow I feel like it would be easier to evolve from the iPad pro with its keyboard to a more laptop-like experience than do the "Universal app" stuff again like they did when they switched from PPC to Intel. And no, I don't think emulating x86 apps on ARM will work well. Both from a technical point of view and legal point of view (Intel patents).
- fernandotakai 8y agojust one thing to remember: you can easily (as in, it's just an app you download from the windows store) unlock the surface go and run windows 10 pro on it. i have one, and i'm doing it -- i can run docker and windows subsystem for linux without a hitch (and honestly, it's not a bad dev experience imho).
- s73v3r_ 8y agoWhy would they do this, instead of continue with the iPad Pro?
- walterbell 8y agoiPad Pro would continue. This would reuse many of the same components and address the "Macbook Air" market which prompted x86 Ultrabook designs. Apple would regain a design crown and compete with cloud-focused Chromebooks for students. The lack of "pro x86" apps on iOS would have less impact on students. It would reduce brand confusion with x86 Macbook Pros, while Apple continues to improve Arm cpu performance. An iPad Pro 12 with external keyboard is poorly integrated and unnecessarily clunky, even though it's the least bad option today for "iOS laptop". iPad Pro is rumored to be getting a USB-C connector, which could enable docking with desktop monitor & keyboard.