10 ms·
How about, "Drone hobbyists angered at pointless laws that treat their hobby like it's a problem" I thought it was pointless, too, until I saw that video taken
by reaperducer 8y ago
How about, "Drone hobbyists angered at pointless laws that treat their hobby like it's a problem"
I thought it was pointless, too, until I saw that video taken from a drone that hovered right above a passenger jet as it was landing at KLAS.
(Sorry I can't search for the video at work — no YT allowed.)
- stickfigure 8y agoThat isn't necessarily a justification. * Is that behavior already illegal under existing law? * Do these new laws meaningfully address that behavior?
- Shivetya 8y agoyou obviously haven't been keeping up with the current state of gun control legislation. governments are keen on making the illegal even more illegal as a means to look like they are doing something and to chip away at rights people are current exercising. drones will eventually become so heavily licensed than anything outside of law enforcement, large news organizations, and politicians, will be restricted to the point of needing specialized parks just to enjoy them. RC planes generally fall under 112-95 Section 336 which pretty much should work for drones
- toss1 8y agoThe problem is that RC planes almost universally require a much higher investment in skill-building to become competent enough to even fly, let alone fly well. There is also a large community of builders and flyers [1], a network of clubs with actual airfields for the purpose, and a multi-million dollar insurance policy with membership. Both the difficulty, the investment, and the training and peer pressure drastically reduces the number of participants who behave like asshats with their aircraft - to essentially zero. With hobby drones, it is exactly the opposite -- just go buy some overgrown toy, and you can now put up in the air a device that with any of hundreds of failures of the device or pilot, can become a lethal projectile falling from the sky. So, yes, serious requirements for anything over a few hundred grams is very reasonable[2]. [1] Academy of Model Aeronautics -- www.modelaircraft.org [2](no, I'm not implying that the Govt automatically implements every reg in a reasonable & effective way, that could still end badly.) [Edit: footnotes]
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoNot to worry. Trump would never sign such redundant regulations.
- spookthesunset 8y agoHere you go! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OlQsYPGtjTE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OlQsYPGtjTE
- x220 8y agoYes, now that it's double illegal, no one will do that anymore.
- KirinDave 8y agoIt's more like quadruple illegal. The thing is, these laws are really, really hard to enforce at the federal level and in general municipal and state governments already do an efficient job (and are happy to collect the fines from rich folks with a hobby) executing on local laws. It's really quite unnecessary.
- wbl 8y agoFoxhunt the control signal.
- KirinDave 8y agoI don't use or scout military hardware but if I were planning to use fpv quadcopters for military use the first thing I'd do is get spread spectrum control hardware.
- yial 8y agoMost RC anymore used frequency hopping spread spectrum for control. Different brands use different amounts of frequencies they hop between. Though all still in the 2.4, 5.8, or different band. A very select few use two different wavelengths at once. (Dragonlink, crossfire)
- gamblor956 8y agoYou know what the difference between a regulatory infraction and a felony are? One is a fine. The other is a few years in prison. It has quite a bit of a deterrent effect. It won't get everyone, but it will cut down on the number of people who try stunts like that.
- wahern 8y ago
- nraynaud 8y agoIt was already illegal, there is no need to make it more illegal. What would be important is forbid passengers planes from flying lower than 500ft.
- dmitrygr 8y ago> What would be important is forbid passengers > planes from flying lower than 500ft. so how do you propose they land?
- zeropoint46 8y agowell outside of the environment obviously
- Intermernet 8y agoCan't land. Front fell off.
- nraynaud 8y agoin the zones that have been conspicuously forbidden to the drones.
- taneq 8y agoIsn't there already a floor on general aviation operations (over most areas, barring crop-dusting and things)?
- Applejinx 8y agoPretty sure that one was CGI: no lights, and the drone did NOT get completely wiped out by the jet's wake, which I think is pretty conclusive. I suppose we could assume that maybe one day a drone pilot COULD do that for real. Also… mighty fast 'drone', to nearly accelerate to the speed of a landing jet. I don't think they make quadcopters quite that brisk yet.
- reaperducer 8y agoAlso… mighty fast 'drone', to nearly accelerate to the speed of a landing jet. I don't think they make quadcopters quite that brisk yet. We must be thinking of different encounter videos. In the one I saw, the drone didn’t move much. It sat in the flight path waiting for a jet to come by.
- Applejinx 8y agoThe drone waits for the jet to come down below it, then leans sharply forward to chase it. In doing this, it drops quite a bit of altitude and hits probably a couple hundred miles an hour before it subsides and lets the jet fly on. The manuevers are quite plausible, the speed not so much. Unless the jet was actually a blimp shaped like a jet :)
- chillfox 8y agoWake turbulence moves down and with the wind. Looking at the video the drone was above the aircraft and would therefore not experience significant wake turbulence.
- rasz 8y agoI saw that one illegal thing that is already illegal, so lets make more things illegal, that will show them!