3 ms·
Marxists by and large have not defended these systems, but attacked them. Leninists and proponents of derived systems like Stalinism and Maoism have defended th
by vidarh 8y ago
Marxists by and large have not defended these systems, but attacked them. Leninists and proponents of derived systems like Stalinism and Maoism have defended them (I'm purposefully avoiding the term "Marxism-Leninism" as depending on who you ask to define this, it can refer to either Leninism or Stalinism; the term was introduced by Stalin and used to justify a lot of his own "innovations" like the thesis of Socialism in One Country, but in "modern" usage it often refers to something closer to Lenins actual ideology purged of the Stalinist elements; but in any case it is ambiguous). Under Marxist theory all of these systems are doomed to failure - Marx argued already in The German Ideology (1845) that he saw an advanced capitalist economy with sufficient wealth that redistribution would eliminated poverty, rather than just spread it around, to be an essential precondition for a socialist revolution to succeed without devolving into renewed class struggle.
It was Lenin that "circumvented" that requirement with his idea of a "revolutionary vanguard" to guide the country to socialism without waiting for capitalism to develop, and pushed the ideas you ascribe to Marxism. In fact this, along with Lenins idea of "democratic centralism" that allowed for tighter control of the party was what drove the split between the Mensheviks and Bolsheviks - the former with the Socialist Revolutionaries believed that socialism in Russia required allowing a capitalist economy to develop first, in line with Marxist theory. Many of them were murdered or arrested for their opposition to the Bolshevik coup.
Deng's reforms were not really anything particularly new: Lenin was forced to accept the same realisation that a return to at least a limited market economy was necessary with New Economic Policy in 1921, after the strict collectivisation during the Russian civil war had harmed the economy substantially. However Stalin reversed most of NEP in the year after gaining power, and this approach was then largely shelved until Deng. But in both cases is what a bandaid to counter damage done by their attempt to policies on underdeveloped economies that they did not have the resources to make work [that does not mean their policies necessarily would work under any circumstances; but the point is that to have a chance at all required a much more developed economy].
- stcredzero 8y agoTranslation: If you're going to redistribute wealth, it helps a lot if you have the wealth in the first place. Marx argued already in The German Ideology (1845) that he saw an advanced capitalist economy with sufficient wealth that redistribution would eliminated poverty, rather than just spread it around, to be an essential precondition for a socialist revolution to succeed without devolving into renewed class struggle. Systems that create wealth are subject to Pareto distributions. However, relative inequality is the primary driver of social unrest. So a stable solution for societal organization needs to take both into account. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3XYHPAwBzE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3XYHPAwBzE
- antidesitter 8y ago> Deng's reforms were not really anything particularly new: Lenin was forced to accept the same realisation that a return to at least a limited market economy was necessary with New Economic Policy in 1921, after the strict collectivisation during the Russian civil war had harmed the economy substantially. Indeed Deng's reforms were influenced by the NEP, according to Pantsov and Levine in Deng Xiaoping: A Revolutionary Life: > It will be recalled that Deng Xiaoping himself had studied Marxism from the works of the Bolshevik leaders who had propounded NEP. He drew on ideas from NEP when he spoke of his own reforms. In 1985, he openly acknowledged that 'perhaps' the most correct model of socialism was the New Economic Policy of the USSR.