7 ms·
Hayekian communism
- WaxProlix 8y agoNot sure what part of China is supposed to be communist these days, except in name and maybe totalitarianism (if you take that to be a tenet of communism). As the author says, actual communist groups have been forcibly disbanded in universities and -- afaik -- nothing is really communally or democratically owned/controlled. Seems vastly more Hayek than Marx to me.
- stcredzero 8y agoNot sure what part of China is supposed to be communist these days There are parts of China where one can be pretty free in one's personal life, so long as one keeps their heads down and one isn't rich or famous. If one becomes rich or famous, one is inevitably drawn into politics, which can have high stakes consequences. Not sure what part of China is supposed to be communist these days, except in name and maybe totalitarianism Communism isn't what's bad about Communism. It's the resulting totalitarianism that's the bad part. If it were possible to and stable to reorganize the world into 450 person communes, there would be something utopian about that. It's very possible to seek out and find such communal experiences. The problem is that such organization isn't stable for Homo sapiens. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17433487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17433487 Here's what we know about democracy. It's short term stable, even when pitted against other forms of government. It often changes from within and becomes totalitarianism, however.
- WaxProlix 8y agoI don't think I disagree with anything you're saying, it just doesn't seem like what China is doing right now has much to do with the goals of communism. So the article seems weird to me. Obviously, given the downvotes, people disagree.
- viburnum 8y agoGreat article. What's happening in China is not so different than in the US and Europe, with management of the economy shifting from democratically elected leaders to central bankers, etc. Hayek was an enemy of democracy (just skim LLL if you don't believe me), so recent trends are in accord with his vision.
- sandov 8y agoYour conflating two unrelated issues: (1) Liking or disliking democracy (2) Liking or disliking certain policies that may be taken under democracy, or under an authoritarian regime. A country could democratically ban the use of cars, that doesn't mean that everyone who is against democracy loves using cars.
- stcredzero 8y agoA country could democratically ban the use of cars It depends on how this is done. If this is done in a way which tightens centralized control of the populace, then it could be quite anti-democratic.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoThat’s the only way it can be done. Otherwise, how do you enforce it?
- stcredzero 8y agoI doubt that any such blanket bans could be democratic. Banning cars from city centers could be. In times of crisis, cars become untenable in any case. A car can help guarantee your freedom in a crisis in a low population area. In a crisis in a city, it's often useless.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoWhat about plastic straws? :)
- JPKab 8y agoChina isn't communist. It's state capitalist, and on an economic level (NOT philosophically) much more similar to the German Fascist model where private enterprise is welcomed, but always subservient to the whims of the state, without limitation. If you disagree with this, then ask yourself if there is a court or any recourse in China for a private enterprise to challenge an action by the government. There isn't, and we all know it. In the US, when the government wants to block a merger, they have to do so in court, where they frequently lose (the recent TimeWarner/AT&T merger being a prime example).
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think the similarity with the Nazi economy is true. They were very technology and business friendly as long as companies stayed within certain limits.
- ethbro 8y agoFurthermore, the state co-oping capital sources and becoming both the primary financer and customer. In that environment, it's a logical business choice to do as the state requests. Ma's a smart man to get out.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThere's also this element of nationalism in China. The Nazis were national socialists, distinct from the communists, who were international ("workers of the world, unite").
- stcredzero 8y agoSo basically, they differ in how the tribal group allegiance is oriented. You will find that there is more nationalism forwarded by the Chinese government nowadays. It is claimed that National Socialism and Fascism aren't of the political left primarily because of the appeal to nationalism. The problem with this, is that historically, all totalitarian regimes eventually start appealing to national and ethnic group affiliation. The most useful political dimension isn't left <-> right. The most useful dimension is the one measuring individual freedom vs. totalitarianism. I remember a time when everyone other than a few select groups were tolerated, no matter how out there they were. Now the left is trying to expand the scope of their intolerance by normalizing the behaviors of intolerance and expanding the scope of labels.
- nabla9 8y agoThere is simple identifiable reason for the economic success of Chinese communist regime. It was Deng Xiaoping and the revolutionary but simple change he made to the standard Marxist thinking: > Socialism means eliminating poverty. Pauperism is not socialism, still less communism. [1] Traditionally Marxists justified the poor conditions in the socialist countries as necessary step on the road to full communism. Alternatively they blamed capitalists outside the country or some inside forces. Deng abandoned this excuse and introduced very pragmatic economic approach. Principles like "One country, two systems" or the cat's color theory: "It doesn't matter whether a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice." helped to push this idea trough. Basically Chinese first moved towards Socialist market economy with limits to private ownership, but the process has taken over and it's impossible to think that private ownership would be reduced again. I don't think that new generation of leaders really want to do that. They don't believe in communist ideology anymore. They want China be like Singapore or South Korea without the democracy part. [1]: Deng Xiaoping, BUILD SOCIALISM WITH CHINESE CHARACTERISTICS, June 30, 1984 http://academics.wellesley.edu/Polisci/wj/China/Deng/Building.htm http://academics.wellesley.edu/Polisci/wj/China/Deng/Buildin...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Traditionally Marxists justified the poor conditions in the socialist countries as necessary step on the road of communism “Leninists”, you mean. Marxists see advanced capitalism as a prerequisite to moving on to socialism as opposed to Leninists who try to bypass capitalism; the poor conditions of Leninist states (which aren't found in socialist systems more broadly) are a direct result of that.
- nabla9 8y agoNEP (New Economic Policy) was Lenin's idea. The NEP was abandoned in 1928 after Joseph Stalin took over.
- simias 8y agoIt's risky to make broad claims regarding Marxism (both for you and the parent), it's kind of a catch-all term these days, especially when "marxist" has been turned into an insult in large parts of the English speaking world and in particular in the USA. After all, even Karl Marx said he wasn't a Marxist. I think it's more interesting to consider the ideas and concepts themselves rather that coming up with a rather meaningless and probably misleading label.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoIsn't a key tenet of communism that workers own the means of production? That doesn't seem to be the case in China. Isn't a fundamental motivator or justification for moving towards communism a reduction in inequalities? That doesn't seem to be the case in China. China is certainly remarkable, but I think a more apt description is: authoritarian with market-oriented policies. I don't see much evidence for communism as originally envisioned. China's recent rise has largely been the story of a strong state enabling markets to function, but I wonder if the state's growing desire to involve itself in business will lead to sclerosis, similar to what happened in the Soviet Union under Stalin.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoChina's government isn't involved in business in anything like the way the USSR's was. China probably has some room before it hits those particular problems.
- beat 8y agoChina had/has different problems in different eras. At the beginning of modern communist China, the country suffered from incredible poverty. Most people could barely feed themselves. They had suffered pretty much nonstop war for over half a century - the Boxer Rebellion (against European colonial powers), the Japanese occupation, WWII, and civil war. I ran numbers on this a while back. Per capita GDP in China has increased 130 times since 1960, from ~$60/year to over $8000/year. With success like that, is focusing on inequality over that period the right approach? Would they be better off with hatchet axe and saw, as Rush put it? But today, the problems are different. Incredible growth leads to massive concentrations of power. It's not just the inequality, it's the ability to alter the system to favor those already in power, at the expense of everyone else. That's sort of America's problem today... the top is growing, but mostly by hoarding 100% (or more) of all economic growth, so none of the benefits reach the bottom 90%. China doesn't have that problem - yet.
- stretchwithme 8y agoThis isn't communism at all. They do oppress those who they think present a threat with the same savagery.
- amasad 8y agoHayek is best known for his book The Road to Serfdom which sounded the alarm on socialism/communism so... no! Hayek won't feel "right at home" in the surveillance state of China that's implementing 1984-esque "social score" and other policies that if not Serfdom I don't know what they are.
- beat 8y agoSocial scores are bad. Credit scores are good. I'm not exactly clear on the difference, but I'm sure it's very important.
- partiallypro 8y agoBecause social scores include thing like "thought crime" and can only be improved if you are behind the state...a credit score can be fixed through bankruptcy, and the US is arguably the easiest country to fix your credit score.
- sp332 8y agoDoesn't your credit score take a huge hit for 7 years after bankruptcy?
- partiallypro 8y agoIt can be used against your credit score for 10 years but your score can improve over that time frame and even be higher than it was before. I don't see how that's even remotely comparable than punishing thought crime against the ruling party. It creates a permanent political underclass for thinking wrong. I don't deny that there are people stuck in credit traps (usually because they are ignorant of bankruptcy law) but to compare it to a stack ranking of citizens based on their political stances is mindblowingly dumb.
- stale2002 8y agoThe only thing a credit score is, is a judge on your likelyhood to pay your bills. The social credit score, on the other hand, is a measure of society/government approval. And it effects your ability to get on trains. It seems fair that if you stop paying your bills, then people might not want to loan you money anymore. It does not seem fair that if you criticise the government, or are friends with people who criticize the government, that you won't be allowed to travel anymore.
- partiallypro 8y agoI'm starting to think many of you have never read Hayek in any serious manner, including the author. The mere existence of the Hayekian information problem, which is the core tenant of Hayek's ideology, refutes the fairly loose framing of what this post tries to convey.
- Apocryphon 8y agoProbably because Hayek is used here as a stand-in for "capitalist thinker." I suppose the author could have just swapped in Rand or von Mises just the same.
- gowld 8y agoIt's fascinating that, to draw crude boundaries, "conservative" thinking is pro-capitalist/free-markets, which is largely justified by the theory of distributed local knowledge, but also strongly in favor of centralized authority on social/moral/scientific/religious/artistic matters.
- rienbdj 8y agointeresting point; I'm not sure why you're banned.
- andrenth 8y agoThere is actually an interesting parallel between the idea of prices in a free market as information (distributed knowledge as you put it) and the conservative notion (originally from Burke I believe) of traditions as information (from one generation to the next). I don’t see conservatism as inherently advocating centralization in the matters you mentioned, just a desire of not throwing away hard-earned good things, due to the realization that they’re much harder to build than to destroy.
- dustinthewind 8y agoThanks, I've created the account just to say the same: the author never bothered to read Hayek. I imagine Hayek (as many other economists) would object to that by saying that the resource allocation under centralized rule is inferior to that of free market because of failure of central planner to account for individual preferences, which manifest themselves easier in a capitalist market. Now, whether we should optimize for individual preferences as opposed to some other common noble goal - e.g. building communism - is another question. But I think everyone would agree that central planning could lead to some excesses (collectivization, starving Ukrainian peasants to death, Chinese ghost towns come to mind). P.S. The author writes: "I thought ten percent was the normal growth rate of communist economies: why would you care to become communist if you would not grow faster than under capitalism?" Not sure if it's urban legend, but I remember reading how many Western observers were surprised by collapse of Soviet economy since communists always boasted high rates of GDP growth. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/14/opinion/columnists/great-recession-economy-gdp.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/14/opinion/columnists/great-... https://utopiayouarestandinginit.com/2015/01/24/paul-samuelsons-repeated-predictions-of-the-soviet-union-economy-catching-up-with-the-usa/ https://utopiayouarestandinginit.com/2015/01/24/paul-samuels...
- scythe 8y agoPaul Krugman provides a contrary perspective here: https://www.pairault.fr/documents/lecture3s2009.pdf https://www.pairault.fr/documents/lecture3s2009.pdf