3 ms·
Politically controversial yet completely legal things, like weapons parts, were not only banned on manufacturing, but as a logo on the subreddit[1]. Meanwhile,
by unethical_ban 8y ago
Politically controversial yet completely legal things, like weapons parts, were not only banned on manufacturing, but as a logo on the subreddit[1]. Meanwhile, a federally illegal, in different ways controversial activity such as marijuana consumption is permitted[2]. It's the right of the company, but there is certainly bias in the use of the logo, and not all fans of reddit are welcome.
1. https://imgur.com/a/bAOhi#tY6JS4l https://imgur.com/a/bAOhi#tY6JS4l
2. https://old.reddit.com/r/trees/ https://old.reddit.com/r/trees/
- jedberg 8y agoI kinda knew this would come up. The gun thing was my call. I'm the one who approved the use of the logo on a lower receiver. I consider it one of the worst decisions I ever made. Yes, it was legal, but it caused a huge controversy and made the controversy even worse when we had to pull it back. The balancing act with allowing fan art is that one group of fans hates the work of another group of fans, you have to make a moral decision as to which group is "right", and it's always the wrong decision to some people. In that case we should have predicted the controversy and said no from the beginning.
- VonGuard 8y agoDood, I back you entirely. I hate guns. There is no reason people should be defending them (They can defend themselves, they're guns!) It's a totally reasonable decision you made, but gun people, by their very nature, are trigger happy and defensive. Your ban on gun pictures hurt their feelings!
- ComputerGuru 8y agoIronically, your comment is needlessly antagonistic.
- Semaphor 8y agoI'd call it a case of Poe's Law because I can't tell if it's satire or not.
- unethical_ban 8y agoI hope this is a joke, because it unfairly stereotypes gun owners, and also because earlier posts talk about how terrible emergency LEO service is in Oakland. Next time a group of people break into your house to rob you with the willingness to kill to cover tracks, let me know how your gun free zone works out. I have aggressive streaks like many men, but in practice I am known as even handed, mediating and compromising among colleagues. I am a peacemaker. I also own almost a dozen firearms.
- zeveb 8y ago> … we had to pull it back. No, you didn't. The Right Thing™ to do would be to have simply told the complainers to carry on with their lives. There's no reason to give hecklers a veto.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's a lovely naive position to take when you aren't dealing with the fierce backlash of a vocal community. It was in fact that position I started from -- live and let live. What I learned is that you can't always take that position. Sometimes you have to take a moral stand, and that will necessarily be in opposition to some people's points of view (sometimes including your own point of view). But it's what you have to do when you're managing a community of users with differing opinions.
- moate 8y agoThe "throw your hands up in the air and blame it on the guy who actually made the offensive thing with your IP" approach has failed SO many times. I agree with you entirely, you're going to be making the morally wrong choice to someone no matter what you do. I think this is why so many people limit what can be done with their IP. Of course there's a double standard. That's how civil societies exist. People will always make equivalencies (false and fair) and get bent out of shape because of the contradicting choices on how each is handled.
- jlawson 8y agoSo whatever community can be the most "vocal" and generate the most "fierce backlash" gets to control the expression of everyone else. No principles, only power. This does seem to describe Internet culture, all right. It only happens because people in your position so often roll over in the face of pressure from any group who can make noise, even inconsequentially, even for a short time. And then you go and say you "can't" take the position of treating people evenhandedly. Yes you can. It may be challenging but you could've done it. You chose the easy path; don't act like you had no choice. Take responsibility for violating your principles. (I say this as someone who has faced such backlash on the Internet and succeeded. The sleepless night are real but once people realize you're not a pushover they move to easier targets.) EDIT: For an example of a major company having a spine in such a situation, consider Valve's recent decision not to be the taste police with regards to what goes on Steam.
- Karunamon 8y ago"Had to" pull it back? Well no, you chose to act - your hand wasn't forced. And saying no from the beginning is the same kind of picking and choosing when drug paraphernalia gets a pass. GP is completely correct in their read on the situation - there is a double standard.
- jedberg 8y agoIt was totally a double standard, I don't deny that. I tried to take the path of "no double standard", but that's not how real life works. Licensing fan art is a balancing act between being permissive and channeling the general consensus of your fans. That's why it's hard and a lot of companies don't do it.
- justtopost 8y agoSo allowing a logo on a gun was the problem (because of the backlash) and not the double standard? Telling.
- jedberg 8y agoYes. That's the issue with licensed fan art. The fans are in control, and if the fans are against you, you're stuck in a hard position.
- Spivak 8y agoI don't really consider it a double standard, every company with branding and has to choose their associations. Saying "we don't wish to have our branding associated with firearms because we don't like them" seems perfectly reasonable. When it's such a politically charged topic that even agreeing to host gun enthusiast communities is a political statement having officially licensed firearm decals is practically an endorsement. The fact that Reddit allows their branding to be associated with other things I don't think plays into it very much.
- pjc50 8y agoThanks for this posting, it's always good to see people looking back on their decisions and being willing to admit a mistake in public. To the other posters I would say it's not a "double" standard but a "standard"; there are some things that Reddit is happy to be associated with and some that it isn't.
- fhood 8y agoAgreed. The people in this thread don't seem to have any understanding of optics. You don't allow your brand on something that will be opposed by the majority of your users. It isn't about fairness or a double standard. It is about controlling perceptions of your brand, which you have every right to do.
- cybrjoe 8y agoThey weren't that unhappy to be associated with the community. They still cashed in their page views for advertising money. The double standard is treating the advertising revenue different from the licensing revenue on the same content.
- mjevans 8y agoI see this in a different light, perhaps because of a nuance. If I were to navigate to a sub-forum /on/ Reddit for a controversial topic it would not surprise me to see some Reddit IP involved in the theme/art; it's a recognition of the underlying platform and the context of the speech makes it feel more like the community using it is paying respect to the platform than the platform overtly supporting/endorsing that community. When you see the logo on actual items outside of that platform the context has shifted. Now it's a holster, tee-shirt, or something else that is advertising an association between the groups; maybe without even a contextual link to where the sub-forum is. The context changes the perception of what is being said even with the exact same work.
- Consultant32452 8y agoI'm very pro-gun but I think you made the right business decision. The only nit I have to pick is that you called the decision a moral one. In context it seems more like an economic one. I'm probably just being pedantic about language choice though.
- jedberg 8y agoThe choice was economic but it expresses a morality. So you’re right. :)
- unethical_ban 8y agoI respect your willingness to engage in conversation like you have here. I'm trying to remember there are humans on the other side of the keyboard. I really do think it is questionable to reject a community's use of an otherwise almost universally free logo, and permit them on the site. I'm one to recognize that in every discussion about everything, "there is a line somewhere" and the debate is where the line is. My belief is that guns are on a defendable side of the line, and you didn't. I believe if firearms are so morally wrong that reddit doesn't want associated with it, then it would be most consistent to quarantine the sub to make clear how morally opposed reddit is to legal, responsible firearms ownership. At the end of the day, though, it is about money. You figured out you could piss off the gun owners, but not enough for them to leave the platform, while placating the anti-firearms protesters. So it goes.
- alexc05 8y agoRemember that Reddit is also a website with a global footprint. Many other places in the world find the near constant mass shootings abhorrent, feel the US’ obsession with the AR-15 is an abusive relationship, and that the arguments around "guns = freedom" or any discussion of controls around weaponry defy all logic and reason. The USA is a very small part of the global population and are apparently only around 50% of the Reddit user base. For every user who feels Reddit should allow their logo to be associated with guns there are likely 2 or 3 who feel they have a moral obligation to not to promote them.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoSame here on HN, I sometimes have the feeling people think "It's English, so it's about the US".
- unethical_ban 8y agoI maintain that if reddit cared as much as the hypothetical majority of reddit users, so much as to revoke licensing of the logo for a US-legal activity, they would quarantine all subs that promote such "immoral" behavior. The reddit admins only care about staying out of the crosshairs. Let jailbait stay around until it's in the news. Let racist subs stay around until an uproar. Let /r/guns use Snoo until a bunch of activists yell long enough. There is no ideology, only pragmatism about keeping pageviews and revenue. They could quarantine /r/guns and related, but they would alienate 350,000 plus accounts. They could ban T_D too, but there are millions of users there. As an aside, I think that is a federal honeypot for Russian agitprop research, but we won't know for years. >and that the arguments around ... any discussion of controls around weaponry defy all logic and reason. I didn't parse that.