46 ms·
This tool is interesting but it is fundamentally an exercise in turd polishing because Reddit is a completely terrible place to get "expert" advice. It's desig
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
This tool is interesting but it is fundamentally an exercise in turd polishing because Reddit is a completely terrible place to get "expert" advice. It's designed to be a place for show and tell with commentary and false appearance of consensus.
If you want expert advice you should be asking for it somewhere that's properly formatted for long form discussion. You should also seek out advice in a specialized community, not a general one like Reddit. For every piece of good advice on Reddit there's ten pieces of terrible advice and ten pieces of mediocre advice you could find yourself on Google offered up by the riff-raff that happen to be passing through that day. Reddit is just polite 4chan. If you want expert advice to somewhere where only people who are interested in the topic you want advice on are (usually forums).
Edit: Also this tool thinks I am an expert in hipsters. I like to think I'm an expert in calling people hipsters.
- gepoch 8y agoCalling people hipsters is the most hipster thing of all. Source: am a hipster.
- fhood 8y agoI thought the most hipster thing was hating stuff that is popular.
- acconrad 8y agoIs anyone aware of a catalogue that houses all of the various forum domains? For example, if you want to seek fashion advice, probably better to head over to StyleForum instead of /r/malefashionadvice (or HypeBeast for streetwear). I know someone asked on here recently for investing forums and were pointed to Corner of Berkshire and Fairfax (as well as /r/securityanalysis) but that is indeed better than /r/investing or /r/wallstreetbets which are garbage.
- Balero 8y agoI think r/wallstreetbest is supposed to be garbage, but with lots of in jokes.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago/r/wallstreetbets is a bunch of intelligent investors pretending to be ignorant, and a bunch of ignorant investors pretending to be knowledgeable. I made a tidy profit off of someone's SPY options play they offered up as a post yesterday in /r/wsb, and they showed their work (proper due diligence on the why). It's not all fun and laughs in there.
- skinnymuch 8y ago/r/WSB is different in that it doesn’t try hiding what it is. Or pretending to be something. It’s supposed to be silly (understatement) and most things discussed are supposed to be [stupidly] high risk. You can’t compare that to most subreddits that take themselves seriously.
- jackpirate 8y ago/r/askhistorians is by far the best place on the internet to ask historians questions. But you're right that most other types of questions are better served by the *overflow communities or something else.
- fhood 8y agoSigh. Reddit is not a completely terrible place to get expert advice. Yes, there is a great deal of awful advice to be found there. But there are also a fair number of subreddits that are the primary gathering place for that community, and thus the best place to go for advice on that topic. When I google something non-programming related, the correct answer is very frequently found in a Reddit post. Reddit isn't usually the absolute best place for advice on a topic, but painting it as "completely terrible" seems like hyperbole to me.
- iamdave 8y agoBut there are also a fair number of subreddits that are the primary gathering place for that community, and thus the best place to go for advice on that topic. With absolutely no way to vet, verify or validate anyone who proclaims to be the expert they say they are outside of asking, and hoping what you get isn't a complete fabrication.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoCould you not generate an "expert score" by comparing expert candidates with open data sources for domain expertise?
- iamdave 8y agoThat's a really good question, the closest thing to this I think is the 'delta' feature on /r/changemyview. How do you see something like that operating in the reddit ecosystem?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou'd essentially build up a reputation score for Reddit users based on their post history, but this would assume you have some programatic method to verify their expertise between domain knowledge data sources and their comments. I would assume only someone like Facebook would have have the resources to accomplish such as task, as they own the platform, and are actively working to discriminate fact from fiction in user posts.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoAnecdata: I searched for "embedded" and found this guy who writes a lot of really great content that seems to go unnoticed: https://www.reddit.com/user/pinealservo https://www.reddit.com/user/pinealservo