2 ms·
Back in the day, early on in Reddit's life, people started making fan art of the Reddit alien, and some cases they started making products with their creations
by jedberg 8y ago
Back in the day, early on in Reddit's life, people started making fan art of the Reddit alien, and some cases they started making products with their creations and then giving them away. We pretty much just let that go. Then someone started selling their products with their fan art, just to make their costs back. At that point we had a decision to make. Do we shut down all the fan art, or do we do something about it?
The decision we came to was that our fans are what make us, so we asked our lawyers to write up a licensing agreement for us that we could use with all the fans. It included provisions for profit sharing so that people could even make a profit off their fan art, as long as they cut us in for a small percentage and got our permission first. And that's how we ended up things like a complete reddit bike kit. [0][1]
After that, it was easier for us to license stuff than it was to try and shut it down, not to mention the right thing to do. I'm sad that CBS couldn't come to the same conclusion.
[0] http://i.imgur.com/AEPJh.jpg http://i.imgur.com/AEPJh.jpg
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/bicycling/comments/2je6z2/2015_reddit_kit_start_your_design_engines/ https://www.reddit.com/r/bicycling/comments/2je6z2/2015_redd...
- unethical_ban 8y agoPolitically controversial yet completely legal things, like weapons parts, were not only banned on manufacturing, but as a logo on the subreddit[1]. Meanwhile, a federally illegal, in different ways controversial activity such as marijuana consumption is permitted[2]. It's the right of the company, but there is certainly bias in the use of the logo, and not all fans of reddit are welcome. 1. https://imgur.com/a/bAOhi#tY6JS4l https://imgur.com/a/bAOhi#tY6JS4l 2. https://old.reddit.com/r/trees/ https://old.reddit.com/r/trees/
- jedberg 8y agoI kinda knew this would come up. The gun thing was my call. I'm the one who approved the use of the logo on a lower receiver. I consider it one of the worst decisions I ever made. Yes, it was legal, but it caused a huge controversy and made the controversy even worse when we had to pull it back. The balancing act with allowing fan art is that one group of fans hates the work of another group of fans, you have to make a moral decision as to which group is "right", and it's always the wrong decision to some people. In that case we should have predicted the controversy and said no from the beginning.
- VonGuard 8y agoDood, I back you entirely. I hate guns. There is no reason people should be defending them (They can defend themselves, they're guns!) It's a totally reasonable decision you made, but gun people, by their very nature, are trigger happy and defensive. Your ban on gun pictures hurt their feelings!
- ComputerGuru 8y agoIronically, your comment is needlessly antagonistic.
- Semaphor 8y agoI'd call it a case of Poe's Law because I can't tell if it's satire or not.
- unethical_ban 8y agoI hope this is a joke, because it unfairly stereotypes gun owners, and also because earlier posts talk about how terrible emergency LEO service is in Oakland. Next time a group of people break into your house to rob you with the willingness to kill to cover tracks, let me know how your gun free zone works out. I have aggressive streaks like many men, but in practice I am known as even handed, mediating and compromising among colleagues. I am a peacemaker. I also own almost a dozen firearms.
- zeveb 8y ago> … we had to pull it back. No, you didn't. The Right Thing™ to do would be to have simply told the complainers to carry on with their lives. There's no reason to give hecklers a veto.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's a lovely naive position to take when you aren't dealing with the fierce backlash of a vocal community. It was in fact that position I started from -- live and let live. What I learned is that you can't always take that position. Sometimes you have to take a moral stand, and that will necessarily be in opposition to some people's points of view (sometimes including your own point of view). But it's what you have to do when you're managing a community of users with differing opinions.
- sargun 8y agoHow did you prevent your brand-oriented website from accidentally ruining itself? I can imagine that without doing a ton of due diligence, you could end up licensing your Alien to someone who sold lead-painted bikes, or something similarly horrifying.
- jedberg 8y agoIt wasn't easy and it was a big risk. Sometimes things didn't go well. We did diligence on all the products -- everyone was required to send a sample to us before we granted a license (which is why the reddit office was filled with fan art, nice bonus!). We did diligence into their previous expertise in manufacturing and who their vendors were. Sometimes we even hooked them up with vendors we knew were good if they just had an idea and didn't know where to go to make it happen. One thing I did was create a public "alien design standards" document that described the correct proportions and colors for the logo, which had to be followed. But yeah, it was a risk. But it was less risky than ignoring it, and far easier to do the diligence than it was to C&D everyone (I think, I don't know since we didn't C&D people).