3 ms·
> What problems are these app stores supposed to fix? You've completely missed the point. The feature isn't an app store. It's browser based applications you
by jasonlotito 16y ago
> What problems are these app stores supposed to fix?
You've completely missed the point. The feature isn't an app store. It's browser based applications you can download and install on your computer, and run locally. The browser is merely the engine the runs the application. They'll probably remove the chrome, and instead of acting like a browser and a web page, it will merely be the application.
- wesley 16y agoSo, removal of a toolbar and a quick launch icon is all this is? Woweee if so.. (web apps can already run locally if programmed to do so)
- jasonlotito 16y agoNo. You aren't even trying to read, or understand.
- asnyder 16y agoIt's probably because the point makes no sense. There's no reason to go back to desktop apps, we were moving away from that and making lots of progress and now all of a sudden many are eager to return back to local desktop, but this time running inside a browser, doesn't make any sense at all. We should be moving forward, rather than going backwards.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> It's probably because the point makes no sense. There's no reason to go back to desktop apps Yes, there is. Being able to install a web app locally means several things immediately: 1. Local and remote storage of data beyond what traditional web apps can accomplish. 2. Snappier applications, since everything is stored locally. 3. You'll still be capable of being connected remotely. 4. Ability to use the app even if you aren't connected, or cannot connect remotely. Also, you assert that we were moving away from desktop apps, when the opposite is true. Native apps are still insanely popular thanks to mobile devices. Even on an iOS device, you can run web apps as if they are local applications. It's incredibly useful here as well. Being able to install an application on your phone outside the App Store.
- boucher 16y agoTo be fair, very little of what's proposed in this project changes any of those points. You can already store data locally using localStorage APIs. You can already cache application content/scripts/resources locally using HTML Manifest files, which also let you use the application when you aren't connected to the net. And of course, you can always access remote resources when you are (even across domains using the new Cross Domain XHR technology). The crux of what they are proposing is a standard way to actually say "I want this web site to be considered an 'app' that can be installed using whatever your platform wants to consider installing". In other words, a slightly more enhanced, standard version of adding an app to your homescreen on the iPhone.
- jasonlotito 16y agoLocal storage is currently limited. On the desktop there will be means for unlimited storage. Manifest files can present more than merely what file to download (such as operating in the background). By setting the apps to a different domain, it gives them room to allow for a different permission set.
- DjDarkman 16y agoIf it would become unlimited than nothing would stop my web app from filling your hard drive up with crap. So removing this limit maybe not such a good idea. Besides if Mozilla wanted to provide unlimited storage they could just remove the limit from the HTML5 storage, but they won't for the reason I already wrote.
- jasonlotito 16y agoIt's the same as any other application you install. What stops any application from filling up your hard drive with crap?
- DjDarkman 16y ago> 1. Local and remote storage of data beyond what traditional web apps can accomplish. We already have HTML5 for that, why would we need yet another method for the same thing? > 2. Snappier applications, since everything is stored locally. Again... this is all possible with HTML5. > 3. You'll still be capable of being connected remotely. 4. Ability to use the app even if you aren't connected, or cannot connect remotely. ...HTML5 or Google Gears maybe. > Also, you assert that we were moving away from desktop apps, when the opposite is true. Show me a recent native app that has the success rate of Facebook or Twitter. A lot of native apps are just interfaces to web apps. > Even on an iOS device, you can run web apps as if they are local applications. With bookmarking them and making the app use HTML5 app cache. > Being able to install an application on your phone outside the App Store. install = bookmark Ohhh and let's not forget the "native" applications that in reality wrapped web apps.
- BerislavLopac 16y agoYou're making a crucial mistake of assuming that the Web apps are the forward. Not to mention that you're forgetting that Web apps are not possible without at least one desktop app.
- DjDarkman 16y agoWhat are the problems with current web apps that this tries to address? Let's say I have a web app, how will this make my life easier?