3 ms·
In addition to the specifically anti-union views mentioned in other posts, I think the biggest problem in the US is simply an apathy towards the goals/purpose o
by mreome 8y ago
In addition to the specifically anti-union views mentioned in other posts, I think the biggest problem in the US is simply an apathy towards the goals/purpose of a Union, caused by sociopolitical views. If I was to tell someone that I’m dealing with poor working conditions at a Job, almost nobody I know would suggest that I organize with other workers to demand improvements. They would tell me to find a new job, or if the issues were egregious enough, sue.
There is a general sentiment in the US that bettering one’s situation comes not from improving the situation, but by changing it. If you’re work conditions are terrible, find a new job. If your whole industry is terrible, learn new skills and move to a new industry. If you don’t want to be an exploited worker, become management. I think this is due to the strong expectation of the self-regulation of employment in a free market. But the cost and risk of changing your situation, combined with industries management collectively working together, and the near monopolistic size of some companies, makes such self-regulation unlikely in many industries/fields.
This is part of an even larger social class issues where the goal for most people isn’t to improve the conditions for their class, but to get them selves into a higher-class. This ends up pitting everyone against each other in a way that makes organization and collective bargaining very difficult.
“… the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires” -- Ronald Wright/John Steinbeck
- philwelch 8y agoIf you compare class consciousness between the US and UK, this is bigger than just unions. Britons, from an American perspective, have a mental block that prevents them from even considering the possibility of social mobility, while Americans, from a British perspective, have an irrational faith that social mobility will happen to them. The difference in attitudes isn't altogether surprising. America was settled by people who left situations they were unsatisfied with instead of staying and trying to fix them; that's why they came to America in the first place. Europe was left with the people who decided to stay home and either resign themselves to the situation or try and change things from the inside. Find a new career? Start a new company? Americans are the descendants of people who found a new continent and started their own country. Of course we're not going to see ourselves as held serfs and agitate for better treatment.