7 ms·
Ah right, "following the laws", because discussions of morality can be reduced to whether it "follows the law" or not? No, that's absurd. Google is objectively
by andrepd 8y ago
Ah right, "following the laws", because discussions of morality can be reduced to whether it "follows the law" or not? No, that's absurd. Google is objectively abetting an authoritarian regime and providing it with extremely useful tools to maintain and strengthen totalitarian control over 1.4 billion people, and this is wrong.
- Aunche 8y agoObjectively, Google is extending its services to a billion people while maintaining the status quo of censorship. Stopping Google from expanding to China is basically another form of censorship, which is wrong.
- 2bitmachine 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_equivalence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_equivalence
- kodablah 8y agoThese are also common arguments against country-level sanctions as well. People have differing opinions on the subject, but that something helps both the people and the regime doesn't always mean taking the good with the bad is worth it. I agree that both Google cooperating w/ China is wrong and that government interference to prevent it is wrong.
- jonathankoren 8y agoIt’s not obviously wrong, nor is it objectively the same product since the censorship and surveillance makes it very different. It makes it a tool of control. Governments routinely regulate exports as matter of policy. Lockheed would very much like to sell Taiwan (or really anyone and everyone) F-35s, but as a matter of government policy, it’s not allowed to, as it runs counter to the policies of the American government. This maybe censorship in a broad sense, but it certainly doesn’t make it prima facie wrong.
- cryoshon 8y agotaking initiative to participate in maintaining a malicious status quo is being malicious. google isn't being coerced here, they're volunteering to help with oppression. put differently: what do you call an accountant who sings up to perpetuate the status quo of a criminal enterprise by updating their books? guilty. but they were "just extending the services of accounting to a new organization while maintaining the status quo of criminality".
- Aunche 8y ago> what do you call an accountant who sings up to perpetuate the status quo of a criminal enterprise by updating their books? The difference is that the accountant is necessary for the criminal enterprise. Google isn't necessary for a censorship state, since China more than capable of handling that on their own. A closer analogy is that Google is the line cook of the restaurant the mafia hangs out in.
- billfruit 8y agoUS and Canada sell weapons and military equipment to Saudi Arabia. Sufficient moral outrage is hardly bandied about in the case of such deals.
- andrei_says_ 8y agoIt amplifies censorship and creates and provides the tools for censorship, which tools will become available as a (hidden) switch everywhere else, including here.
- femiagbabiaka 8y agoCorporations aren't people and regulation isn't censorship.
- 794CD01 8y agoNot everyone thinks authoritarianism is morally wrong. They already abet plenty of other things that some people find morally wrong, like enforcing IP law, censoring all kinds of information, cooperating with police investigations, etc, some of which you can already spin as authoritarian.
- bogomipz 8y ago>"Not everyone thinks authoritarianism is morally wrong" The people who don't find authoritarianism morally wrong are generally elites who enjoy privilege on account of their being ranking members of that authoritarian regime. Can you provide any examples of a 21st century authoritarian regimes where this hasn't been true? Mugabe? Bouteflika? Quaddafi? Assad? I don't think so.
- slavik81 8y agoRodrigo Duterte. Strongmen often enjoy broad popular support. They get things done. Mussolini made the trains run on time. A cult of personality is how an authoritarian leader defends themselves from being overthrown by other members of their regime. They ensure that they are associated with all the good that their government does, while deflecting blame for the bad towards scapegoats. Worrying about fairness or the rule of law is a luxury. A lot of people just see a weak and ineffectual government replaced with one that actually does something for them and they don't care how it was achieved. I wish you were right. It would be much easier to defend against authoritarians if they were unpopular.
- bogomipz 8y agoDuterte was democratically elected. He will be stepping down in 2022 and has already been voicing his support for Ferdinand Marcos Jr. >"Strongmen often enjoy broad popular support." "Strongman" is not even a real political term its a media term invented in the US media and first applied to General Noriega of Panama. The term doesn't even necessarily apply to official the head of state as was the case with Noriega. >"Mussolini made the trains run on time." No this is not actually true. See: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/loco-motive/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/loco-motive/ And my question was regarding authoritarian regimes of the 21st century. The rise of Mussolini was very much tied the consequences of World War 1 on Italy.
- oconnor663 8y agoLook, my biases are much more in favor of the US govt than of China's, for all the obvious reasons. But we have to be able to see that this is opening a huge can of worms. For example, I think it's pretty troubling that the French government banned a bunch of Muslim religious garments. Does that mean I should advocate that various US companies need to stop doing business with France? Clearly there's _some_ level of abuse that would be too much. But I think setting objectively standards about these things is extremely difficult.
- colanderman 8y agoIf those companies were making special tools to identify and remove said garments, then yes.
- oconnor663 8y agoThat sounds like a hard line to draw. A tool that makes it easier to look at lots of footage, which happens to get used for garment enforcement, is that a "garment related tool"? How do we factor in the French government's intention to build its own garment related tools on top of a camera's general purpose interfaces? What if the camera company itself is in France, but it's _suppliers_ are in the US? My goal here isn't just to be annoying and nitpicky. It's to try to make it clear that there are a million different questions interacting here.
- xg15 8y agoHmm, what's worse, a single populist regulation, punishable by a moderate fine or total information control? Very hard to draw a line indeed...
- oconnor663 8y agoI think you just put words in my mouth, which is difficult to respond to on the internet. Of course I agree with you about which is worse. Have you thought about how I can both agree with you and also believe that drawing the line is hard?
- test001only 8y agoBecause government making decision based on morality is slippery slope as morality is very subjective and varies with people, race and religion. Also is not Republican the party which advocates small government?
- briandear 8y agoConservatism is about small government and while Republicans and conservatives overlap, they aren’t the same thing. It’s kind of how Socialists tend to vote Democrat, but that doesn’t mean that Democrats act consistently with socialism. But I agree, government forcing a company to do something isn’t particularly in line with Republican ideas and it’s hypocritical in the context of limited government.
- merpnderp 8y agoWe force corporations to do things all the time. Like the US is at a serious disadvantage in countries which use bribery to make corporate decisions, allow slave labor, or murder to coerce uncooperative locals. Conservatives are fine with this level of coercion, aka the rule of law.
- matt4077 8y agoIt's worth mentioning that "slippery slope" was originally meant as a fallacy, i. e. the invalid argument that something good is nonetheless bad when extrapolating to some extreme version of it. It's easiest to see how useless the "slippery slope" concept is when noticing that it can be applied to absolute everything: "if I start by feeding my own kids, I will soon have every needy kid at my door, asking for food" "If we start to expect politicians not to be murders, a parking ticket will soon be disqualifying" etc. etc. Specifically here: government makes decisions based on morality all the time. I'd argue every single decision by the executive, legislative, and judicial branch is based on morality. It's obvious for the criminal justice system. For everything else, like deciding between different uses of tax money (aircraft carrier or social housing), making decisions requires some sort of function to optimize, and that function can ultimately only rest on morality.
- int_19h 8y agoNotions like "free speech is good" are themselves based on morality, and highly subjective. Yet we have them written not just into laws, but into our very Constitution.
- chocolatebunny 8y agoWhat do you think Google or any other company should do when it is handed national security letters in the USA?
- mulmen 8y agoI'm not going to defend what Google is doing. Having said that you should be very careful when asking corporations to enforce any kind of morality. The electorate defines our morality through government. Companies should play no part in this definition outside of the rights of their employees as private citizens. You should also be very careful when imposing your own personal views on people living in an entirely different country. Our (western) moral superiority is something we have justified to ourselves many times and it has rarely worked out in our favor.
- ehsankia 8y ago+1 It's not Google's job to go to every government in the world and tell them how they should run their country.
- Spooky23 8y agoGlobalism is messy. The west, particularly the US made a policy decision years ago that engaging with China commercially would yield benefits to China, the US, and the world. Arguably that was correct, although the predictions that making money would create a democratic society proved to be inaccurate. If you wear men's undershirts, you're objectively abetting an authoritarian regime that allows companies in Bangladesh to systematically abuse textile workers. Is that ok? At the end of the day, the Chinese have nukes and will do whatever they want to do. Why should Google suffer, when nothing is preventing Chinese services from launching in the US and competing with their properties?
- s73v3r_ 8y ago" Why should Google suffer" 1. I reject any notion that Google is somehow "suffering" if they don't go into China. 2. You're making it seem like Google is entitled to all the business it wants. That's not true in the least.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hazz99 8y ago2. You're making it seem like Google is entitled to all the business it wants. That's not true in the least. Why not?
- earenndil 8y ago'Why not?' is never the right question to ask. The onus is on you to support a claim, you cannot demand of the other person to prove a negative.
- hazz99 8y agoDidn't they propose that "Google is not entitled to all the business it wants" without justification? I'm prodding for them to support the claim, because (as you said) the onus is on them.