4 ms·
I have no idea how you come to this conclusion, but it is very very wrong. It only vaguely makes sense if you believe that there can only be one cause for some
by dasil003 16y ago
I have no idea how you come to this conclusion, but it is very very wrong. It only vaguely makes sense if you believe that there can only be one cause for something. However, clearly there are multiple factors at play.
I actually had two chemistry teachers in high school who fit this description. The first was a drunk that they hired off the street (seriously, the administration not believe us until we found an empty whiskey bottle in the back cupboard). They replaced her the second quarter with a flighty woman who didn't understand the material and regularly lost our assignments and tests; some time after they fired her I saw an article in the variety section of the local paper showing her in her home, back to the camera, with her hands on her hips staring at the massive pile of junk in her house—it was an article about ADHD adult packrats. For the final quarter they put us in a real chemistry teacher's class, where none of us were at all prepared having learning nothing for the first 2/3rds of the year, and they had to just give us the credit for the year.
The point of this anecdote is that there were plenty of smart, motivated students in this class, but the teachers made it impossible to learn, so the performance of everyone was equalized to the lowest common denominator. The only people who learned anything were the ones willing to read the book for its own sake without any guarantee of proper labs or tests. The next year I got into the physics class of a teacher who was widely regarded as the best in the school. We learned a lot in that class, but even there you had problem kids who refused to make any effort, despite the fact that the teacher clearly cared about the students; they saw him as someone to be taken advantage of.
So you see, neither factor stands alone. You need decent teachers, and you need kids to show up.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoMy statement was a conditional one, as you can see from the words "If this is true". You can disagree with the hypothesis this is based on, but that does not invalidate the conditional conclusion. ZachPruckowski and RyanMcGreal seem to be claiming that variation in teaching methods has little effect on achievement, and demographics/non-school factors seem to be the major cause of variations in achievement. If teaching is not a major cause of achievement, we should not waste time and money on it. Similarly, we should not waste time and money on shark repelling sticks or homeopathy. But I should point out that the anecdote you repeat seems to imply that teachers don't have a particularly large effect on achievement. As you say, "even there you had problem kids who refused to make any effort" and you had "the ones willing to read the book for its own sake". The teacher won't help either of these categories of student very much. Supposing, for the sake of argument, that these two types of students make up 2/3 of the class, and a good teacher can improve the grades of receptive students by 20% over a crappy one, then teacher quality only accounts for 6% of the achievement of the class.
- dasil003 16y agoDid you even read what I wrote? This response is an utter reading comprehension failure from the beginning to the end. Seriously, this is maybe the worst response I have ever got on HN.
- ZachPruckowski 16y agoTeachers can definitely have a large impact. But students spend 80% of their time outside the school. You could have the best teacher on the planet, but if they're not getting reinforcement from outside the system, there's not a lot you can do. If three wheels have their brakes stuck, it doesn't really matter how fast the fourth is turning, you're not going anywhere. It's not that we shouldn't work on our schools, but we have to approach raising children holistically - it's not enough to have them in school for 6 hours a day for half the year, we need parents to be involved and we need to make sure those kids are getting a basic level of stability outside of school. Then there's the Hierarchy of Needs issue. Before you can really learn and grow and develop, you have to fulfill your basic needs. If you're starving, then the only fractions you're able to focus on are fractions of a sandwich.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIf three wheels have their brakes stuck, I turn the car off. I'm not going anywhere and I might as well save gas. By the way, no one in America (besides anorexic rich girls) is starving. Gluttony is the only food-related problem faced by the poor, starvation hasn't existed for a while.
- ZachPruckowski 16y ago>If three wheels have their brakes stuck, I turn the car off. I'm not going anywhere and I might as well save gas. So you're suggesting we abandon schooling altogether, and just let all those kids wander around unable to read? >Gluttony is the only food-related problem faced by the poor, starvation hasn't existed for a while. Would it were so.
- ExcilSploft 16y ago