7 ms·
Won’t change my mind and will stick to Firefox after having switched because of this. First I don’t want to be logged in in my browser at all. Second, and proba
by cm2187 8y ago
Won’t change my mind and will stick to Firefox after having switched because of this. First I don’t want to be logged in in my browser at all. Second, and probably more important, software is about trust. Even for an open source project, no one has the time to review millions of lines of code. So unfortunately one has to rely on what one believes is the behavior of the authors of the software. And what google did is to shatter that trust by sneaking that change discretely.
- nsmith14 8y ago>And what google did is to shatter that trust by sneaking that change discretely. How did you expect them to announce a change they probably perceive as a minor UX improvement? Also this has been brewing for months in canary/beta, it's not like they actually snuck the change as you imply.
- grey-area 8y agoHow did you expect them to announce a change they probably perceive as a minor UX improvement? Just because you split a large change into a set of minor UX improvements and have different excuses for each individual change, that doesn't make the direction of travel any less damaging. To be clear, the direction of travel is for Google to abuse their de-facto monopoly on search and browsers to own SSO across the web and track their users completely, at which point they will pretty much own your entire web experience (logins, browser history, maps, news, search, tracking, analytics - all this data will form a huge moat making it hard to compete and hard to resist decisions made by google about the web) - even if you don't use them they'll own the experience of the majority of your customers. This is why these small changes are so pernicious, and why people have reacted badly to them. This is why people reacted so badly to AMP. This is not an argument over technicalities or quibbles over UX, this is a fundamental question of who owns the web. Google have built up a lot of trust over the years by keeping the browser independent of their other operations, and making great technical progress with Chrome, but these changes (and others like starting to abuse their search monopoly by privileging certain google results) show that is not going to last - they are now at the monetising phase of their lifecycle, and nothing can stop it - a huge corporation has a momentum of its own.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wbl 8y agoThe competition to their products is a click away. People use google products because they find them more useful. If that's a result of the data they have, who cares?
- mirko22 8y agoIt’s not the result of data they have but the other way around.
- wbl 8y agoSo because they make more useful products people give them data as opposed to money?
- grey-area 8y agoPeople use google products because they find them more useful No - because they are free, ubiquitous, and often installed by default. People choose their browser as they would choose a hat, from the limited selection available.
- TekMol 8y agoI don’t want to be logged in in my browser at all Same here. Why does Chrome log you in in the first place? I mean I know it from the companies perspective of course. They want to consolidate as much data about you as possible. And tie you into their ecosystem. But what is the user facing benefit? Syncing your bookmarks across devices?
- RossM 8y ago> But what is the user facing benefit? Syncing bookmarks, recently opened tabs, passwords, autofill(?). These are genuine benefits when you're working with laptops, desktops, phones and tablets. Whether they're worth the cost of data mining is another matter of course.
- TekMol 8y agoThese are genuine benefits when you're working with laptops, desktops, phones and tablets. I work with all of these devices. Yet I don't want any of that syncing. The thought that Google wants to send my 'recently opened tabs' to their servers makes me shudder. So they get the whole browsing history of every one of their users? Of all the pages that have nothing to do with them? Same with passwords. So they have a gigantic database with all of their users passwords for all the services the users use? Even those totally unrelated to Google?
- r3bl 8y agoOne advantage that wasn't mentioned is the ability to send a tab between devices. I'm looking at something on my desktop, have to go somewhere, so I just send the tabs to my phone and continue consuming. If I forget to do so, I can also use the url bar to search through common history, so that I could enter a few words from the title and go back to that article. That being said, I personally wouldn't trust Google to do this, so I use Firefox that I believe encrypts data client-side by default.
- acct1771 8y ago
- lwhi 8y agoI do think Google has turned a corner recently. They've achieved so much ubiquity, that their offerings are becoming incompatible with an open web.
- StanAngeloff 8y agoThis same change to Google Chrome forced me to go to Firefox, too. After about a week of pain, I'm now much more comfortable about my choice. I do have a Firefox account which syncs up my passwords, history, etc. so in a sense I'm still logged into the browser. I do trust Mozilla more than I do Google with my personal data, though.
- nailer 8y agoMozilla don't have access to your data even with Sync turned on! They've confirmed it multiple times this week. One more reason to go with Firefox.
- crummy 8y agowhy do we trust them when they say this, when we don't trust google when they say it?
- nailer 8y agoHave Google said they can't see your data when syncing?
- Hendrikto 8y agoBecause collecting user information is Google’s main business.
- commoner 8y agoData in Firefox Sync is end-to-end encrypted, while data synced to Chrome is subject to Google's privacy policy. "The security model of Firefox Sync ensures that your sync data is encrypted before it ever leaves your machine, and that the password to unlock this encryption is never transmitted to the server. Not even Mozilla can access your sync data, so while we transmit it all over TLS for additional security, we do not depend on the confidentiality of TLS to keep your data safe." https://medium.com/mozilla-tech/how-firefox-sync-keeps-your-secrets-if-tls-fails-14420d45885c https://medium.com/mozilla-tech/how-firefox-sync-keeps-your-... "When you sync Chrome with your Google Account, we use your browsing data to improve and personalize your experience within Chrome. You can also personalize your experience on other Google products, by allowing your Chrome history to be included in your Google Web & App Activity." https://www.google.com/chrome/privacy/ https://www.google.com/chrome/privacy/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- evrydayhustling 8y agoYes, opt-in is the beginning, middle and end of the problem here. Google has plenty of tools to inform users of these capabilities and allow them to turn them on or off. I wouldn't even mind if they nagged me a couple of times with a pop-up about browser log in, or a confirmation that I want to keep or delete Google cookies. But on-by-default features have a special responsibility to be conservative with a user's privacy. I actually value and use sync. Google sees most of by browsing through page-hosted GA anyway! But at best, this was really lazy product management that smacks of condescension about less technical users (don't worry your head about these cookies). And at worst, it's testing the waters on some really nefarious strategies.
- x0re4x 8y agoWell, putting: { "SyncDisabled": true } into /etc/chromium/policies/managed/test_policy.json (for debian linux) seems to do the trick for now, unsure how long it lasts... see: https://www.chromium.org/administrators/policy-list-3#SyncDisabled https://www.chromium.org/administrators/policy-list-3#SyncDi...
- mda 8y agoOh please It wasn't done discreetly at all. This whole Google.. tracking mining profiling evil omg omg hysteria has became really comical TBH.
- bla2 8y agoI don't understand what "because of this" means. Chrome made some change that some famous blogger misunderstood, and everyone got up in arms over nothing -- https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/gyny83/google-chrome-sync-privacy https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/gyny83/google-chr... Given that, their reaction on their blog seems above and beyond to me. Edit: Downvoters, reply with how this is incorrect instead of downvoting.
- notyourday 8y agoGoogle pays the salaries of every tech person whose opinion it values at a rate of > $0.00.
- cbolton 8y agoFirst I don't want to be logged in in my browser at all. OK but I expect that most Chrome users feel different about that. Most are probably happy that this UI change makes things less confusing. Second, and probably more important, software is about trust. [...] And what google did is to shatter that trust by sneaking that change discretely. Why did the UI change shatter trust for you? It doesn't enable syncing so I don't see what the big deal is. With syncing out of the equation, I can imagine that you don't like being logged in in the browser for aesthetic reasons or something, but to have one's trust shattered?