7 ms·
The Myth of Charter Schools
- Poiesis 16y agoNot sure if this is a terribly relevant article, but I'll note that we actually homeschool throughout a charter school with minimal oversight. What this means is that we're enrolled in the school, they send a teacher out every week to evaluate progress, we do the teaching, and--critically--we get hundreds of dollars a year to use on curriculum. If it weren't for the last point we'd just do it alone; it's solely for the money that we stay in the school.
- jimwise 16y agoThis seems central to Ravitch's argument: ``For many people, these arguments require a willing suspension of disbelief. Most Americans graduated from public schools, and most went from school to college or the workplace without thinking that their school had limited their life chances.'' In other words, her argument seems at least in part based on the assumption that the public schools of today are equivalent in quality with the public schools in which most adults today were themselves educated. It's not clear to me that this is correct...
- kiba 16y agoI thought education can have so much more potential. If we so desire, there could be a genuine basic electrical engineering classes where kids are taught to assemble their own electronics, build robots, amongst other things. What we got though, is the uninspired math class, the boring basic computer class, reading plays that are meant to be played out, and so on. However, formal education must use a metric of some kind. A way to say a neat number. The penchants for mechanization where teachers are taught to "teach", not learn and teach, are widespread. Why don't we have industry professional, scientists, and so on, work with the teacher directly? Doesn't it alway seem to you that educations are in general, just mediocre. The IQ of kids are more than enough to handle complex ideas. We don't try very hard, but those who try are more likely to be successful, and seemly much more knowledgeable.
- andrewce 16y agoThis might not be a correct assumption, but the difficult part about it is defining "quality", and should there be a difference, identifying the culprit. I suspect that the "back to the basics" ethos of NCLB has done more harm than good (it's amazing how quickly children learn to read when they're read to every day, rather than the current method which seems to involve lots of phonics instruction in spite of English's phonetic weirdness). This is the same "back to the basics" ethos that was promoted shortly after Sputnik was launched, and the same ethos that was promoted after "A Nation at Risk" was published. And when that ethos doesn't work, we generally pile even more on it. "Chidren not performing well enough at math? We'll do 2 hours instead of 1! We'll cut recess!" I don't think I'm disagreeing with you here, but the only successful attempts I've seen to "improve education" have been the ones that offer more engagement and more freedom, with higher expectations placed on students (as well as a willingness to work around student learning, rather than forcing student learning to work around a pre-determined progress chart). Everything else has been ham-handed, at best.
- ZachPruckowski 16y agoThat's not central to the argument at all. The article's first argument is "only 17% of charter schools out-perform matched public schools, so it's unrealistic to expect them to be a silver bullet". The schools in "Waiting for 'Superman'" are the rare few that are getting exceptional results. Yes, we as a country would be smarter if every public school was a charter school with exceptional results, but that's like saying we'd be smarter if every public college was replaced with Harvard or MIT. And that's just the first argument. Then it breaks into several more about non-school factors being responsible for the majority of achievement variance among students, and about charter school selection effects[1], as well as a lot of discussion of relevant omissions and factual errors in the movie. I'm not saying I agree absolutely with the article (I haven't seen WfS yet), but if you're dismissing it based on a fact-free first impression of a throw-away line halfway through it, you're doing yourself a disservice. [1] - Since only students with parents who are deeply involved in their education even apply to charter schools, those students are at an inherent advantage whether or not they get in.
- klenwell 16y agoI thought that claim was weakly stated. She backs it up more convincingly with this point: "The annual Gallup poll about education shows that Americans are overwhelmingly dissatisfied with the quality of the nation’s schools, but 77 percent of public school parents award their own child’s public school a grade of A or B, the highest level of approval since the question was first asked in 1985." More central to her argument, however, was her point that once you control for spending and other factors, charter schools seem not to perform significantly better than public schools.
- Alex3917 16y agoThere are a few questionable statements and conclusions in this article, for example her belief that we shouldn't worry about students who score at the 'basic' level on NAEP is highly questionable, although admittedly it's a bad test. In general though I think she's correct that the idea that the free market will fix our school system is absurd. But she wildly overstates both the quality of public schools, as well as the possibility of improving them. All in all though it's probably the best analysis of the movie I've seen so far, which in itself is kind of sad.
- vinhboy 16y agoOne thing I didn't like about the WFS is they did not give enough credit to "good" public school teachers. I thought they swiped everyone with one brush and made it seem like it's their fault.
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoFrom the studies I've seen, once you take into account the risk selection practices of charter schools, the advantages disappear.
- kiba 16y agoWhy is this so? Does the charter school do the same thing as public school?
- andrewce 16y agoMost do, yes. It doesn't matter if you're in a private charter school or a large public school, with large classes or small classes, if all that is going on is the lecture-then-test that limits itself to rote recall. If that's all that we're doing as teachers, it doesn't matter a single bit where it happens, so long as students can be made to comply.
- ktsmith 16y agoSome school districts aren't moving towards this methodology even though that's what's being pushed at the national level. The district my wife teaches in doesn't do this however the school she's stuck at this year is doing it to an extreme. They use a scripted curriculum. The teachers read from the script, the children provide a choral response and they repeat until every student gets it right. There's no need for teachers in that kind of a system since they aren't allowed to deviate from the scripts or supplement the scripts with other methods or resources. It's really depressing to see what some schools are resorting to to make AYP.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhile that method of teaching (direct instruction) is boring for teachers, and makes them easily replaceable, it is highly effective. Some info: http://www.jefflindsay.com/EducData.shtml http://www.jefflindsay.com/EducData.shtml Remember, the goal of schools is to educate children, not provide enjoyable high-wage employment for teachers. Or at least, that is the stated goal.
- futuremint 16y agoSingle page link: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2010/nov/11/myth-charter-schools/?pagination=false http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2010/nov/11/myth-ch...
- egabrielova 16y agoThe article mentions the school systems in Finland as a potential model for our public school system, though there are economic differences. I was curious, so here are a couple of relevant links. This article from BBC summarizes the basics, plus a couple videos. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8601207.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8601207.stm This focuses in particular on student age, school structure, and respect for the teaching profession. An longer article about Finland's school reforms since the 1970s. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3098447 http://www.jstor.org/stable/3098447
- niels_olson 16y agoI think Ravitch should be applauded for arguing an unpopular position with vigor. I also commend HN readers for reading critically. I hope we can point out her strengths as well as weaknesses, and I hope someone can provide some insight on the content of Waiting for Superman.
- Alex3917 16y ago"I think Ravitch should be applauded for arguing an unpopular position with vigor." Technically her position is actually the more popular one, it's just that you'd never know it because the media has teamed up with silicon valley and wall street to push charter schools and standardized testing. Anyway there is some more analysis on the previous thread linked below, but the fact is that though both Ravitch and the movie make a lot of valid points, neither is fully correct and you're never really going to understand why without reading books. Hacker News is fun and all, but there's no way you're going to understand the last 50 years of educational research after reading a few dozen comments. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1774156 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1774156
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoCharter schools are more for the adults who start the school rather than the children. I grew up in a state that had charter school mania, and it was always something like, some weird guy with a master's degree had a boner for Medieval Literature and his interpretation of the Origins of the University, so he'd start a charter school focused on Rhetoric, Sums and Figures, Swordsmanship, and Court Jesting (NO JOKE.). Or, some muslim elders from Somalia would start a somalian school catering to the special needs of somalian students, while simultaneously catering to the special employment needs of the school administrator's family who just arrived from Mogadishu. Or, a guy in the midwest who couldn't get a job as a final cut pro editor (no kidding?) so he'd start the "Media Sciences" charter school, etc etc. The actual kids attending these schools were a total afterthought.
- Alex3917 16y ago"I grew up in a state that had charter school mania, and it was always something like, some weird guy with a master's degree had a boner for Medieval Literature and his interpretation of the Origins of the University, so he'd start a charter school focused on Rhetoric, Sums and Figures, Swordsmanship, and Court Jesting." I'm laughing because that sentence instantly reminded me of pg because of this: http://www.paulgraham.com/essay.html http://www.paulgraham.com/essay.html (Which is actually one of my favorite pg essays, but it's still kind of funny.)
- tptacek 16y agoI'm undecided on this issue but slightly biased towards public schools (my mom is a public school teacher, I send my kids to public schools --- but because of where I live, my kids are going to de facto private school). I found this critique pretty devastating, and would be interested in seeing if any HN'ers can knock it down. Here are (I believe all) of the factual arguments presented in the article: * The film admits only 20% of charter schools gets "amazing results". In reality, the huge study that stat comes from says only 17% of charters beat public schools, 46% generate comparable results, and 37% are worse. * The film higlights successes but ignores chains of charters with newsworthy mismanagement scandals (real estate scams, embezzlement, religious indoctrination, $300-400k salaries to teach small student bodies). * Since test scores are what determines the perceived value of a charter, some charters expel students just before testing days or have high student turnover, particularly with low-performing students. * The NAEP test the movie relies on for the claim that 70% of 8th graders can't read at grade level says nothing of the sort; the movie distorts the results so that any student scoring less than a B is "below grade level", when in fact only 25% are below C, not 70%. The author of the article was a member of the NAEP governing board. * One of the film's heroes, Geoffrey Canada, runs a organization managing two (2) charter schools that is funded to the tune of $200MM, and is paid $400,000; the author of the article is an admirer, but implies that no public school system is similarly well equipped. * In 2010 state tests, 60% of Canada's 4th graders were below "proficient". Canada also expelled his entire first middle school class because their scores were too low, which the movie didn't note. * Another charter the movie celebrates, Green Dot's Locke High, took $15MM in funding and got only tiny improvements; only 15% of its students are now proficient in English, up from 13.7%; math rose from 4 to 6.7%. * Another charter, SEED in DC, is successful, but spends 3 times what the average public school spends ($35,000 per student). * Studies appear to show that teacher quality --- while the most important factor within a school --- accounts for only 10-20% of outcomes, while non-school factors account for almost 60% of the outcome. * Americans are dissatisfied with the quality of schools in general, but 77% of them rate their own school A or B. * Finland, the movie's model school system, is entirely unionized, has much lower poverty, and has a stronger social safety net than the US. * While the movie points out that only 0.04% of teachers ever lose their certificate, it omits the fact that 50% of new teachers leave the profession within 5 years, mostly because of working conditions.
- jaxn 16y agoI used to teach at a charter school in DC (http://seeforever.org http://seeforever.org) Our student body was made up solely of court-involved truants. These were kids who refused to go to school. They attended from 8am until 8pm and worked on regular course work as well as vocational training (I worked in the tech vocational program teaching design / web development / and Cisco networking). The school had a graduation rate over 90% and over 75% went on to college. Charter schools do tend to be thematic and some may seem frivolous, but the good ones are designed to help a poorly served segment to excel. It doesn't always work, but when it does it is remarkable. Charter schools cannot fix the entire system, but I do feel they are an important cog.
- ktsmith 16y agoI really like the idea of thematic schools. Locally we have a charter school that is college prep with a focus on science (http://coralacademy.org/ http://coralacademy.org/) and it's a great school. We also have two charter schools that focus on bilingual instruction that have produced really good results as the students receive each lesson twice. Once in their native language and once in english. Unfortunately it turns out that one of those schools is being investigated for test score manipulation so the results may be misleading. If you have students that aren't willing or able to perform in a standard school having alternatives available for them is a great thing. There's no reason that students that have no desire to go to college or what not should not have the option of a school that also offers vocational programs.