4 ms·
Google's power today is far greater than Microsoft's ever was in the 90s, and yet they had to sit through years of antitrust trials. Now we have Republicans arg
by chrisco255 8y ago
Google's power today is far greater than Microsoft's ever was in the 90s, and yet they had to sit through years of antitrust trials. Now we have Republicans arguing for fair treatment and threatening the use of the FTC...while Democrats (the traditional antitrust party) have sat on their hands over the past decade on these issues. Presumably, as far as I can tell, neither party has any particular morals. They're for things that are good for their base and against things that are bad for their base. And in this case, a left-leaning tech elite is good for Democrats...so we're not hearing a peep of antitrust talk from the Dems.
- voxl 8y agoBeing left-leaning is not cause for antitrust. Making your argument a false equivocation. Should Google be subject to antitrust trials? I would say yes, but not because of a left or right leaning bias in their search results.
- chrisco255 8y agoI think it's their 90% dominant position over the search market, mobile, advertising, and online video that should be subject to antitrust trials... As for the left/right leaning bias, I think that's all part of the same banana. Their powerful position gives them the flexibility to lean whatever way they choose with few, if any, market repercussions.
- bobdole123456 8y agoBeing the best in the market isn’t an antitrust issue. There isn’t any credible alternative to Google because they’re head and shoulders above everyone else. There are other search engines, they just don’t measure up.
- obpacheco 8y agoits not just that google has a search engine, they also own youtube, which plays a huge role into how people are getting their news today, as people watch less and less television.
- thrmsforbfast 8y agobobdole123456's point is that monopolies aren't illegal but abuse of monopoly power is illegal (you're being downvoted because you do not explicitly address that fact). But I actually think you raise an extremely interesting question: does pushing a political agenda using your monopoly position constitute an abuse of monopoly power? The advent of privately controlled monopolistic forums is somewhat new. I don't think it's at all obvious how the spirit of anti-trust law should be extended in the age of platforms... We're in new territory.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>Being left-leaning is not cause for antitrust.... As horrible as this may sound, it is a cause for anti trust break up when those in power are right leaning. I mean, let's not split hairs here. As a matter of pragmatic reality, that's pretty much what it comes down to.
- jasonlotito 8y ago> while Democrats have sat on their hands over the past decade Well, except for when they didn't. A simple search reminds us of this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/ftc-to-announce-google-settlement-today/2013/01/03/ecb599f0-55c6-11e2-bf3e-76c0a789346f_story.html?utm_term=.9116e5e92c12 https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/ftc-to-an... "Google emerged from nearly two years of intense federal scrutiny Thursday by convincing the Federal Trade Commission that even though rivals may suffer as the company continually refines its search engine, consumers often win through better, faster, more valuable answers to their queries." This also ignores more recent requests from Democrats to look into Google: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/06/04/pressure-is-building-among-some-democrats-for-another-antitrust-probe-of-google/?utm_term=.45bec69f16aa https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/06/04... "The new complaint comes from Minnesota Rep. Keith Ellison, a progressive in the upper ranks of the Democratic National Committee. In a letter to the Federal Trade Commission dated May 31, Ellison urged the watchdog agency to take a closer look at Google and its parent company, Alphabet, given that European regulators recently found that the search giant harmed its rivals and fined it $2.7 billion. “The FTC should determine whether Alphabet has engaged in similar conduct in the United States and whether such conduct violates the FTC Act,” he wrote." Those are just two cases I found in searches. I wouldn't call this sitting on your hands. > ...so we're not hearing a peep of antitrust talk from the Dems. We are. It's just getting drowned out by everything else that is happening.
- chrisco255 8y agoThose are good finds, but none of this scrutiny compares to what Microsoft got in the 90s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor.... That the Obama-stacked FTC did not take Google to trial is sort of telling. You got one company, presiding over 90% of the search on the web: http://www.visualcapitalist.com/this-chart-reveals-googles-true-dominance-over-the-web/ http://www.visualcapitalist.com/this-chart-reveals-googles-t... Might as well call Google the Ministry of Truth. They sit in a very powerful position over information and influence. China understands this, that's why they tightly control their search results. Anyone arguing that one company should have so much influence without probably being subject to some sort of oversight or regulation, is naive at best.
- JasonFruit 8y agoI hate to argue where you've said so much that's right, but neither party is really concerned about what's good for their base. They are concerned about what keeps them in power. Sometimes that is about doing what's good for your base, so they keep on voting for you, but sometimes you shaft your base to enlarge, enrich, or strengthen your kingdom. But in the end there are no statesmen — just power-hungry opportunists.
- lvs 8y agoThis is totally beside the point. Antitrust law governs market dominance and manipulation of market competition. It has nothing to do with political speech. If it did, Fox News would be in serious trouble!
- dmode 8y agoDisagree. Left leaning companies constantly get hit by legislation from left leaning politicians. See Amazon and BEZOS act for example. Airbnb and city legislations is another example.