5 ms·
I think the problem would be if their Search aspect were to be classified as a utility, then they would have to be more careful of their results manipulation.
by mc32 8y ago
I think the problem would be if their Search aspect were to be classified as a utility, then they would have to be more careful of their results manipulation.
So long as they are not regulated as such, then I don’t think the gov should get involved. But then again, that raises the question, should google be allowed lawfully to, say, supress all topics around Atheism, or Christmas or Hanukah or Russian meddling, if their management and ownership changed to one even more manipulative?
- sieabahlpark 8y agoNow you've shown that what they desire is a slippery slope for later.
- FireBeyond 8y ago> So long as they are not regulated as such And to think, it's the Republican Party that's been anchoring for removing any pretense of net neutrality. But now it's Bad(TM). Or at least Unfair(TM).
- magicalist 8y ago> I think the problem would be if their Search aspect were to be classified as a utility People have been writing this, but I'm curious what they mean, as there is no single legal "Utility" classification that could be put on something like google or facebook. Is there a specific legal approach people are talking about or is it just the commonly understood meaning of "utility" they're referring to?
- creaghpatr 8y agoSame framework as net neutrality except with speech/content instead of bandwidth. Of course, net neutrality isn't en vogue with current lawmakers.
- jonathankoren 8y agoBut the problem is that it is content and not simply bandwidth. Bandwidth is objectively measured, content isn’t.
- Someguywhatever 8y agoExample: You can't shut off somebody's electricity or water because they are a bad person, or have expressed unorthodox opinions. But you can shut off their twitter, their email, their web search, their facebook, their linked-in, stop processing payments for them (potentially cutting them off from their livelihood). You can cut them off from their digital identity and shut them out of the digital "public" in a manner of speaking. When that happens right now today, people hand-wave it away because "X is a private company they can do what they want." Never minding the fact that X has become how almost everybody addresses/interacts with the rest of the public digitally, or how X has ALL their email data, and many important documents etc Getting locked out of these things is not life threatening in the way that no water is, but it can essentially delete somebody from the "public" with almost no recourse.
- jonwachob91 8y agoThe utility company will turn off your services for failure to pay, a violation of their ToS. Twitter/Facebook/Google/whomever will suspend your account for violating their terms of service. What's the difference?
- roenxi 8y agoA usual TOS relationship with a utility isn't politically charged. The important line that is being crossed here is that you can get banned from Twitter/Facebook/Google/whomever for saying something that is not illegal but is in the opinion of the company objectionable. No utility has the power to disconnect me if I do something they think is objectionable with their service. And that goes to the heart of what people seem to want from "regulating as a utility" (a phrase that is terrifying in its vagueness) - they want freedom to voice unpopular opinions and let those who agree, agree.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoBut does that extend to advocating harassment? That's what Jones was accused of doing. Does harassment count as an unpopular opinion?
- bcheung 8y ago"An important legal requirement for common carrier as public provider is that it cannot discriminate..." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_carrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_carrier "Net neutrality is the principle that [providers] treat all data on the Internet equally, and not discriminate" "In a "dumb network", the endpoints are thought to be where the intelligence lies, and as such, proponents argue that the network should leave the management and operation of communications and data transfer to the end users, not a government bureau or Internet company." "Supporters of net neutrality... want to ensure that [companies] cannot screen, interrupt or filter Internet content without a court order." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality
- ericd 8y agoMaybe crawling should be a common utility, with the ranking being left to individual competition, similar to fiber lines owned by utilities and then companies being free to lease those and deal with end customers. As it is, many websites are hostile to new crawlers that don't already have lots of traffic to bring them in exchange, so it's difficult to offer an alternative to Google, even if you can get over the high minimum bar of being able to crawl a significant fraction of the web.
- bduerst 8y agoIsn't that just creating a duplicate internet then - one that taxpayers have to pay to host instead? That creates a ton of issues around being forced to pay for hosting other people's speech. For example, I don't want to pay to host anti-vaxxer site information but because of the first amendment, this public service can't remove it.
- ericd 8y agoWhy would you care about the cost to store a copy of sites you disagree with? It's a crawl, it's not the government making value judgements one way or the other. I'm sure the library of congress also contains material you disagree with. I don't think it would count as a duplicate internet any more than archive.org would.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoThis is the obvious reason why they have to take the government seriously. The stakes are that they end up heavily regulated. On a side note, I find it very ironic that a community who so passionately embrace net neutrality are so quick to cry 1A and liberty when it comes to political censorship and bias by the huge internet companies.