4 ms·
Nice propaganda, "By force" would be hitting your employer like a pinata until money came out. A union exists to make the exercise of the employees rights more
by michaelmrose 8y ago
Nice propaganda, "By force" would be hitting your employer like a pinata until money came out.
A union exists to make the exercise of the employees rights more meaningful by doing so collectively. If you acknowledge that an individual employee has a right to ask for more money or changes to how the business is run and decline to come to work its difficult to understand how all employees don't have the same rights collectively.
Incidentally this is an instance of the free market. Labor is a market. They are selling YOU their time and collaborating to get a better deal.
- seibelj 8y agoBut a business owner can’t fire everyone because they are starting a union, which by your logic they should have the right to do if this is a market. The whole point of a union is to limit what managers can do and tie their hands. So even if the business wants to fire unionized labor and find new and better labor, they can’t. They must now work through a tangle of rules to make changes to their business.
- gamblor956 8y agoSo even if the business wants to fire unionized labor and find new and better labor, they can’t. Those terms exist precisely to target the abuse you are describing: firing experienced, knowledgeable workers for "better" employees that are inexperienced and know jack-shit about what they're supposed to be doing and whose only qualifications are being cheaper. Let's face it: in most unionized gigs, the contribution of each individual worker isn't significant, so the marginal gains of hiring a "better" worker is generally immaterial to the bottom line. In the cases where that's not true, the union contracts generally have reduced job protections that make it easier for underperforming workers to be let go (on the basis of objective criteria).
- seibelj 8y agoWould you support banning automation and other labor-saving devices that eliminate the need for labor? Because that is another alternative.
- michaelmrose 8y agoThey can individually fire workers that perform poorly. Not being able to fire people for organizing is why we don't have people being crushed in machines and thrown away like trash to be replaced with more disposable people.