7 ms·
This argument is silly and ignores the power imbalance between employer and employee. We would be better of saying no company can offer employment on $obviousl
by Spivak 8y ago
This argument is silly and ignores the power imbalance between employer and employee.
We would be better of saying no company can offer employment on $obviously_bad_for_employee terms than letting the 'market' decide. Every employer benefits from this arrangement and no employer would have it in their contract if it didn't benefit them.
The power to just change jobs isn't as common and people on HN believe and that power is meaningless when most employers require arbitration. And why wouldn't they, it directly affects their bottom line.
- mbrameld 8y ago> no employer would have it in their contract if it didn't benefit them Isn't that true of every item in the contract when it comes down to it, though?
- colanderman 8y agoYes, which is why, for example, contracts waiving basic labor rights are illegal. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract#Illegal_contracts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract#Illegal_contracts
- vertex-four 8y agoBetween entities of similar power, contracts contain terms to protect both parties. When one entity has more power than the other, the terms are used to further empower them at the cost of the other.
- sneak 8y agoWho are you to decide what is obviously bad for someone else? Leave contract contents to those adults who participate in them. If either of the parties think provisions are “obviously bad”, then they won’t sign.
- pc86 8y agoI mean that's a pretty elementary interpretation to say the least. If you're struggling to make ends meet and are considering Uber for a few extra dollars every week are you going to care whether or not there is an arbitration clause? Even if you know it's bad you might be willing to risk it.
- sneak 8y agoGood thing Uber isn’t the only employer, or even the only rideshare option.
- rectang 8y agoI agree that this isn't a monopsony situation. The reason that "agency" is meaningless has more to do with the power imbalance of the individual relative to any large corp -- there doesn't need to be only one option for the negotiation to be a farce.
- xenihn 8y agoI can't remember the last time I went to a medical provider who didn't force you to sign an arbitration waiver. There's no realistic alternative.
- briffle 8y agoOr cell phone provider
- kevinskii 8y agoI too am always asked to sign arbitration waivers by medical providers. I never do, and I make sure they’re aware of it. I’ve yet to encounter one who will decline to treat me or my family because of it.
- justtopost 8y agoAbsolutely. Too many people underestimate a polite but resolved refusal to sign (without modification) any contract (including recipts!) whose terms you do not agree to. Not all, but many orgs will oblige if you don't seek to abuse it. Obviously Ymmv, not a lawyer, free advice from random internet stranger, caveat emptor, etc, etc.
- noobermin 8y agoThose who signed it are suing Uber, so clearly they've decided for themselves their relationship is problematic.
- SilasX 8y ago>We would be better of saying no company can offer employment on $obviously_bad_for_employee terms than letting the 'market' decide. Hold on -- are you saying that nothing about employment contracts should be up to the market? What are you counting as obviously bad here? Different people would say that e.g. under $wage/hr is obviously bad, but then you're right back to price controls. What are you criteria for when something should be up to the market?