4 ms·
You simply ask yourself this question What would be best. If the customer had to go to three different app stores to get what they want or just one. A fragme
by ThomPete 16y ago
You simply ask yourself this question
What would be best.
If the customer had to go to three different app stores to get what they want or just one.
A fragmented ecosystem can never be a benefit to consumer as it hinders the free flow of information and increases friction.
I did a longer post about digital ecosystems if you are interested
http://000fff.org/the-power-of-digital-ecoystems/ http://000fff.org/the-power-of-digital-ecoystems/
- vetinari 16y agoIs it a big drain on your life to decide, where to do your (physical) shopping? With apps stores, it is the same. You can have your favourite shop, where you do your shopping most of the time. But you have an option to change. Which is important, because the shop owner is also aware of this. As a result, he will not trying to f*ck you so hard, as he would, if you didn't have this option. (If you are locked in and the conditions change to worse, what are you going to do? Accept and submit, that's what.)
- ThomPete 16y agoI don't understand your reasoning here. If I have an android I have to go to different app stores to get different apps. With apple I just have one store where I can get all my apps no matter what telco I am on. That is the benefit of the integrated approach. I have yet to see how apple is exploiting customers. They aren't setting the price, they are allowing free apps. Aren't you confusing being a developer with being a customer?
- vetinari 16y ago> If I have an android I have to go to different app stores to get different apps. No. On Android, you can get most apps in most stores. Some stores are more popular than other (have more customers and more apps). As for now, the most popular is Google Market. On Apple, you must go through store. Even if you have .ipa on you harddrive, you must go through store. Apple sets conditions, what an app can and cannot do. Would you accept similar scheme for your computer? In most businesses, sole supplier is a no-no (if you ever forget, your risk auditors will remind you). There is a reason for that, believing in benevolent dictatorship will get you nowhere.
- ThomPete 16y agoTake on your consumer hat instead of your developer/hacker hat. Setting conditions to streamline and create consistency is good for the consumer not bad. No one is forcing people to buy apple products. If you want you can just choose android or Nokia. But people want the iphone because it's easy. Apple isn't sole supplier I don't know why this strawmen keeps getting thrown around.
- grobolom 16y agoWhy is it that everyone thinks that Android is "hard"? I think a point that most people are missing is that Android isn't actually hard at all. With the newer devices, we are seeing better and better interfaces. The reason many people think iPhone is better is because the marketing comes from one direction, rather than the diffuse marketing from Android. So iPhone gets cast in a better light. In reality? Not a huge difference. I do agree that consistency is good for the customer. But so is direct competition and choice. I think what will decide who dominates in the (far) future is which hardware people will develop more for and I can see either one being on top.
- ThomPete 16y agoThere is direct competitions. Between android and apple. The discussion resembles around what is best for the end consumer. And it's my view it the integrated approach is better than a fragmented one when we are talking about the same product
- grobolom 16y agoAnd why is that? What facts directly support that opinion? I think that if that was the case, there wouldn't be an immediate discussion following Jobs' comment on the same thing. If anything, I think the fact that these remarks have made it all the way to this discussion proves that it isn't such a clear-cut answer. In fact in many areas I'd disagree with the statement that integrated is better. While in some cases simplicity is great, what the hell is the difference between a store with 170,000 applications versus 90,000? If you're saying that the average consumer can tell the difference, I'd call BS. If you're talking about an above-average user, then the issue is moot because they will know how to get the applications they need without hassle anyway. Not only that, but fragmentation in itself has many levels. Yeah, everyone that codes iPhone applications has to use (somewhat) similar tools and API. However, what's the main draw for an app-maker? If anything, I think what platform a developer writes for has a lot more to do with his previous experience than the current dominant or integrated platform. Don't distance the developer from this. Consumers and developers, especially in these kinds of micro-transactions, are intimately tied. Things that affect developers DIRECTLY affect consumers, and I don't think it's so easy to draw the line.
- bad_user 16y agoIf the customer had to go to three different app stores to get what they want or just one. Personally I go to Google and type "best free iPhone apps", and I also ask friends for their preferences. I also have one mall where I make all my shopping and one phone carrier that provides me with what I need. BUT I CHANGED my phone carrier twice in the last 5 years, and I ended up with one that has better contractual terms and lower prices.
- ThomPete 16y agoYou are not answering the question. It's not about finding iphone apps but about having to have your credit card info in one store (iphone) vs. having it a different app stores (android) With regards to changing your phone carrier that actually just proves my point. With apple telcos can't make their own app store with android they can. In other words, androids ecosystem will be fragmented, I will have to be a verizon customer or a Amazon customer or a t-mobile customer. You don't have that problem with Apples app store. And that is the reason why it's better for the customer.
- bad_user 16y agoBullshit ... if multiple marketplaces happen, it is only because Google won't /doesn't manage to build a good enough marketplace in the first place, which proves my point. You've also probably been spoiled by the country you live in, but I used to live under a communist system where there was no such thing as consumer choice and competition. YES, it makes people unhappy to make choices (I've seen the switch in mentality on a large-scale). But it makes their lives better, since a free marketplace that allows choice is driven by natural-selection, with trends like lower and lower prices, better and better service. That's called a paradox and you're not seeing the forest from the trees, or you're just some shill.
- ThomPete 16y agoHow does that prove your point? My claim was that multiple app stores isn't a benefit for the consumer. You still haven't told me how that is a benefit to the customer. What is better about the multiple app stores that sells android apps and then the app store from apple. Pray tell. How is that better today? From a consumers point of view? Is it more expensive? More tedious? So far your sole argument is confusing communism with consumerism.
- omouse 16y agoThe customer has been able to install "apps" on ANY pre-iPhone device from ANYWHERE. They know how that works and they didn't mind the freedom at all. Sure J2ME apps sometimes suck, but you could get them anywhere, not from a single app store.