2 ms·
Thanks for linking that thread. It included a link to a discussion of adopting a CoC for the Ruby language project, which in turn linked to this https://where.c
by throwanem 8y ago
Thanks for linking that thread. It included a link to a discussion of adopting a CoC for the Ruby language project, which in turn linked to this https://where.coraline.codes/blog/on-opalgate/ https://where.coraline.codes/blog/on-opalgate/ - which provides some useful insight and context around that one Github issue from 2015 of which so many make so much. Given that the Opal maintainer was OK with it, and everyone involved came out unscathed, I see nothing of value in so many people who were and are totally uninvolved in the situation trying to cast it as a metonym of some kind of notional SJW thought police. It is not.
Where have I given Ms. Ehmke a free pass? Where has anyone?
- bitwize 8y agoWell, you've talked a big talk about how vicious the other side has been, but not a peep from you when Ms. Ehmke, herself, lashes out at her critics -- or even people she feels are guilty of not being progressive enough. So Ms. Ehmke's only regret in Opalgate is that she tipped her hand too much too soon, and wasn't vague and concern-trolly enough to convince the Opal project maintainers to evict the allegedly transphobic contributor seemingly of their own accord. Part of the problem people have with the Contributor Covenant is that while there isn't any anti-meritocracy language in the document itself, the rationale for the document cites "dogmatic insistence on meritocratic principles of governance" as a problem that must be corrected. It's right there on https://contributor-covenant.org https://contributor-covenant.org. Previous versions of this document made reference to "the pervasive cult of meritocracy", but again, that was tipping her hand too much so she dialed it back some. Given that meritocracy is the bedrock of open source development principles, chafing at the adoption of a document whose stated purpose is to combat meritocracy is to be expected. Her goal is to make her values open source values, and in the absence of an opportunity to collect scalps, she will look for leverage to twist arms. The strategy is to tone down the language of her CoC and related documents until it's palatable enough to get an in, and then put the screws to the community once they've pledged to uphold her code. Ever play Pandemic? A winning strategy is to start with benign symptoms like sniffles and a sneeze or cough, and then, only once everybody is sick (including those paranoid holdouts in Madagascar), crank up the nausea, vomiting, internal bleeding and heart failure sliders.
- throwanem 8y agoThe term for what you describe is ‘entryism’, or ‘Gramscian incrementalism’ if you want to be showily verbose. As it happens, the critique of meritocracy is one of the claims I don’t particularly buy. One of many; sympathetic as I am to most progressive goals, I think the movement’s choice of methods is almost maximally foolish. But, leaving aside the question of good faith on which I doubt we will agree, I think you ascribe a lot more power to the pro-CoC faction than that faction is in truth able to command.
- bitwize 8y agoI was talking about intent, not actual power to achieve. In my original post, I said the CoC would be a problem, but the structure of Linux governance appears to be resilient to bad-faith complaints for the time being -- again, likely to prevent entryism from the likes of Microsoft in the 90s, when the threat of infiltration of the process by saboteurs was arguably more real.