5 ms·
A shame that uber and the whole gig economy is so shit, circumventing basic employment rights and both minimum and living wages. I mean I like the basic idea an
by Cthulhu_ 8y ago
A shame that uber and the whole gig economy is so shit, circumventing basic employment rights and both minimum and living wages. I mean I like the basic idea and I agree that the taxi business needed the disruption, but it's opened the gates to people working well below a living wage because there's nothing else. That is, there's plenty of people that are willing to work below minimum wage because it's the only thing they have left. And companies - including Uber - are more than happy to offer that kind of work.
- icebraining 8y agoTaxi drivers were already considered contractors and working for shitty wages. Uber just followed the existing model. In fact, it was worse, as drivers had to pay to work, by renting the cars with medallions, rather than being able to use their own. https://www.nytimes.com/1995/04/09/nyregion/driving-a-taxi-difficult-in-best-of-times-gets-tougher.html https://www.nytimes.com/1995/04/09/nyregion/driving-a-taxi-d... The change for taxi drivers has only started to come after Uber was already making it big, e.g.: "For what the union involved says is the first time ever, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) declared taxi drivers are legally “employees”" http://www.peoplesworld.org/article/nlrb-declares-taxi-drivers-are-employees-can-vote-to-unionize/ http://www.peoplesworld.org/article/nlrb-declares-taxi-drive... (2015)
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoNot all countries have the medallion system (or that system the way it works in parts of the USA), and in some places drivers felt they were paid pretty adequately the way things were, and so they reacted very negatively to Uber drivers showing up and undercutting them.
- stormbrew 8y agoIn places where medallion or similar systems were in place, most of the protesters tended to be medallion owners. Who may or may not themselves be drivers, but even if they were were probably still deriving significant income from non-owner drivers renting their cars and medallions. They're more like landlords than employees.
- condescendence 8y agoThe NYC model is rarely how taxi's operate. My uncle was a taxi driver around the same time (maybe a little earlier?) and was paid a livable wage plus benefits. >"There are so many drivers available that it's an owner's market," said Edward G. Rogoff, a professor of management at Baruch College who studies the taxi industry. "Drivers are competing for these low-prestige, low-pay jobs, which pushes their incomes down further." You also missed the main part of the article. Simple stated there were too many taxi drivers. Now I don't know about you but if I were to have that many people willing to work for me its either the pay is good or working conditions. This sucks because like the article mentions, it becomes an owner's market. On top of this it's also NYC. No taxi driver is gonna be able to afford many of the places they get fares from. >"In '87, '88, you could make $100 a day, maybe more," said Sam Khan, a 37-year-old driver from Pakistan. But now, he said with a grimace, "maybe $60, $65."
- BurningFrog 8y agoIt's fascinating how you can fully spell out that Uber is giving people in a shitty situation a better life, and still have no doubt they're doing something bad!
- kryogen1c 8y agoI don't understand this logic generally and in this case it makes even less sense. 10 years ago, Uber literally didn't exist. How, in any way, is Uber forcefully underpaying it's employees/contractors? People flocked to drive for Uber; where is the oppression here? This is the same "Walmart doesn't pay its workers and destroys local businesses argument". People work there, and people shop there. Walmart didn't make anyone do anything, and neither does Uber. In a free market, people do what is valuable to them. How can you say those people aren't? If it's not a free market, then how is it the corporations fault? Don't hate the player, hate the government.
- simias 8y agoI mean, if you're a libertarian that makes sense. If you're not then wonder about why things like minimum wage exists, surely if people are willing to work for less than minimum wage why stop them?
- afterburner 8y agoIn a completely free market, corporations are free to distort economic and labour policy so that poor unemployed people are desperate to get any job they can, regardless of how poorly it pays. This is why minimum wage and other laws exist. See also: race to the bottom.
- ascagnel_ 8y agoTo add to this: if workers are underpaid relative to the cost of living in their area, they'll likely end up on some government assistance program. Effectively, Walmart/Uber/etc get to double-dip -- they pay their employees less than a living wage, and based on the US tax structure, don't have to pay for the government assistance programs that their employees end up needing to make ends meet.
- eh78ssxv2f 8y ago> To add to this: if workers are underpaid relative to the cost of living in their area, they'll likely end up on some government assistance program. But that was already the situation before Uber came to the market? For all we know, driving Uber might have moved some of the people less dependent on the government assistance programs.
- malvosenior 8y agoIsn't this a case against minimum wage laws? Obviously people's paychecks need to be paid from somewhere. Not all business models are going to work when you have to pay $15 /hr. So in that case, no job gets created and the person who could have done the work gets no money. By removing the artificial market controls, people can voluntarily choose to get paid less, and make something (which is better than nothing). I think people that complain about Uber not providing "basic employment rights and both minimum and living wages" don't really know what it's like to be poor. Talk to an Uber driver sometime, they're grateful for the opportunity to make some cash on their own terms.
- aaronblohowiak 8y agoIn Germany, I used an uber-like app, having the same tracking and reputational semantics, but it hailed actual taxis. very nice.
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhys that better than Uber though?
- Moodles 8y ago> it's opened the gates to people working well below a living wage because there's nothing else Haven't you just walked into an argument for abolishing the minimum wage here? (I'm not arguing for or against minimum wage. I'm just observing that the tone of your comment seems to suggest you don't like the idea, but this sentence seemed to be a good argument for it.)
- kidsnow 8y agoCould someone conceivably build a reference implementation FOSS client and server so that anybody could start their own Uber / Lyft. It would eliminate the friction to get going.
- Razengan 8y agoIt's certainly better than nothing; for both riders/guests/users and the drivers/hosts/providers.