3 ms·
Try playing around with this interactive graph, hosted on the same site mentioned in the article: www.babynamewizard.com/voyager . Not exactly a refutation of y
by kibwen 8y ago
Try playing around with this interactive graph, hosted on the same site mentioned in the article: www.babynamewizard.com/voyager . Not exactly a refutation of your hypothesis, but it does seem to indicate that both boy and girl names are following the same trend of increasing diversity over time, leading to reduced absolute dominance of any given name. If those trends are the same, and if we assume that both parents are just as involved in the naming process regardless of boy or girl, then it may be that there's not much of a difference in the faddishness of names.
If I were to propose a counter-hypothesis, it may seem as though boy's names are less faddish because of cultural tendencies to name children after biblical figures, of which there are many more men than women. Names like e.g. Matthew, Timothy, Benjamin are more-or-less timeless because of this (though of course they'll still wax and wane like any other), whereas people seeking girl names are relatively out of luck: you've got Mary, other Mary, um... Delilah (if you're okay with the whole "treachery" thing)... strangely Eve has never seen the same enduring popularity as Adam.
In a similar vein, it seems that boys are more prone to be named after ancestors, for which I offer the anecdotal evidence of how few women are "Juniors" compared to men. (And all of this is assuming western culture, I have no clue as to naming practices elsewhere.)
- amyjess 8y ago> whereas people seeking girl names are relatively out of luck: you've got Mary, other Mary, um... Delilah (if you're okay with the whole "treachery" thing)... strangely Eve has never seen the same enduring popularity as Adam. Just off the top of my head: Deborah, Esther, Leah, Rachel, Rebecca, Ruth, Sara(h) Maybe if you just want to stick to the NT you'll be limited to Mary (and "the other Mary" has evolved into Marlene in modern times). But I'm not really sure... I grew up Jewish, so I'm not too familiar with what is and isn't in the NT.
- kibwen 8y agoTrue, I grew up Catholic, so maybe I'm only slightly ashamed that I forgot all about Rachel and Ruth. :)
- crzwdjk 8y agoI would think that the reason few women are "Juniors" is because the assumption is that they will likely marry and lose the family name anyway. I'm not actually sure what happens to the suffix when Sue Smith Jr, daughter of Sue Smith Sr. becomes Sue Roberts or whatever, but presumably the suffix is dropped at that point since it is no longer needed for disambiguation.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> strangely Eve has never seen the same enduring popularity as Adam That's like saying Jesus has never seen the same enduring popularity as Mary. Chava is a pretty conventional name.
- kibwen 8y agoJesus as a name is quite popular, though. According to the site I linked above, in 2016 Jesus was the 134th most popular name for boys; Mary was the 127th most popular name for girls; Maria the 113th; Eve the 456th; Adam the 75th.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoJesus is not a popular name among English speakers. It's popular among Spanish speakers. (Joshua is currently popular, but according to your link that popularity reaches all the way back to the hallowed days of the 1970s.) Similarly, Eve doesn't have enduring popularity among English-speaking Christians, but that's a very different claim from saying that it hasn't seen enduring popularity.