4 ms·
There is no ecologically sound way of getting vegetable calories out of the Montana native grasslands. The best way of feeding people using that land would be
by bryanlarsen 8y ago
There is no ecologically sound way of getting vegetable calories out of the Montana native grasslands. The best way of feeding people using that land would be raising Bison; cattle are an acceptable second choice.
But your basic point still stands. The Montana native grasslands can only support a few cattle per square mile, so it definitely does not work at scale.
- mcv 8y agoThere re many different kinds of soil. I can totally understand that some soils are better used for this kind of sustainable grazing. Other soils are great for growing crops. This should not be a veganism vs organic meat discussion, but an organic meat vs intensive meat production discussion. And a separate sustainable crops vs soil-depleting crop production discussion. You can't feed everybody on just meat; you're going to need crops of various sorts. Feeding crops to animals for meat is incredibly wasteful, but having animals graze on land that's otherwise unusable, is a great idea. I hope this is the future of meat production. But it's not a replacement for sustainable crops.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"I can totally understand that some soils are better used for this kind of sustainable grazing. Other soils are great for growing crops." One could readily argue that most soils are better used for sustainable grazing. Tillage is very intrusive, destructive and unnatural. Most food crops require tillage. I used Montana as an example of a soil that would be quickly destroyed with a little bit of tillage. Luckily most soil isn't as fragile as Montana's, but virtually all soil is damaged by tillage. It's all moot though -- our current level of meat consumption is way above the level that can be met through sustainable grazing.
- mcv 8y agoWhat's better for the soil also depends on what you consider "good". Is it food production? Is it unspoilt nature? Soil used to grow food is different from soil left to nature, but expecting all soil to remain as natural as possible is unreasonable; we've got 7 billion people to feed, and building houses or streets in not good for soil either. What matters is how you can produce food efficiently and sustainably. There is soil that can produce more food in a sustainable manner through crops than through grazing. There is also soil where the opposite is true.
- bunderbunder 8y agoThere's an interesting UN report from a while back, Livestock's Long Shadow [1], that observes that, nowadays, it's not necessarily even ecologically sound to use the grasslands in the first place. A big feature of their findings are that large-scale grazing tends to prevent forests from forming in wetter climates, and contributes to desertification in more arid ones. Both of those consequences have huge implications if you're worried about climate change. One of the key goals they set out, aside from getting people to rely less on livestock agriculture in the first place, is to try and convert more of it to CAFOs. Yeah, factory farms are ugly, but they found that it's much more efficient from a land and energy use perspective. As have other disinterested parties. The loudest voices saying otherwise seem to be ones that have a financial interest in selling more grass-fed beef. A subtext here is that we live in a very different era than the one that the one invoked by more nostalgic approaches to agriculture. Once upon a time, people had no choice but to figure out how to feed themselves off the land they occupied, and nature put much firmer limits on how many people could occupy certain areas. Nowadays, not only is getting food shipped in a realistic option, sometimes it's even the more economical and sustainable one. 1: http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.HTM http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.HTM
- bryanlarsen 8y agoI agree that just idling those Montana ranches is probably best. Huge tracts of land just to raise a few cattle. But then what? Back to Bison? Bison are much more effective at preventing forests from forming than cattle are. So "natural", but from an ecosystem protection and climate change perspective probably not the best choice. "What's best for the environment" is often a large set of conflicting goals...