7 ms·
That's obviously not the point Jobs is going after. He'd be silly to do so. The warped, personalized, differentiated Android variants is exactly why Android is
by drivebyacct2 16y ago
That's obviously not the point Jobs is going after. He'd be silly to do so. The warped, personalized, differentiated Android variants is exactly why Android is taking off.
- apl 16y agoHm, obviousness aside - would you mind elaborating on that? Additionally, even if warped, personalized and differentiated Android variants have turned the underlying OS into a success, that doesn't imply that it's a good thing. Coincidence, iffy business tactics and "being good enough" are exactly why Windows took off.
- ThomPete 16y agoThis is beneficial for the phone companies only, not for the customers. And that is what Jobs is getting at. He want to make the best possible experience for the customers not create a fragmented ecosystem that allows anyone to make a version of how they see Android.
- bad_user 16y agoA fragmented ecosystem is also a competitive one: how can you argue that this doesn't benefit the customers is beyond my comprehension.
- apl 16y agoCompetition isn't intrinsically beneficial. Within the Android ecosystem, all you get is pseudo-competition: none of the players are interested in making Android any more open than it has to be.
- bad_user 16y agoThat depends on market forces that change by definition and it is definitely not a rule. Android gives the possibility of building unlocked phones ... from there it's just an issue of customer-demand. If only one manufacturer, like HTC or maybe Samsung, has success with an unlocked phone, the others will start replicating the recipe.
- ThomPete 16y agoIt's not about customer-demand, it's about big enterprise logic.
- vetinari 16y agoBig enterprise logic changes the same way, as cash flow changes. It is called "vote with your wallet" for a reason.
- ThomPete 16y agoIt doesn't change the way you seem to be assuming. Big enterprise havs cash cows and until those cash cows are gone they will be making all sorts of ego driven decisions. You would be surprised how much is driven by individuals and how little is driven by rationality. There are states within the states with their own motives. It is my experience that besides with the cash cows, it's anything but rational decisions that are being made in most cases.
- vetinari 16y ago> You would be surprised how much is driven by individuals and how little is driven by rationality. Oh, I wouldn't, I see it every day. Thank god for consultants, you can bring them in, and they will say the obvious/rational thing.
- ThomPete 16y agoWell then you know that enterprise logic far from always are rational.
- bad_user 16y agoI'm not seeing HP or Dell selling locked Windows PCs on which you cannot install Linux.
- 16y ago
- ThomPete 16y agoYou simply ask yourself this question What would be best. If the customer had to go to three different app stores to get what they want or just one. A fragmented ecosystem can never be a benefit to consumer as it hinders the free flow of information and increases friction. I did a longer post about digital ecosystems if you are interested http://000fff.org/the-power-of-digital-ecoystems/ http://000fff.org/the-power-of-digital-ecoystems/
- vetinari 16y agoIs it a big drain on your life to decide, where to do your (physical) shopping? With apps stores, it is the same. You can have your favourite shop, where you do your shopping most of the time. But you have an option to change. Which is important, because the shop owner is also aware of this. As a result, he will not trying to f*ck you so hard, as he would, if you didn't have this option. (If you are locked in and the conditions change to worse, what are you going to do? Accept and submit, that's what.)
- ThomPete 16y agoI don't understand your reasoning here. If I have an android I have to go to different app stores to get different apps. With apple I just have one store where I can get all my apps no matter what telco I am on. That is the benefit of the integrated approach. I have yet to see how apple is exploiting customers. They aren't setting the price, they are allowing free apps. Aren't you confusing being a developer with being a customer?
- vetinari 16y ago> If I have an android I have to go to different app stores to get different apps. No. On Android, you can get most apps in most stores. Some stores are more popular than other (have more customers and more apps). As for now, the most popular is Google Market. On Apple, you must go through store. Even if you have .ipa on you harddrive, you must go through store. Apple sets conditions, what an app can and cannot do. Would you accept similar scheme for your computer? In most businesses, sole supplier is a no-no (if you ever forget, your risk auditors will remind you). There is a reason for that, believing in benevolent dictatorship will get you nowhere.
- sovande 16y agoFragmentation kills. Too many versions to support, too few resources, risk of targeting the wrong version (newest) etc. etc.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoTweetDeck's launch stats show that this weak argument against fragmentation simply doesn't stand up.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoIronic how spot on I would be... http://www.businessinsider.com/tweetdeck-steve-jobs-2010-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/tweetdeck-steve-jobs-2010-10
- ergo98 16y ago>This is beneficial for the phone companies only, not for the customers. I have a number of top notch companies fighting for my attention and purchases, all of them generally on a common "app level": None have the comfort of sitting back, cocky that you'll have to choose them anyways. Do I want a Galaxy S? Maybe a slider? That new dual core? Maybe an inexpensive LG? It's extremely good for consumers.
- ThomPete 16y agoYou are missing the point. We are talking ecosystems here. Namely Androids vs. Apples
- ergo98 16y agoI'm not missing any point: An ancestor post made the very correct statement that Android's "fragmentation" is also its strength. You went off about how it doesn't benefit consumers. That is simply wrong. Sidenote: The phone companies don't customize the handsets at all. The manufacturers do it for them. If the Verizon Samsung comes with a particular app or has a feature removed, it's because Samsung -- an Android partner -- did that for them. It's a small nuance, but it's an important one.
- ThomPete 16y agoI haven't yet seen anyone show how it benefits to customer.
- ergo98 16y agoIf you can't see how choice and a competitive ecosystem benefits consumers, then I don't think you're really looking.
- ThomPete 16y agoChoice between what? I am all for choice between Android and Apple. But we are debating choice WITHIN Android ecosystem. I.e. different app stores for the same type of os. That isn't good for consumers there is absolutely no advantage to that. What should that be?