3 ms·
I'd say it's more like conventional factory towns from a couple centuries ago. I grew up in the Boston area, and on a recent trip back home, took my wife to se
by nostrademons 8y ago
I'd say it's more like conventional factory towns from a couple centuries ago.
I grew up in the Boston area, and on a recent trip back home, took my wife to see Lowell National Historic Park, birthplace of the industrial revolution in America. It struck me how similar the stories of the young women who went to work in the mills were to the young people who now flock to the Bay Area. Like today's workers, they were fleeing political instability & violence (for immigrants) or economic stagnation and lack of opportunity (for domestic migrants). Like in the Bay, they were thrust into a melting pot of cultures that sometimes stirred conflict but usually ended up broadening their horizons. Like in SF, they lived in small tenements or boardinghouses, often 2/room. Like at tech startups, they worked long hours in often alienating conditions to make capital owners rich.
The interesting thing about it was that despite all the hardship, it was very often the right choice financially for them. Many of the women who worked in the mills would "retire" in their mid-late 20s or early 30s, having saved up the majority of their wages. They were then free to do things like become a pastor (the 1840s equivalent of living a life of spiritual enlightenment), or get an education (nearly unheard of for women in those days), or marry above their previous station and have a family, or return to their hometowns and buy up large swaths of farmland that would've been out of their reach had they stayed on the farm they grew up on.
The people who really got screwed by the industrial revolution were those who didn't take the factory jobs in poor conditions - the small homesteading farmers, the artisans and craftspeople, the local merchants. They were largely wiped out as the new means of production spread throughout the world, bankrupt dinosaurs who eventually had to sell what was left of their homesteads when the dust bowl hit almost a century later. Most of them ended up catching the next wave, though, migrating to California or the Great Lakes and getting jobs in the new aerospace, defense, and automotive industries.
- vostok 8y ago> Many of the women who worked in the mills would "retire" in their mid-late 20s or early 30s, having saved up the majority of their wages. Thanks for sharing. I was under the impression that this was a relatively new phenomenon with the advent of sky high compensation in tech roles. Do you happen to know how common it was for them to be making, say, $300k in inflation adjusted terms by, say, age 26? I'd love to read more about this if you have any links. All the stuff I remember reading in school was about how horrible it was.
- badpun 8y agoMy guess was that standards of living were drastically lower back then, so the accumulated factory wages could make a difference. Back then, people lived in crappy little houses with no electricity, no water/sewage, obviously had no cars etc. There was relatively little stuff in their lives, so, as long as the land provided you with food, you didn't need much money. My grandma used to live like this in rural Poland - they occasionally bought something with money, like salt or matches, both mostly were self-sufficient.
- jfindley 8y agoIsn't that likely to be the same as what people 90 years in the future will say about us, though?
- CamTin 8y agoIn most of the developed world, literally all of our necessities (housing, healthcare, even food) require interaction with the money economy, which is the opposite of what is described here, so probably not. Even the Amish have to interact enough with the "English" economy to buy things like nails, and to pay their property taxes. Possibly we can operate this way again, with nano-factories turning homegrown soybeans into jeans and iPads or something, and a self-healing infrastructure, but that's far future sci-fi, not current reality.
- nostrademons 8y agoIt was exhibit panels at a museum, so there's no online link, but looking up some historical prices: Wages in the Lowell Mills in 1845 were about $25/month. [1] As of 1825 farmland went for roughly $5/acre. [2] So for every month you worked in the mills, you could buy a 5 acre farm. Save up for 10 years and you could get a roughly 600 acre farm, which is pretty substantial. Mill girls had very low expenses because their room & board was often paid for by the company and they didn't have time to go out and have fun, so they banked a lot of their earnings. A house in Brooklyn went for $2500 [3], so if you wanted to be a city girl, save up for 8 years and you could own it free and clear. It's hard to talk about "$300K in inflation-adjusted terms" because life was qualitatively so different back then. You couldn't buy an iPhone at any price, nor electricity, nor running water, nor basic sanitation and medical care. The poorest American today lives a much better life than the richest industrialist back then, except for having to look around him and see how everyone else is living even better ones. But by the standards of the day, someone who saved for 10 years in the mills could become quite wealthy, at least relative to the peers they left behind. Conditions were horrible - quality of life for mill girls was usually a lot worse than the farms they left behind. That goes for middle-class kids who become programmers in Silicon Valley as well. ;-) But economic gain is different from quality of life: part of the reason wages were high was because they needed to be to attract people from their old lives and put up with the new one, and one way to do that is to say "Well, when you're done here, you're gonna be the big man/woman in your old village." Also, we tend to judge the past by the standards of today, which isn't really fair. The choice these workers had wasn't "Work in the mills or live in the post-WW2 era of 40 hour work weeks", it was "Work in the mills or work on the farm." [1] http://courses.wcupa.edu/johnson/lowell1845.html http://courses.wcupa.edu/johnson/lowell1845.html [2] http://www.afrigeneas.com/forumdarchive/index.cgi/md/read/id/2344/sbj/price-of-land-per-acre/ http://www.afrigeneas.com/forumdarchive/index.cgi/md/read/id... [3] https://247wallst.com/investing/2010/09/16/the-history-of-what-things-cost-in-america-1776-to-today/2/ https://247wallst.com/investing/2010/09/16/the-history-of-wh...
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoI would hope it's not like that. Not after reading a quote someone posted about Lowell just yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18060336 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18060336
- nostrademons 8y agoThe interesting thing about that quote is that her family would've been fucked - even more fucked - had the Lowell factories not existed. The source of her family's misery was "a father’s debts are to be paid, an aged mother to be sup- ported, a brother’s ambition to be aided", all of which are pre-existing conditions that ultimately result from life (and perhaps some poor financial management). Similarly, I think we're fucked today, and the source of our fuckedness has nothing to do with technology. It comes from overpopulation (there are now 7.4B people on this earth, compared to 4.5B when I was a kid and 1B when my parents were kids), and climate change, and resource depletion, and living like the good times will always go on rather than investing in the future. Life requires resources - when the planet has more lives to support and fewer resources to support them, the standard of living will necessarily go down.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIt's not a part of history I know enough about - the quote raises almost as many questions as answers. I surely wouldn't appreciate being locked in a factory for a 12 hour shift whatever the reasons. The little I do know about factory towns make me think the father's debt might very well be because of the factory town. It was common for the worker to be paid in factory currency to be spent in the factory store, live in a factory house, and for things to be organised such that they'd never make enough to pay off a debt accrued when they arrived and took on the house, or make enough to ever leave. They were a very different thing to the model towns of the philanthropic industrialists of the Victorian age. To your second point, sadly, I am in full agreement.
- nostrademons 8y agoIn her specific case, the factory didn't cause her father's debt. Sarah Bagley was born in Sandia, NH; like many of the early mill girls, she was a domestic migrant [1]. The roots of her family's financial troubles were just that her parents each had many siblings and then they had 4 kids, which meant that whatever property the family owned would've been long since diluted. I don't want to make the point that she shouldn't have been fighting for labor rights - a 40 hour work week and egalitarian distribution of wealth is better than what conditions were like in the 1840s, and we wouldn't have gotten them without activists like her. I do want to make the point that empirically, some period of time where everybody in the labor force is fucked over seems to be necessary for economic development. Without it, there's no incentive to, well, ditch the labor force for the far more uncertain world of entrepreneurship & innovation. And this has been observed in basically every industrializing country - Britain, Germany, Russia, Japan, now China. Once the new industries and new technologies are established, then there's usually a consolidation period where social equilibrium is restored; in the U.S, this was from the 1930s-1980s. It appears that you can't do the latter until the former is complete, though, because you don't know what form the industries will take or what the centers of power will be. Unions were a very effective check on industrialists, but it seems likely they won't be nearly as effective in the information age, because the set of roles that workers occupy in the tech economy is more diverse, and their necessity to a company's day-to-day operations is smaller. If all engineers at Google walk off the job, Google Search will continue to run, and it will continue to run for several weeks afterwards. That blunts the effect of a strike or work stoppage. Probably we need things like regulations around data ownership & access, pro-competition statutes, and widespread education & job training to restore social equilibrium in the data age. It's really hard to judge until all the technologies that'll make it up have been invented though. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarah_Bagley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarah_Bagley
- vtange 8y agoBut how does the scale compare between the two? It would seem like tech work lifts much less people up the chain as factory work did. And in less proportion too: A factory in the industrial era could employ thousands at a time from a population of hundreds of thousands whereas now we live in a world of millions and tech comparatively employs a couple hundred.
- nostrademons 8y agoIt's similar in percentage terms, perhaps even a bit more concentrated. Lowell, Massachusetts had a population of 20K in 1840, with maybe 6000 working in the factories. Total U.S. population was 17M at the time. Compare with Google alone having 60K employees spread out across dozens of offices. Lowell was the only such center of manufacturing in the country at the time, much like how Silicon Valley is considered synonymous with the tech industry. There are other tech hubs, though, and other companies, and tech is already starting to bifurcate into sub-industries. I'd actually equivalent 1840s Lowell to the Massachusetts Miracle of the 1970s, when the MA economy was rescued by the arrival of info-tech firms like DEC, Stratus, Wang, etc. (ironically, DEC was started in a former textile mill, and Wang Labs had its headquarters in Lowell). The current point in history seems more like the 1880s or 1890s, when the center of industry had moved to the Great Lakes region and the basic technologies had bifurcated into the steel/oil/shipbuilding/railroad industries. We think of factory work as employing the whole population because the oldest folks alive today only have memories of the 1920s and onwards. What are these big industries that lifted people up the chain? Automotive, aerospace, airlines, oil, manufacturing, plastics, chemicals, retail, consumer goods, media. In 1880 the car hadn't been invented. The plane hadn't been invented. Plastic hadn't been invented. Radio hadn't been invented. TV hadn't been invented. The department store hadn't been invented. Consumer goods required all of these. Similarly, I suspect that the great industries of the information age have yet to be invented. Or they're in vary nascent, experimental forms today, like drones and cryptocurrencies and hyperloops and robots and self-driving cars (which'll probably end up being pods, eventually).