3 ms·
What happens when life support is discontinued for someone who has a normal sized brain? Are steps taken to make the end quick, or do they also starve? If the l
by tzs 8y ago
What happens when life support is discontinued for someone who has a normal sized brain? Are steps taken to make the end quick, or do they also starve? If the latter, then I'm not sure that it being provably not potentially horrible for Schiavo has any relevance to the underlying ethical question.
Also, brains are overrated [1]. :-)
[1] https://www.iflscience.com/brain/man-tiny-brain-lived-normal-life/ https://www.iflscience.com/brain/man-tiny-brain-lived-normal...
- wahern 8y agoQuick Googling suggests that it's widely understood that starvation isn't, per se, painful. Presumably what might be painful is prolonged malnutrition. As someone who has fasted for a week, I can attest that much of the physical discomfort disappears rather quickly. Though, I can't speak directly to near-death starvation, nor to dehydration. I agree that it's ridiculous that doctors (in the U.S., at least) rarely have a way to quickly and legally dispatch people (or the shells of people). It happens informally, though. Being such a high-profile case, advocates for Terry Schiavo's parents all but ensured the doctors would follow the book--starvation.
- cf498 8y ago>As someone who has fasted for a week, I can attest that much of the physical discomfort disappears rather quickly. Though, I can't speak directly to near-death starvation, nor to dehydration. There are quite alot of reports from prisoners on hunger strikes, some of whom died. The ones I read about agreed with you. The discomfort disappears after the first week of so, after that you just get weaker and weaker to the point were you are no longer able to eat normal food. Dehydration is much more problematic with slipping into a delirium and going into spasm. Sadly there are also examples of prisoners experiencing this, as some countries have had the concept of "dry cells". They were first used as punishment and later to break hunger strikers. Baader of the German Baader-Meinhof group for example retained kidney damage from his stay in such a cell during a hunger strike.
- jacobush 8y agoSo, torture cells.