2 ms·
"Everything you've said may be true, and yet your comment is still a perfect example of whataboutism." The initial topic of this thread is China, not the US, s
by perl4ever 8y ago
"Everything you've said may be true, and yet your comment is still a perfect example of whataboutism."
The initial topic of this thread is China, not the US, so it seems to me that criticizing China cannot, by definition, be whataboutism in this particular context.
I'm not personally inclined to dismiss things as "whataboutism" as though it were an automatic debate ender, but if you do, then you have to restrict your discussion to China's sins in this thread.
- markdown 8y agoI'm not talking about this thread or the discussion in this thread, I'm talking about this: > I like to remind people of shit like this when they claim that the United States government is an "oppressive" presence on the Internet. In January, the US Senate passed a bill to renew the NSA’s warrantless internet surveillance program for six years with minimal changes. If walrus01's friends had brought up that topic at the time, it sounds like he'd have defended the program because China is worse. Whataboutism.
- perl4ever 8y agoMaybe? Calling out hypothetical whataboutism of someone else is like whataboutism squared on your part, though. Hyper-whataboutism. Meta-whataboutism. Not that there's anything wrong with that, of course.