5 ms·
The Chrome team has been shocked about a lot lately. I give them the benefit of the doubt on their intentions (although I'm less sure about upper management).
by danShumway 8y ago
The Chrome team has been shocked about a lot lately.
I give them the benefit of the doubt on their intentions (although I'm less sure about upper management). But regardless of their intentions, they need to get better at thinking ahead.
Situations like this are always a little complicated, so I don't want to oversimplify or claim that they should have been psychic. But... it really shouldn't have been hard to tell that people would be upset. I kind of feel like if nobody on the Chrome team could have predicted this, then the Chrome team is seriously out of touch with users.
I mean, heck, the change contradicted Chrome's own privacy policy, which had to be updated after the fact. Is there seriously no process to check stuff like that before features ship? How is anyone supposed to trust Google's privacy policy when any team can break it inadvertently and it takes a Twitter thread weeks later for them to find out?
The Chrome team has a nasty habit of simultaneously saying, "just trust us, we're experts, we know what we're doing", and "there was no way we could have predicted that users would be upset by this."
Both of those things can't be true.
- pvorb 8y agoOf course they knew technical professionals would be upset. That's why they are prepared and they all can react with a single voice.
- lrem 8y agoThere is a process where external launches need to be approved by a separate privacy team. If you're certain you can do a better job, you can find some listings on https://careers.google.com/ https://careers.google.com/ (just search for privacy).
- tedivm 8y agoI don't think that using this incident as a recruitment pitch is a good idea.
- lrem 8y ago"Somebody should do a better job!" "Why don't you try yourself?" Seems like a somewhat reasonable train of thought. A lot of good things can come out of outrage, as long as people are willing to take action (no, I don't claim going through Google recruitment to be the optimal strategy, but it is an option)(I actually got my first job as a result of my technical complaints, obviously not in Google).
- snowwrestler 8y ago"How about you do it then?" works in volunteer situations where anyone can step up. That's not the Chrome team at Google. Unless you are actually offering a job at Google, it's not a reasonable train of thought, it's a (somewhat pissy) cop-out.
- danShumway 8y ago> "Somebody should do a better job!" "Why don't you try yourself?" This argument makes sense when you're talking about a problem that one or two people control rather than a large system with higher stakeholders who may not have interests aligned with your own. But I'll assume you're right for a sec. Let's assume that Google cares a ton about making sure their privacy policy is consistent, but it's just an insanely hard job and nobody could do any better. Why does that matter? In that scenario, I still don't trust your privacy policy. I don't care whether it's inconsistent because people are incompetent or because the problem is hard. In either case, the privacy policy is unreliable. If I can't trust it in Chrome's case, how can I trust it in Gmail's case, or in Adword's case, or in any other product? In a way, saying it's a hard problem is even worse. I would have felt better if you had come back and said, "oh, the Chrome team is just uniquely incompetent, but everybody else has got their stuff together."
- lrem 8y agoMy thinking is more in line of: if privacy team was bigger, it would intuitively have a way easier job keeping tabs on all the developments. However, that's a job without talent attractors like glamorous launches. When you're sailing smooth, nobody knows you exist. But when I mention they're hiring in an incident, I learn this is the wrong time to mention them. But then again, I'm neither in privacy team, nor Chrome team, know no specifics of this case and can't really argue any position (note how I'm neither defending nor condemning the issue of OP). Just pointing out generalities that I don't see mentioned.
- curiousDog 8y agoOr you know a better option would be to use a competitors product.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThey should have just put the new behavior in an extension and heavily promoted that to g-suite users.