4 ms·
I don't blame them for this. They want to get out of OpenGL because how much of a maintenance nightmare it has become due to non technical concerns. To ship t
by monocasa 8y ago
I don't blame them for this. They want to get out of OpenGL because how much of a maintenance nightmare it has become due to non technical concerns. To ship top end OpenGL (and DirectX) drivers these days, it's more or less required that you write tons of code that recognizes the application that's calling your driver and fixes bugs in their code. Nvidia starting doing this, and now all end users see is that programs work on Nvidia and not AMD (or Apple as they write their own drivers), and blame everyone other than Nvidia. The switch to these new Mantle derived APIs is as much if not more about resetting those expectations of responsibilities than the technical benefits that these APIs provide (which AZDO 80/20 ruled most of the way to anyway).
Supporting a MoltenGL as a first class item defeats the whole purpose of moving away from OpenGL to begin with from their perspective. OpenCL never got the critical mass in their eyes, and someone else is already taking on MoltenVK.
- ancarda 8y agoWait a sec... My gaming PC (2x AMD R9 290X, 8 GB video memory) is absolutely awful with a lot of (esp. Ubisoft) games like Assassins Creed or Watch_Dogs. I just assumed the games weren't optimized for AMD hardware. That is based partly off the Nvidia logos that are shown during startup and in the graphical settings menu. There's also graphical issues at high resolutions. I've been planning on buying an Nvidia GPU so I can actually play games at a decent frame rate. Are you telling me part (or all?) of the problem is bad drivers? I got the drivers from Windows Update rather than from AMD so they would just update themselves and be the correct ones.
- crooked-v 8y agoNot bad drivers, bad game code.
- cpeterso 8y agoOr AMD drivers that are not adding "do what I mean" hacks to work around bad game code? Sounds like AMD and Nvidia took different approaches to Postel's Law ("Be conservative in what you send, be liberal in what you accept").
- monocasa 8y agoIMO, there's a practical upper limit to how liberal you can be. There are some games that straight up don't call endscene and present and crap like that in DirectX land. Or have bugs in their shaders, expecting the driver ISVs to just completely rewrite them by hand anyway. Nvidia can get away with this because they have something like 10x the engineering staff as AMD's on the GPU sides of their companies. Apple never had a hope of competing in this space at the same level.
- cpeterso 8y agoIf Nvidia is adding workarounds in their drivers for crappy game code, how did those games work before Nvidia added the workaround for their crappy code? :)
- monocasa 8y agoIn my mind, the problem is bad code from developers like Ubisoft, and the willingness of Nvidia to expend tons of engineering effort to hack around them on a case by case basis. It's not really fair to call standards compliant drivers "bad" in my mind. AMD pushed Vulkan (and Mantle previously) hard because it lets them break the cycle due to the layering concept in the driver stack. Intrinsic in how those drivers work is allowing end users to stick API verification layers in at load time. This will allow AMD to go to the press and say "see, it's not us, it's the application developer that wrote terrible code" without leaking any internal IP of those other shops.
- ksec 8y agoThat is one of the reason why I think Metal is the right way to go. I can't understand how we will be able to sustain the current development of GPU, when more than half of the cost are in software drivers development and cost % is constantly moving up. Another reason why the Desktop GPU market is so hard to break in, as have we seen times and times again, from 3Dfx with poor Direct X Drivers, S3, 3D Labs, Matrox, PowerVR etc. But I tried making this point with an Intel GPU engineers and he said my point is moot. May be he knows something I don't.
- CoolGuySteve 8y agoDue to the windows certification process, the drivers from windows update are always six months to a year out of date. Or at least that's how it used to be, I haven't checked in years. It's always better to get graphics drivers from the chipmaker directly for both Nvidia and AMD cards.
- monocasa 8y agoI wouldn't be surprised if certified drivers have some of the more egregious hacks disabled too.
- Sharlin 8y agoThe fact that the drivers aren't special cased to compensate for Ubisoft's buggy code doesn't make the drivers bad. The games are bad.
- iainmerrick 8y agoDon't they need some kind of OpenGL support anyway, for WebGL? (Okay, that's OpenGL ES, but it's very similar.) Why can't they continue to support OpenGL at least to the level required by WebGL? And if they want to switch out the backend to some kind of GL-to-Metal translation layer, so be it. I don't care whether it's a native driver or a compatibility layer. If I do care, for performance reasons, I should be using Metal, sure.
- monocasa 8y agoBecause once they open that can of worms they're on the hook for supporting it. Additionally, there isn't a good way out on the browser side, as Vulkan/DX12/Metal style APIs would pretty trivially allow JS code to escape whatever sandbox it's in. So the obvious answer is to keep their OpenGL implementation internal to Safari, and only support one of the new APIs (obvs Metal in this case) for native apps.
- iainmerrick 8y agoWhy would the web need Vulkan-style APIs? It just needs WebGL (so far). I still don’t see why that Safari implementation of OpenGL would have to stay internal.
- favorited 8y ago> Why would the web need Vulkan-style APIs For the record, there is an Apple-led initiative to bring a modern GPU interface standard to the browser: https://webkit.org/blog/7380/next-generation-3d-graphics-on-the-web/ https://webkit.org/blog/7380/next-generation-3d-graphics-on-...
- iainmerrick 8y agoI hope there’s no plan to drop WebGL. Although it wouldn’t surprise me. Really the only question is when -- years or decades?
- Negitivefrags 8y agoAs someone who works on a game that is pretty popular I'm not sure I buy this. I'm certainly not aware of nVidia doing anything special for our game, and honestly, they haven't really been super easy to get help from when we have attempted to ask them questions about problems that are nVidia specific that we run into. Since we are not a big publisher, it's super difficult to maintain a relationship. We will get assigned someone to talk to, and next time we actually have a problem that person will have quit / moved to a different department / stopped caring about us. Our game is in top 10 on steam right now, and is typically in the top 20 even during low periods, so I would have thought we would be somewhat higher up the priority list for specific attention if that was going to happen. So all of that is to say, we pretty much have to deal with the problems ourselves, not rely on nVidia to fix them for us. That being said, people complain about problems on AMD in our game all the time. So why is that? Forget game specific optimisations, I think it's just that nVidia has just plain better drivers in general. When we are developing new engine features, the difference is pretty clear. If you naively implement a shader, it often runs faster on nVidia initially. It's usually possible to persuade the AMD drivers to run things just as fast, but it's totally non-obvious how.
- monocasa 8y ago> Since we are not a big publisher That's the thing. Ubisoft, EA, etc. get special treatment that happens before release. If you've released and it works without custom drivers, then obviously you don't need that special treatment.
- tmikaeld 8y agoIs the game Toxikk?
- Cogito 8y agoPer their profile page, most likely it's Path of Exile.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoSounds like Nvidia understood what Microsoft understood. An operating system is really only useful in that it allows you to run the software that you use. Because of this Microsoft went to extreme efforts to make sure when you upgraded your OS, your programs ran. Nvidia understands that you gamers buy graphics cards to run games on them. They just want their game to run and look good on the graphics card. They don't really care about how bad the game developers are and want efforts Nvidia had to take to get the game to run. At the end of the day, games running good means happy customers.