4 ms·
So, it's bad because it doesn't sync your history by default? Even if the UI is confusing, the worst case here is thinking that your data is being synced when i
by sp332 8y ago
So, it's bad because it doesn't sync your history by default? Even if the UI is confusing, the worst case here is thinking that your data is being synced when it's not. It's like the opposite of a privacy problem.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> the worst case here is thinking that your data is being synced when it's not Confused, what do you mean? To me thinking that my data isn't being synced when it really is sounds much worse...
- sp332 8y agoYeah there's a usability issue for sure, but the article is talking about privacy and potential GDPR problems. Edit: what I mean is, there's no way to get the interface into a state where it looks like you're not logged in, but it is syncing in the background. The only confusion here is in the other direction: you're visibly logged in, but it's not syncing.
- mehrdadn 8y agoI was talking about privacy too, not usability... it's a privacy issue when your data is being synced when you think it isn't. (I think you might be mixing up the two scenarios?)
- rando444 8y agoIt's bad because it's by default signing you into a service you didn't ask to be signed into, and don't have an easy option of turning this off. Sure, it doesn't automatically sync your browsing history now, but we all know change happens gradually. It's just a "feature" to be enabled later. I've never once signed into chrome in my life (on purpose). I don't want anything synced between browsers, I like to try and limit what gets kept in the cloud, and with this change they've simply just taken the option away from the user. Yes, I'm sure that I'm in the minority, but I'm taking this opportunity to start switching to Firefox, switching my mail provider, and am hoping to send them a GDPR request to delete all of my data. It's not necessarily just this issue that made me do it, it's just the tipping point for me that says.. "ok, this company has gotten too big off people's data, and i no longer wish to be a part of feeding that machine" Just my 2 cents.
- sp332 8y agoWhat is (or was) the difference between signing in to Gmail in the browser, vs signing in to the browser without sync? (You might feel that this is a tipping point but it's still not a GDPR issue as far as I can tell.)
- hackinthebochs 8y agoThe difference for me is that, previously I knew I was multiple difficult steps away from having my browsing data uploaded to Google servers. That provided me a level of comfort that doesn't exist anymore. With the new method I'm one misclick away from giving everything to Google. Add on to this, Chrome has been increasingly pushy with its sign in prompts. There's no reason to think it won't eventually be equally pushy with its sync prompts.
- tedivm 8y agoFor one thing they have completely different privacy policies. By signing into the chrome they are automatically forcing people to accept the privacy policy that is far less private than the when people aren't signed in.
- _dmurph 8y agoThis doesn't seem to be turning on Chrome Sync, so users aren't being forced into any privacy policy: https://twitter.com/__apf__/status/1044109898013765632 https://twitter.com/__apf__/status/1044109898013765632
- tedivm 8y agoRead the actual privacy policy, not the tweet talking about it. Primary sources are always best. > The personal information that Chrome stores won't be sent to Google unless you choose to store that data in your Google Account by signing in to Chrome. That doesn't say "unless you enable sync", it says it changes "by signing in to Chrome". Since they're now forcing you to sign into chrome without your consent they are also forcing you to accept that they can send your data to their services without needing any additional permissions from you.
- partiallypro 8y agoAnecdotally when I tested this the "sync your data" screen seemed a lot more like a "yes" prompt. Similar to Facebook's 3rd party fiasco of an app asking for tons of permissions, and just saying "accept" to be done with it. So most people are going to just sync their data and probably have no idea what's happening. They might not even care, but I don't think that is a good measure of if this is good or bad. Most users are ignorant.