13 ms·
MacOS 10.14 Mojave Reviewed
- NickBusey 8y agoGeez.
- thatswrong0 8y agoIt has "infinite" scrolling though.. by default you can view the whole article in one page.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chooseaname 8y agoHow's battery life on Mojave? My 2014 MBPro is still on El Capitan and doing well, so not sure I'd upgrade if there's a battery hit.
- robin_reala 8y agoI haven’t noticed any with the betas, nor seen anyone talking about it, but my battery isn’t especially happy anyway on my 2012 Macbook Air so I’m used to not expecting much.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- noncoml 8y agoDark mode is really refreshing for the eyes. Tab completion now shows dot files as well; ".DS_Store" is there everywhere. I wonder if they have a plan to do away with the .DS_Store anytime soon.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- neilsimp1 8y agoI've never owned an Apple anything and yet I swear I still find .DS_Store files on my Windows/Linux machines from time to time.
- bobwaycott 8y agoAssuming you deal with software, I'd guess that's because someone has committed them to a repo. It's one of the reasons Mac-based devs should always have a global .gitignore file.
- ben174 8y agoMaybe a shared directory someone has browsed from their macOS box?
- reaperducer 8y agoI see them on my CentOS servers. But then I also see tons of Thumbs.db
- ihuman 8y agoI miss Asepsis. It was a daemon/dynamic library that would redirect the .DS_Store file location. Unfortunately, it can't run on modern Macs due to System Integrity Protection.
- beamso 8y agoDark mode is darker than what I had expected. Only the focussed window looks good. Background windows are black.
- derefr 8y agoQuestion for anyone who knows: is there a reason .DS_Store files cannot instead be stored as xattrs on the directory inode they’re “for”?
- 8y ago
- noja 8y ago2FA with SMS was a standout weird choice from Apple. I hope they discourage that quickly with a better alternative.
- xoa 8y agoYeah, maybe it's just a bow to practicality but if anything mildly surprised regardless because they've gotten quite serious about their own HSM implementation which is slowly starting to spread to more and more new Macs, and it's effectively universal under iOS. I sort of expected given initial thrusts like Apple Pay that they'd push hardware token usage way harder, with either direct support for Macs with T-series chips already or else some tie-in to iDevices. Ideally NitroStick/Yubikey/etc would come along for the ride and Apple would work towards a framework that could be used with other HSMs beyond their own, but at this point I'd take any major platform trying to move crypto auth forward over passwords/sms/anything else at all.
- chrisfinazzo 8y agoI think your first instinct is correct, here. While they probably would feel safer if everybody was using Google Auth, Authy, or a physical device, it gets around people having to explicitly copy tokens around which, IIRC has been abused a fair bit in order to steal credentials.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoThey do 2FA for iCloud sign-in through an vanilla iOS prompt, not SMS afaik.
- xoa 8y agoLike iOS 12 very promising overall from the sound of it, and a genuine step forward from previous years in the fundamentals of speed and stability just as they promised to work towards. One continuing (though not new at all to the release) disappointment I have with Apple though: >The end of OpenGL and OpenCL on the Mac A solid summary of the situation, but to me where Apple really deserves blame there is not having MoltenGL and MoltenVK (and perhaps some theoretical MoltenCL too) as 1st party projects. I completely understand them wanting their own directly writable and controlled low level graphics language and having that be the interface layer. They are pretty vertically integrated and are now even doing their own GPUs, but even before that on the Mac they have long built the OS very strongly around GPU capabilities (for better and for worse, basic VM experience is very mediocre if you don't have a hardware GPU to passthrough). If anything I'm mildly surprised in retrospect Metal wasn't done earlier, OpenGL wasn't working for them and it's that big a deal. Microsoft invested in their own graphics layer for Windows ages earlier. But controlling their own low level layer doesn't mean that higher level non-proprietary interfaces shouldn't still be supported on top. Part of the point should be to enable abstraction there. Apple is a big enough player and platform that this shouldn't be a zero-sum game, and their perfectly understandable strategic concerns addressed by Metal don't preclude OpenGL continuing to be officially supported as a layer on top of Metal. Apple could have even done it as another open source project of which they were the primary sponsor even if they wanted to manage it that way. This may be just another symptom of their unusual startup-type culture which lets them hyperfocus on specific products but reduces their corporate ability to multitask, but it's still a shame. It could have been just about supporting newer and better stuff going forward, not taking something away. Even if MolenVK/MoltenGL ultimately fill some of that void I don't think that should have been relegated to 3rd party only.
- monocasa 8y agoI don't blame them for this. They want to get out of OpenGL because how much of a maintenance nightmare it has become due to non technical concerns. To ship top end OpenGL (and DirectX) drivers these days, it's more or less required that you write tons of code that recognizes the application that's calling your driver and fixes bugs in their code. Nvidia starting doing this, and now all end users see is that programs work on Nvidia and not AMD (or Apple as they write their own drivers), and blame everyone other than Nvidia. The switch to these new Mantle derived APIs is as much if not more about resetting those expectations of responsibilities than the technical benefits that these APIs provide (which AZDO 80/20 ruled most of the way to anyway). Supporting a MoltenGL as a first class item defeats the whole purpose of moving away from OpenGL to begin with from their perspective. OpenCL never got the critical mass in their eyes, and someone else is already taking on MoltenVK.
- cptnapalm 8y agoHaving an older Mac Pro, I saw that it Mojave will do a firmware upgrade. I won't be using MacOs, but will be running the installer for that. Thank you Apple!
- butz 8y agoStill using El Capitan on my iMac. Should I upgrade directly to Mojave, or wait a bit?
- yasp 8y agoAlso still using El Capitan, and wondering the same.
- IBM 8y agoThe rule has always been to wait for the first point update.
- dexterbt1 8y agoSame boat. I'm still on Sierra and still have concerns as a colleague on High Sierra almost hosed his system with APFS. Any stability issues on the new file system?
- chrisfinazzo 8y agoIt's been mostly fine on High Sierra, but I did have one instance where my inodes went wonky. Had to restore from backups as Disk Utility couldn't do anything with it. HFS+ was terrible, but at least I knew most of the ways in which it was terrible.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoPeople bitch and moan about HFS+ but I've never found anything particularly objectionable about it, even after writing several filesystem utilities on top of it. I've always found Spotlight to be utter garbage, but that's not the fault of HFS+.
- chrisfinazzo 8y agoOK, so you're not just spewing nonsense, but it bears repeating that the internals of HFS+ were horribly dated towards the end of its life. This prevented them from adding features or fixing bugs in a way that would be forward looking. The system requirements for HFS and HFS+ reflected this and partially explain why there was little progress for literally years at a time. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2011/07/mac-os-x-10-7/12/#hfs-problems https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2011/07/mac-os-x-10-7/12/#hf... Eventually, you have to start over.
- whalesalad 8y agoDirect download link: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/macos-mojave/id1398502828?mt=12 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/macos-mojave/id1398502828?mt...
- kccqzy 8y ago> But Core Storage, the technology responsible for keeping the most frequently accessed files on the SSD, can only see data on your drive at the block level, not the file level. It can’t tell the difference between an app that needs to be launched quickly or a document that doesn’t need a lot of extra speed; all it can see is how frequently blocks are accessed. APFS changes that. Fusion Drives can now move files to the SSD based not just on how frequently they’re accessed, but also based on how much the type of file will benefit from an SSD. APFS will store all file metadata on your SSD, too, speeding up Spotlight searches and metadata lookups in the Get Info window. Can someone more knowledgeable than me explain how in the world this is an improvement? The old Core Storage model perfectly makes sense to me: it strictly operates beneath the level of a file system, combining multiple physical volumes into a logical volume family which contains a logical volume. It moves blocks between SSD and HDD using frequency of access. Now, why should we suddenly need to look at the type of file to determine which block device to store the data? Even if it's an application, but if it's not frequently used, why should we keep it on SSD? And filesystem metadata should be even more obvious. Since basically all file operations need the directory entries and the inode information, the old Core Storage-based system will automatically move them to the SSD. Why do we need to explicitly tell the filesystem to do this? Overall this feels like a step backward to me. I like systems that are dynamic and self-adjusting, not those with hard-coded rules and heuristics. Also I'm a bit disappointed as the author, while producing a fine review to read, didn't quite do the deep-dive I had expected for a system that's arguably the most important in an OS—a system in charge of storing user data.
- monocasa 8y agoJust in general, when optimizing for different latency use cases, looking at averages falls flat in a lot of cases. For instance you probably want fast startup, but how often does the startup code get executed?
- coldtea 8y ago>Now, why should we suddenly need to look at the type of file to determine which block device to store the data? We don't "need" to, it's an extra optimization. >Even if it's an application, but if it's not frequently used, why should we keep it on SSD? Because if we have the space to spare on the SSD, we'd appreciate the faster launch when we do try to use that app. And for other types of files it can now decide to move them or not move them based on the benefit from the faster load, not just the frequency of access (and thus optimize the SSD use).
- qwerty456127 8y agoWhat are the pros and cons of upgrading to Mojave for a hacker using a Mid-2013 MacBook Air? Is that true that Mojave looks ugly on non-retina displays, won't allow your scripts to access some stuff previous versions allowed, integrates with Apple's internet services and DRMs more tightly and can have problems with playing old Windows games like Fallout 3 with Wine?
- Eric_WVGG 8y agoYou can preview "ugly" by turning off "Use LCD font smoothing where available" and restarting any app to check it out. It's subjective, lots of folks complained about subpixel being ugly when it was first introduced. The Apple iCloud stuff is still optional. A "hacker" should have no trouble with the Terminal commands necessary to disable SIP. Dunno about Fallout but Boot Camp and VMWare are still around.
- qwerty456127 8y agoThanks. > Boot Camp and VMWare are still around At least it's too space-consuming to maintain a separate Windows system on a 128 GiB SSD, Wine/CrossOver feels a better solution in the cases where it can manage.
- poyu 8y agoBetter yet, use SteamPlay https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/ https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/
- nil_pointer 8y agoThe ugly font issue for non-retina displays is real, luckily there's a workaround to revert it how it used to be: defaults -currentHost write -globalDomain AppleFontSmoothing -int 3 defaults write -g CGFontRenderingFontSmoothingDisabled -bool false
- ino 8y agoI've installed mojave on that same computer model and the font smoothing switch is there, and the pixels look the same as before, which is great. Nothing has changed. Maybe they only removed the switch on retina macs.
- Apocryphon 8y agoIs this the new El Capitan, which was the new Snow Leopard?
- saagarjha 8y agoIt’s very stable, if that’s what you’re asking.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIs the reworked App Store faster? I always wonder how they could make it so slow without any feedback while it navigates between pages.
- cs02rm0 8y agoSubjectively, yes, I think it is.
- Androider 8y agoIt's faster, but still incredulously slow. For example, when you launch it it's just a black rectangle for 3-5 seconds (2018 Macbook Pro). And the UX is all over the place, with 3-4 different ways to go back/close whatever you're looking at. The way you navigate reviews with side-swipes might sense on a phone but makes no sense whatsoever on the Mac. You can tell it's made to spec and with zero developer love softening the rough corners, because no developer who cares would make a full-screen screenshot view mode you cannot exit with Esc.
- kkarakk 8y ago>The way you navigate reviews with side-swipes might sense on a phone but makes no sense whatsoever on the Mac. it makes complete sense, I switched over to mac in 2017 and as I got used to the gestures I tried them everywhere. if i'd found one place where they didn't work I would have abandoned them. the side swipes also work in Netflix on chrome on Mac. I really LOVE this aspect of the mac. gestures are functionally useless on windows coz of the uber patchy support for them....
- andrewmcwatters 8y agoLooking at the recent news about Marzipan, I'm fairly certain the App Store we got is actually the iOS App Store. There's so many iOS design motif quirks.
- tom_ 8y agoObviously too late for this article, but here's a general tip: if you're going to show a bunch of comparison screen grabs, or before/after screen shots, and the like - e.g., https://arstechnica.com/features/2018/09/macos-10-14-mojave-the-ars-technica-review/12/#h3 https://arstechnica.com/features/2018/09/macos-10-14-mojave-... - don't put a scroll effect in. Don't put a fade down then fade up effect in. It makes it too hard to see the difference. Just flick instantly between one and the next. (Possibly related: https://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2012/02/15/why-does-adobe-photoshop-differentiate-between-undo-and-step-backwards/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2012/02/15/why-does-adobe...)
- Stratoscope 8y agoThat reminds me of something that happened when I was working at Adobe around 2002. A coworker saw me using PaintShop Pro to sort through a few photos, and he said, "But... What? You work for Adobe!" I explained, "I'd love to use Photoshop, but it fails to do the very first thing I need when I look at a batch of photos I shot in burst mode: flip back and forth between them to see which is best." PSP let me flip between two photos instantly so I could see which I liked; Photoshop couldn't do that. Every time I used Ctrl+Tab to switch photos, it first drew a placeholder checkerboard across the entire screen, and then it slowly pulled in the new photo block by block. Of course, there was probably some good technical reason for this: maybe some legacy Photoshop code designed for even older computers with little memory. But that didn't help me. The funny thing about your (valid!) complaint is that browsers are perfectly capable of doing the right thing for you when you replace one image with another - an instant visual swap. But instead, people add scrolling and fading and other effects just to show off how "designy" their site is.
- Amygaz 8y agoIf you want a webby award, that’s what is needed.
- kccqzy 8y ago> Let’s talk Gatekeeper first. In High Sierra, Gatekeeper controls access to Location Services, Contacts, Calendars, Reminders, and Photos—any app that wants access to any of that data needs to ask for it and be granted permission first, and the app should fail over gracefully (i.e. not crash) when that permission is denied. This is just wrong. Gatekeeper is not the iOS-like privacy controls. It's about enforcing apps to be from the MAS or identified developers. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491
- chrisfinazzo 8y agoTechnically, Andrew's still in the clear as Gatekeeper is a system facility for controlling what can be installed and run on your machine. Permissions for access to system services and app databases is the only thing that's changed.
- saagarjha 8y agoTCC, which manages this access, is not a public-facing feature. Hence the reuse of GateKeeper.
- throwanem 8y agoDoes it fix the hard crash/freeze issues around hibernation and FileVault? That's pretty much all I care about; I _really do not like_ having to choose between running a laptop without FDE and having to spend ten minutes going from zero to usable every time I stick the stupid thing in my backpack for more than fifteen minutes.
- Spartan-S63 8y agoI run with full disk encryption and have never had this issue. I've never heard of this issue either. So, it just happens when your laptop goes into hibernation with FileVault enabled?
- throwanem 8y agoYeah. Two laptops, actually, one whose FileVault activation preceded the upgrade, one whose did not. Doesn’t matter which hibernation mode I use, 3 or 25 - either way, it reliably fails to either sleep or awaken cleanly; not sure which, but the wake is a cold boot with no state restoration.
- m_eiman 8y agoI had something similar, and IIRC it was fixed by reformatting the drive. Tedious, but Time Machine helps.
- makecheck 8y agoThe pop-up permission boxes don’t make a great first impression since I saw at least 5 of them within 2 minutes and they tended to have really obscure descriptions like access to “System Events”. While probably technically much more difficult, maybe they could have the first Mojave launch of every app occur in a separate and invisible “everything allowed” area, where the system just pretends to allow things and tracks everything that the app did on launch that would require permission. And then, it can display one box with a summary of features that seem to be required for that app, relaunching the app in the real system sandbox if approved.
- saagarjha 8y agoHow would the system simulate user interaction required to get to a point where the popup would be necessary?
- rbanffy 8y agoAn application could access the protected APIs it needs during a first run in order to force the authorization dialogs. If I were designing an API for that, I'd allow a single call to declare as many permissions as needed, so all authorization dialogs would be triggered at once.
- saagarjha 8y agoBut then you just have a model where an app asks for a dozen permissions upfront, which may not even make sense in context. For example, should your bank's app (assuming it had one) get camera access? On the surface this seems a bit strange, until you realize that it has check scanning functionality.
- jedieaston 8y agoYou could pop up a box that says "Bank of America is asking for access to the following parts of your Mac:" Followed by a table with the function (I.e Camera, mic), a description from the developer about why, and a checkbox to accept or deny.
- plussed_reader 8y agoDoes APFS still run like dog feces on a spinning platter drive in 10.13? I have a bunch of older iMacs I have stuck at 10.12 for this reason.
- close04 8y agoThere's no reason to stay on 10.12 to avoid APFS. I tried a fresh install of 10.13 with APFS on a hard drive. I wasn't happy at all with the performance especially at boot (for some reason). So I started over and went with HFS+. I have no idea if APFS on Mojave behaves better but if it doesn't force the file system upgrade (didn't check this yet) I see no reason to avoid Mojave. APFS would make a lot more sense on an SSD but even with 0 improvement (excluding visible performance drops here) at storage level the other features alone should make the upgrade worth it.
- yborg 8y agoIs it possible to upgrade without upgrading the boot filesystem to APFS? I have a Fusion Drive, and don't have high confidence Apple got this right.
- chmaynard 8y agoProbably not. I wouldn't be too concerned, I've heard that the file system engineering team at Apple is extremely good. For example, they pulled off the conversion from HFS to APFS in iOS without a hitch.
- LeoPanthera 8y ago> don't have high confidence Apple got this right I'd love to know why. The transition to APFS for all other devices has been utterly seamless. Apple probably has a whole filesystem team. I wonder if you have any special qualifications to justify why you think you know better?
- yborg 8y ago>for all other devices Yes, the solid state storage for which it is designed. The Fusion Drive by definition includes rotating media and compounds this problem by involving 2 devices in a common logical storage device. The APFS support for Fusion Drives was pulled from High Sierra for reasons that were never explained so there were apparently issues, and without knowing what those were it is impossible to evaluate how likely it is that these were all resolved now.
- mr_toad 8y agoThey could have pulled it from Mojave too if they felt there were still issues.
- yborg 8y agoWell, took a backup and decided to go for it. You don't get a choice, it converts the boot filesystem to APFS. Took about 3 hours on a very full 1.5 TB Fusion Drive, but converted successfully. We'll see how it goes.
- saagarjha 8y ago> I wish the easy-to-use app icon wasn’t tucked away in the Utilities folder, but it does do a considerably better job of exposing screenshot and screen recording options that have been a part of the Mac for years. Command+Shift+5? > The way the Kids These Days are customizing their email is with emoji Kids These Days don't use email. Or at least, often, that is.
- protomyth 8y agoIf you use AppleScript to automate your finder, then I would wait a bit until you have a really good idea how much work it is going to be to change things to meet the new security changes. It is a non-trivial operation. Also, I should probably give up any hope of Apple fixing any scripting errors in the Finder since its still broken since Mavericks.
- zbentley 8y agoThis is a very good review, but it still makes me miss the ones John Siracusa wrote. He was(is!) a great writer, programmer, and colleague (separately, of course). Hope he's up to something fun!
- unspecified 8y agoIf you're into podcasting, give ATP[1] a shot: John is one of the three hosts. The other hosts are Casey Liss and Marco Arment (developer of Overcast). John also has some other podcasts like Robot or Not[2] and Reconcilable Differences[3], but ATP is by far my personal favorite. [1] http://atp.fm/ http://atp.fm/ [2] https://www.theincomparable.com/robot/ https://www.theincomparable.com/robot/ [3] https://www.relay.fm/rd https://www.relay.fm/rd
- pippy 8y ago>ending support for 32 bit apps >deprecating openGL My opinion on APIs have gone from new and bleeding edge to 'support it till the sun burns out'. Computers and meant to work. on linux or mac, no executable over 5 years old seems to work. But if download a .exe from the early 90's on a PC, it often just works. In 100 years, the windows API and .exe are going to be the lingua franca of programs. there are many indications this is happening, valve baking WINE into steam, the fragmented package managers on linux, and no common runtime environment taking off.
- chillacy 8y agoWhy would that be the case instead of programs following power/popularity like natural languages do? After all the lingua Franca of the world isn’t French anymore, despite its romance origins and therefore high “backwards compatibility” with Latin.
- rgovostes 8y agoCuriously enough, “Lingua Franca” doesn’t refer to French.
- mr_toad 8y agoWindows is a desktop OS, and the desktop is dying. In 100 years I’d say the chance of anything running Windows would be about the same as the likelihood of it running VMS.
- pjmlp 8y agoLaptops and 2-1 are the new desktop, and the large majority runs Windows.
- jsgo 8y agoI love my MacBook Pro. Really, I do. And chances are, I'll probably use some iteration of a PC (in this case, I use an eGPU so I could replace my desktop entirely) until I, well, stop using hardware. I also use macOS and Windows on it. That being said, I will eventually die. Now, the question becomes what are the people that follow after me going to be using. I have kids in school: both use Chromebooks for school work, in one case a PS4 for gaming, and hand-me-down iPhones/iPhone SEs for social, gaming, and the like. Could they eventually need a PC? Possibly, depending on their career path/interests and the level of support for iPads, Chromebooks, etc. at the time. But they don't need it now. And I know people who are my age and older who limit themselves to iPhones/iPads for technology beyond the TV. None of these things are running Windows.
- dirtylowprofile 8y agoOn my MBP 2012 on every boot up the screen will flicker and I guess this is just old age and normal? I guess this is the last update on 2012 model. Also noticed the resolution is a little bit brighter and nicer for an old MBP.
- bradgessler 8y agoThe screenshot annotation UI is an abomination. It’s some weird mish-mash of buttons that feels like a word processor instead of a really simple tool that’s just an arrow + text with a white outline (like Skitch). I really hope this gets fixed.
- mrcnkoba 8y agoI'm surprised that MacOS 10.14 release came almost unnoticed on HN.
- super_mario 8y agoAnyone else find dark mode stark? It was a bit shocking to see it and very jarring after almost 2 decades of looking at various shades of sliver/gray menubar and dock. I now kind of miss the ability to have only dock, menubar, notifications side bar, spotlight and HUD for brightness, volume be black. This mode offered a great balance between classic window chrome and the too much brightness you now get in "light" appearance mode. I find I can't work in dark mode during daytime. Way too many reflections and reading mail and PDFs in preview are too jarring. Black, beside white makes each other stand out so much. I think macOS is now least polished it has ever been.