4 ms·
I've experienced this pushback against the algorithm firsthand. I work in NLP, and I was asked to write a script to select data for annotation based on a number
by ashelmire 8y ago
I've experienced this pushback against the algorithm firsthand. I work in NLP, and I was asked to write a script to select data for annotation based on a number of criteria, including some automated balancing of a few factors. It turns out, this was very unsatisfying to some. It led to questions like "why is this document being selected, but not this one?" without an answer that was really satisfying. I ended up changing it to give total control to the person running the script, and removed the self-balancing feature. Since then, I pushback against any sort of black-box auto-selection sort of ideas, because I know that, while they might result in faster and ultimately equivalent results, people want control.
- jstarfish 8y agoPeople don't want control so much as those answers you yourself didn't get. Nothing is more infuriating than not being told why you're being punished, why someone got accepted into a school when you didn't, or why a judge won't consider your appeal. We can even handle injust answers-- "his parents are alumni that donate a lot of money." That sucks, but it's the answer. But we can't handle not knowing. Denying people the ability to reason is one of the cruelest things you can do to them. The Amish figured this out centuries ago.