4 ms·
Well, it is nice to see someone going straight for the details. Do we have any context on why this ... short novel :) ... was written? I want to interpret this
by roenxi 8y ago
Well, it is nice to see someone going straight for the details. Do we have any context on why this ... short novel :) ... was written?
I want to interpret this as a coinciding of two things; the first that the "Socratic Method" as described here would be a powerful method of creating and perpetuating a culture amongst law students trained at Harvard; where their opinions and beliefs are subjected to a very public examination and then reshaped to be what the professors think they should be. Not a terrible idea, that seems like a valid interpretation of what teaching should be, with many warts as noted.
And the second is the philosophy that gets mentioned a few times in the article that there are topics that are “too hot to handle” that might "injure" a student. Part of the fringe push to redefine "injury" to mean hearing something unpleasant or disagreeable.
So my assumption is that the author sees a crisis approaching the law school where it must take a stand on what its objective is - preserving a culture, relaying uncontroversial material to students, or some other path. And then this pdf is balanced factual synthesis of the issues at hand - I'm not sure the author is even proffering a conclusion.
If that assumption holds then there are some points raised here that could have profound influences in 10 or 20 years. Law students eventually become lawyers then judges, and unfortunately the US political class seems to be sourced heavily from the lawyers (~40% of Congress, I think). If confrontation is de-emphasised in the classroom, that could have spillovers into the heart of how political debate and distribution of justice is undertaken.
But I don't know enough about "Jeannie Suk Gersen" or why she wrote this to form a strong opinion on the topic apart from wishing lawyers were trained to write reports.
- mirimir 8y agoIANAL, and so have no opinion on the merits of her article. However, I have concerns about "topics that are 'too hot to handle'" in the sciences. For example, a recent thread[0] about Hill (2017) An elementary mathematical theory for the variability hypothesis.[1,2,3] And by the way, there's lots of great discussion in the comments on the Quillette article.[1] And it's interesting that the deleted NYJM paper is online.[2] So what, are there now two different papers at New York J. Math. 23 (2017) that begin at p. 1641? Strange. edit: Earlier versions of the preprint were apparently more controversial.[4] 0) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17938318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17938318 1) https://quillette.com/2018/09/07/academic-activists-send-a-published-paper-down-the-memory-hole/ https://quillette.com/2018/09/07/academic-activists-send-a-p... 2) http://nyjm.albany.edu/j/2017/23-72v-orig.pdf http://nyjm.albany.edu/j/2017/23-72v-orig.pdf 3) https://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.04184.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.04184.pdf 4) https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.04184v2 https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.04184v2
- mirimir 8y agoAnd more generally, it can be difficult now to research possible differences among protected categories, such as genders, races or sexual orientations. There are exceptions, for sure, such as differences in response to diet recommendations, medical treatment, or drug therapy. But otherwise, it can be a minefield. Student protests. Difficulty with funding. Tenure blocks. Difficulty publishing. There's failure to make a key distinction, here. Sexism or racism involve judging people on the basis of their gender or race. But that's not the case for experimental studies of differences. There are, of course, confounding issues that complicate interpretation of results. Humans are so readily programmable that it's very difficult, and perhaps impossible, to attribute any observed differences to biological hardware vs cultural influence. But that's just something for the discussion. It's not a valid reason to block the work. Also, the idea that some work shouldn't be done, because it upsets or discourages some protected group, is very dangerous. It's contrary to the overall concept of experimental science. And yes, there are parallels to nuclear research back in the day, and to machine-learning and AI work now. But even there, refusing to look seems ultimately destructive.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't take HN threads off topic into generic ideological tangents. Those are predictable and tedious.
- pjc50 8y agoIt's a law review article, looks about 14000 words. This fulfils roughly the same professional role as science papers, except because this is law the core activity is to advance an argument through references and narrative. It's the same kind of size and complexity as a doctoral thesis except that as a professional you're expected to produce them a bit quicker, say 1-2 months of work. It's probably the minimum necessary for a serious investigation of the topic, rather than a glib condemnation of trigger warnings.
- mirimir 8y ago> It's the same kind of size and complexity as a doctoral thesis except that as a professional you're expected to produce them a bit quicker, say 1-2 months of work. As I recall, it only took me about two months to write my PhD thesis. The hard part, which took a few years, was finding an interesting question, and collecting the requisite data. And also, getting up to speed on some decades of literature. But subsequent papers didn't take much more than a few months each.
- mistrial9 8y agohmm .. there is something badly missing in this response.. The word 'trauma' has a serious medical meaning aside from whatever this paper says.. The quick associations encoded above in 'Part of the fringe push to redefine "injury" to mean hearing something unpleasant or disagreeable.' is not only accusatory via some unspoken point of view, but also dismisses the medical definitions of trauma.