5 ms·
I'm not sure I could define it as intentional and nefarious but I definitely find Google search results to be markedly worse over the last few years. It used to
by ehnto 8y ago
I'm not sure I could define it as intentional and nefarious but I definitely find Google search results to be markedly worse over the last few years. It used to be really competent at finding specialist/technical results but lately it's gotten more generic and less useful. It's possible that's actually the nature of content creation these days, with everyone hyper optimising to please the Google search algorithm. But it's resulting in a less useful web for me. Certainly a less interesting one.
Same thing with Youtube, the algorithms seem to optimize for the lowest common denominator and all the interesting niche stuff is lost in thr noise.
Some of the solution is to do a better job of actively searching for good content instead of waiting for the algorithms to recommend it. But that itself has gotten harder too. Finding good content curators is hard.
- garyclarke27 8y agoAgreed - Particularly infuriating, is Google’s habit of returning search results with many missing terms, implying that they know whats best for me- ignoring a large part of my precisly crafted search input. I know there is Verbatim option, but this is another slow step and does not work in combination with valuable time filter. Wish there was an option to always use Verbatim and more default time filters such as 3 months, 6 months.
- ehnto 8y agoAbsolutely. That is one of my biggest pet peeves. There must be a threshold where it would rather give you well ranked but worse matching results over low-ranked but well matching results. That threshold seems to be too low hence the generic garbage results for really specific terms.
- fetbaffe 8y agoIt has become harder & harder to find videos on YouTube you know exist. Feels like the algorithm i geared to find new content rather to find what I'm looking for.
- mfukar 8y agoInteresting. I have the opposite experience. Searching to try and find _new_ content just presents me with videos/playlists I usually have already clicked/watched.
- cylinder 8y agoBasically all the results these days are just from news articles on other sites.
- ag71668 8y agoIt is absolutely intentional. Their goal is not to make the web useful for you, it's to make the web useful for themselves by manipulating what information you're exposed to. It is the mind-control wet dream. Google is guiding people to ideas that they like and preventing people from being exposed to those they don't. If you think that the Gun Rights thing is some kind of freak accident, consider that they also started outright censoring guns in the shopping page, with hilarious side effects like also censoring water guns. When talking about a multinational conglomerate that hires the world's best engineers, do not ever mistake malice for incompetence. https://www.businessinsider.com.au/google-shopping-bans-gun-searches-water-guns-guns-n-roses-2018-2?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com.au/google-shopping-bans-gun-...
- apatters 8y agoI believe a major reason for the widely observed decline in Google's SERP quality is that SEOs got too good at gaming the system. The Panda and Penguin updates a few years ago kicked off a trend of prioritizing content from highly authoritative domains (e.g. big brands) even when that content is less relevant to your search query. Google has been doubling down on this direction progressively--their justification being that people game the long tail by producing a lot of low quality, highly niched content. There may be no real solution to this within the context of Google's PageRank-inspired algorithm and this may be an opportunity for disruption.
- ehnto 8y agoI can definitely see that being part of the issue. Having been a dev in the boiler room for a few heavy SEO reliant domains, it was remarkable the kind of low quality articles people would spin and Google would eat up, especially before Penguin and Panda. The blame can't all be put on Google, the SEO industry is a dirty place that consistently pushed out small producers of genuine content in order to make a buck.