6 ms·
This is especially true today. I have seen a critique of Marvels infinity war where (spoilers) Thanos needs to "sacrifice that he loves the most" to gain a spe
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
This is especially true today. I have seen a critique of Marvels infinity war where (spoilers) Thanos needs to "sacrifice that he loves the most" to gain a special stone.
So he throws his daughter off a cliff, and cries as he does. He "loved" her.
People have pointed out that for an abused child sitting watching with her abuser, this reinforces the idea that the person who is harming her actually loves her ... a repulsive idea and perhaps as damaging as jumping off a roof with a towel.
I guess "with great power comes great responsibility"
PS
not being American Mr Rogers is a mystery to me - can anyone recommend a documentary / example ?
- kbenson 8y ago> People have pointed out that for an abused child sitting watching with her abuser, this reinforces the idea that the person who is harming her actually loves her Maybe. But maybe the story that the abuser doesn't care about the victim isn't actually accurate, even if it is more useful for resolving the problem. I think it's entirely possible that a large class of abuse happens from abusers that do love and care about the victims, but are so screwed up in their own mind that they can't help themselves. That does lead to the interesting question, does continually asserting to the victim that the abuser doesn't care lead to helping the issue faster than asserting that they might care, but by allowing the situation to continue it harms both the victim and the abuser, and the best way to improve both their lives is to be separated? Not that helping the abuser is the main goal, but if it helps to extricate the victim faster, that's a net win, and just because the abuser is not someone most people would find pity for doesn't mean they don't deserve some help fighting their own demons too. Not that I think that's necessarily true, but it would be interesting to know whether this is one more case where the common knowledge "best thing to do" is sub-optimal.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI flatly disagree - i think the word "love" has connotations of protection and putting their best interests first whatever is going on in the mind of a paedophile it is not love.
- LocalH 8y agoNobody else mentioned pedophilia. There are other forms of abuse that aren't sexual.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agowhatever else is going on in the mind of a paedophile / other abuser, it is not love.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 8y agoI'm sure we would all sleep much better at night assuming that's the case, but I'm not sure there's much basis to it besides wishful thinking. The fact that some people actually opt for chemical castration because they cannot control their urges leads me to believe that it's fairly deeply psychologically ingrained, and I'm not sure why a compulsion to do something somehow negates any other feeling a person might have. And this isn't a defense of pedophiles (which were not what I was envisioning when I mentioned abusers in my original comment), but it is an attempt at better understanding them. I think that's the best path for everyone involved, as if we understand them, perhaps we can stop them, and help them (preferably prior to any bad behavior), and then everyone is better off. Simply rationalizing that pedophiles do horrible things therefore they are horrible and evil people is a cop-out and will likely never actually fix the problem, as we've seen. I think that results in more victims and more people in prison. If we can prevent the crimes and help the people that would commit them be productive members of society that don't hurt anyone (preferably before they've hurt anyone), should we not do so? Are we not all better off with that outcome?
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI am not an expert, but I do not believe we have any framework for understanding paedophilia, let alone any category for all other forms of child abuse. There is a framework for understanding say schizophrenia, and so potential for a cure But without such a framework then I cannot see much progress - like downthread i say bank robbers are not bad all the time, abusers are not bad all the time. But the crime is enough to take action. Yes I would like a cure for abusers, just as a cure for robbers. Till then we should treat them all as crimes and prosecute accordingly
- watwut 8y ago> I think it's entirely possible that a large class of abuse happens from abusers that do love and care about the victims, but are so screwed up in their own mind that they can't help themselves. In that case, the abuse would be visible in public. If abuser is doing what he/she is doing in private only, then it reasonable to assume that abuser is in control.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI'm not sure the public/private distinction is meaningful. That's a pressure on the abuser too. We all do things in private we'd be frozen in shame at attempting to do in public. It doesn't mean we're 'in control'. It just means we're sometimes out of control, in private
- francisofascii 8y agoNot really. A person addicted to food, alcohol, porn, etc. is perfectly capable of keeping these addictions at bay in public, but lose control while in private.
- tomgp 8y agoKind of beside the point though when we're talking about a children's cartoon. A straightforward 'people who hurt other people don't love them' message is probably preferable.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoQuite right - i think you have to accept the limitations of your medium.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tokyodude 8y agoI'm not religious but isn't that a common story from Christianity? God sacrificing his son to save the world? Not religious and not saying there aren't other interpretations of that story but it is a common one.
- ctchocula 8y agoYeah, it seems a common trope in western culture. In the Iliad, Agamemnon leader of the Greeks does not get favourable wind that is needed for his armada to sail to Troy before he sacrifices his daughter who he loved.
- leetcrew 8y agoit's worth noting that this is considered a sin against the gods, and agamemnon is cursed for it.
- perilunar 8y agoAlso Abraham and his son Isaac.
- zaphar 8y agoTechnically, Jesus sacrifices himself willingly. The whole thing is pretty nuanced.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoPretty crazy. God sends his son down to ultimately sacrifice himself. Not clear who is in charge here. Then he 'sacrifices' himself by being arrested, charged and convicted. Then he dies(?) Then he's re-born. So, unsacrificed? Or didn't really die? Not like regular people anyway. Then he goes to heaven without dying again.
- moate 8y agoI mean technically Jesus is a human embodiment of God (according to the Council of Nicaea) so he is both himself and his Son. That whole story is a mindfuck and a logical nightmare. Right up there with the Tower of Babel when it comes to "What the fuck is this omnipotent, omniscient being fucking doing up there?!"
- dragonwriter 8y ago> People have pointed out that for an abused child sitting watching with her abuser, this reinforces the idea that the person who is harming her actually loves her Viewed another way, it validates the idea that an abuser can be a mortal risk even if he loves her, which, because quite often the abused in such a scenario already has a deep and unshakeable (and possibly accurate) belief that the abuser loves them, which leads them to discount the risk of escalation and try to manage the situation without escaping it, is potentially a more valuable message than repeating the “abuse is incompatible with love” message that society puts out through quite a lot of channels, and which promotes discounting abuse if you are convinced of love as much as the reverse.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI think that ends up saying "if only the child realised she would then be able to leave" as opposed to what I think we need "if only society at large realised, then we would put a stop to it" Sorry it's still abuse != love.
- afthonos 8y agoIt feels like you’re arguing definitions. If you had to restate “abuse != love” without using either word, how would you state it? I suspect you might find more people agree than this thread indicates.
- nextlevelwizard 8y agoIsn't Thanos the villain? Why is this any worse than Joker shooting Batman's parents or Snow White getting poisoned.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoBecause Thanos is the protagonist - it is his story, he drives the narrative. His desires (to collect the stones) is what causes all the action and reaction. We are asked by a story to place ourselves in the position of the protagonist- which is why reading Lolita is uncomfortable or worse. The killing Joke is the jokers story. Batman is just in it. Infinity war is Thanos story. The Avengers are just in it. So the decisions Thanos makes are important - especially in a under nuanced blockbuster as opposed to say Lolita as above.
- nextlevelwizard 8y agoI still don't get what the big deal is. It is just a movie. A 12 year old should be able to tell what is real and what is not. Kids are dumb, but maybe not as dumb as you make them out to be.
- CptFribble 8y agoLearning is more than rational examination of facts. A person whose mind is not fully developed, especially the rational emotional control portion, may still internalize something about how to behave without realizing it. Many people grow and change by merely being immersed in culture and behaviors that are different from their current selves, rather than holding everything at arm's length and saying "what is this, how does it affect me." This is especially relevant for young people, who have little control over their environment and who and what they interact with. Think back to your early years at school. How much of what you thought of the nature of the world around you was because of your particular school environment? How the teachers interacted with students? The emotional messaging in the posters on the wall? Most of us have no idea how much of that stuff formed who we are and what we think as adults, because growing up is a long and complicated process, and no one is fully aware of how they're changing day-to-day as 12 year olds. Many of us don't know how we're changing as adults.
- jakemauer 8y agoA documentary about Mr. Rogers was recently released, “Won’t you be my neighbor?” I highly recommend it, in a theater with other people if possible.
- yoshamano 8y agoThere was a documentary about him released this year I highly recommend called Won't You Be My Neighbor. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Won%27t_You_Be_My_Neighbor%3F_(film) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Won%27t_You_Be_My_Neighbor%3... As far as examples, here's an episode about divorce that I remember helping me deal with my parents' divorce when I was little. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xxbsV1XTFcA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xxbsV1XTFcA Or here's his speech to Congress fighting for funding for public television (it's more complicated than just funding for public television, but that's the basic idea). https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA Or one of my favorites, his acceptance speech for his lifetime achievement Emmy Award. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Upm9LnuCBUM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Upm9LnuCBUM
- chrisweekly 8y agoThanks for all the links. I was going to share that last one -- a contender for the greatest award acceptance speech of all time.
- watwut 8y agoI think that solution here would be to show point of view of sacrificed child too. She is getting nothing in exchange of sacrifice, has no choice and suffers more then him. Manga Berserk had this theme in it. It does not matter whether abuser loves his victim or not.
- CharlesW 8y ago> People have pointed out that for an abused child sitting watching with her abuser, this reinforces the idea that the person who is harming her actually loves her ... a repulsive idea and perhaps as damaging as jumping off a roof with a towel. Some good critiques of Infinity War's questionable messages: Let's Talk about Thanos - Movies with Mikey: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7Skq8UtJpY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7Skq8UtJpY Daddies in Film: Bad Dads [referenced by video above]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJ0nAkXOkMs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJ0nAkXOkMs
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoI have firsthand experience with abuse, and I think in many cases abusers do love those they harm. I don't see how acknowledging this makes abuse any more acceptable. In fact, I think often that's what makes abuse so hard on victims: they know that their feelings towards their abuser are real and they also see that their abuser often cares about them, and it is hard to reconcile this with how they are treated. I'm not an expert on this, but it seems to me a better way to frame it is something like: loving someone doesn't excuse being treated this way.
- GuiA 8y agoWhat does it mean, to “love” someone? Is it a prescriptive phenomenon - where if I say I love you, then we must take it at face value regardless of my actions towards you? Or is it a more descriptive thing, where my acts may show that I love you even though I may never tell you the words “I love you” explicitly as such? Or is the act of “loving” a purely self centered one - where my love is purely a means to fulfill my own needs (of wanting to be desired, appreciated, needed, respected, empowered, etc)?
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoI don't think it makes sense to try to define "love" independently of a relationship between two people. If person B says person A loves them, then that it a good indication that A does in fact love B, particularly if person A would agree with that statement as well.
- mindgam3 8y agoI also have extensive experience with chronic abuse. I would argue strongly that abusers do not love those they harm. Abuse is not an expression of love. If you want to argue that abusers think they are loving those they harm, perhaps because they don't know any better, perhaps because they themselves received abuse disguised as "love" during their formative years, then I could agree with that. But love doesn't cause harm to people. Full stop. Not even "tough love". In my experience it has actually been quite liberating to realize that AbuserX does not and did not love me. It's really confusing to be in this middle ground where I think they love me and yet they continue to deliberately harm me. This leads to a very twisted version of love that exposes one to more dysfunctional, abusive relationships that repeat the original cycle. Break the cycle. Repeat after me. If somebody is abusing you, it's not love.
- mcculley 8y agoThis was taught to me in elementary school (among other things: https://enki.org/2018/07/30/things-i-learned-in-elementary-school/ https://enki.org/2018/07/30/things-i-learned-in-elementary-s...) as Genesis 22.
- zspade 8y agoThis really has been a common theme through mythology though. One needs to look no further than Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his son on god's word. I'm not saying this is good, quite the opposite, but it seems to reflect a dark theme in humanity. The ones most likely to hurt you are your loved ones. Of course our media is going to reflect that. At the end of the day some parental digression is required here, and if you do take your child to see this film, it may open up a good opportunity for an earnest conversation about healthy and unhealthy relationships.