3 ms·
> it is possible that such a conclusion [God exists] can be arrived at rationally ... starting from teleology [purposeful Universe] as an assumption. I agree a
by carapace 8y ago
> it is possible that such a conclusion [God exists] can be arrived at rationally ... starting from teleology [purposeful Universe] as an assumption.
I agree and indeed I did something like that: I built a model of God based on the assumptions that feedback exists and time is eventually transcended by humans or other sentients through technology or other means. I eventually discarded that model, but it was arrived at rationally.
> Because this is possible, you cannot rationally conclude that a person is irrational just because they believe in God.
I agree[1], however, I didn't do that. OP's father isn't irrational because he believes in God, he is irrational because he thinks God makes fake fossils. It's a concept of God so foolish as to disprove itself. If it were possible to mock God this would surely be the way to do it. The Flying Spaghetti Monster has more dignity.
[1] I am rational and I believe in God, so it would be hypocritical of me to claim that a person is irrational just because they believe in God.
- lisper 8y ago> he is irrational because he thinks God makes fake fossils You can't know that without knowing how he arrived at that conclusion. You cannot judge the rationality or irrationality of conclusion simply by looking at the conclusion. When you do so, you are making the exact same mistake that atheists make when they look at you and decide that you must be irrational simply because you believe in Satya Sai Baba.
- carapace 8y agoSorry, I was using that as a kind of short-hand and obscured my meaning. That particular belief is a symptom of the underlying irrationality of his belief-structure but not in itself necessarily arrived at irrationally in the general case, eh? > You can't know that without knowing how he arrived at that conclusion. In this case we do know how he arrived at that conclusion and we know that it was due to a form of reasoning that obviates itself, that his reasoning is irrational, that he is, in fact, not reasoning by his own admission. I can't say whether or not this religion is working for OP's father, but I can (and do) say that it is irrational, because it is irrational in its structure. Anyway, he doesn't have to reason correctly because (his) God(-image) does not require it, He is content with irrational faith.