3 ms·
I've never understood why this is an issue. If I'm god, and I'm creating a planet for humans, and I made humans the curious beings that they are, would I: a)
by gpm 8y ago
I've never understood why this is an issue.
If I'm god, and I'm creating a planet for humans, and I made humans the curious beings that they are, would I:
a) Create an earth that is boring with no history to dig into and explore
b) Create a rich and storied history with things for them to wonder at
Now, I mean, if I was god I would chose option b. Even in the alternate reality where I would personally chose option a I don't see any reason to think that the actual god couldn't have chosen option b.
I'm not religious or well versed in Christianity, but I'm not aware of any reason why option b is inconsistent with the bible (the one possible exception is the flood story, but that is easily explained away by god fixing the earth afterwards).
- aggie 8y agoYour argument is a plausible retcon of the bible, but the "God made it that way" mechanism is essentially infinitely flexible and unfalsifiable. The problem with that is for many people, falsifiability is an important aspect of evidence-based belief (judged by predictive or explanatory value). Even if your explanation for why there are fossils etc. sounds sort of reasonable, if you grant this reinterpretation of the Christian creation myth, you've established that the goalposts can be moved, and from there you can find a way to move them for just about anything. Imagine we uncover a convincing, contemporaneous writing of Jesus' proclamation that he is merely a human. You could say, "Well God put that writing there to test our faith."
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI think the issue is how one is valued over the other. Science's "proof" is based on an assumption(s), and then faith is put into those. To say to someone of religious faith "you can't bbe right because we have proof" completely overlooks science's base assumption, and dismiss the possibilty that said assumption(s) might be off target. Yes. It's a fine line. None the less faith is faith regardless of how well you rationalize it.
- sofal 8y agoScience's "assumption" is that you can understand the world through repeated and verifiable observation. Faith, on the other hand, is the excuse people give for believing in something when they don't have a good reason.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI have a similar argument / belief. Simply put, if God was able to create "the heaven and the earth" - an effort that is well beyond our (limited) imaginations - then adding in some doodads (e.g., fossils) and whatnots (e.g., what appears to be geographic history) is a relative piece of cake. I believe to think otherwise is naive and lacks imagination. I mentioned this possibility to an atheist friend of mine and it stopped him in his tracks. Note: I'm also not heavily religiou by any means. But the odds of there being things beyond our imagination and beyond our knowledge are extremely possible. As a side note, I find it kinda funny that Elon Musk can says (paraphrasing) "we live in a world created by someone / something we cannot see and we ultimately cannot understand" and no one gets upset. But isn't that presumption the basis of most theoism-based religions? No offense, but Some Musk states the obvious and that suddenly profound. Maybe I'm missing something?