2 ms·
>But just like a contract, where the sides don’t agree, one is entitled to have the contract enforced as written. Where in the Constitution does it say that?
by krapp 8y ago
>But just like a contract, where the sides don’t agree, one is entitled to have the contract enforced as written.
Where in the Constitution does it say that?
Because if it doesn't, then the entitlement you're describing doesn't exist as far as it's concerned.
- rayiner 8y agoThe Constitution is a law, and that’s how laws work. Either follow it or agree to change it. The Constitution has a whole provision explaining how to change it—that would be irrelevant if it contemplated people just ignoring it when they didn’t like the result.
- cuboidGoat 8y agoOne thing about how laws work, is that they only become facts on the ground, so to speak, in the interpretation. Courts change the followed interpretation of law all the time without amending the written law. Often the written law only gets amended when the difference between the definition on paper and the definition in common practice can no longer be bent any further, after decades of plain conflict in language.
- rayiner 8y ago> Courts change the followed interpretation of law all the time without amending the written law. They should not do that either. That’s an usurpation of the legislature’s powers and an affront to democracy.
- cuboidGoat 8y agoIf you wanted them to stop, you'd have to change the law so as to disallow interpretation, as the law as written already codifies that the law can be critically interpreted by courts. However I am not sure how that would even work, given the law is in language and language must be interpreted to elucidate meaning from it in the first place. Even if you fixed the first interpretation as sacrosanct, you would then have to interpret that interpretation each time.