7 ms·
Your father's beliefs are not necessarily irrational, they are just based on different assumptions. Your assumption is that the order in the universe arises fr
by lisper 8y ago
Your father's beliefs are not necessarily irrational, they are just based on different assumptions. Your assumption is that the order in the universe arises from causality and physical law. His assumption is that the order in the universe arises from purpose, i.e. he believes in teleology. That is not in and of itself irrational.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoThis is a little confused. A theist could easily say that the 'universe arises from causality and physical law', but that God set in motion those laws (deism). A popular form of proto-biology in the early nineteenth century, 'natural theology', committed itself to studying the natural world because it believed that God's divine genius was manifest in its splendour, intricacy, and so on. Also, one could say that the 'universe arises from casuality and physical law', and observes a teleological direction. Most Enlightenment philosophers in the eighteenth century believed that both were true.
- lisper 8y agoSure. I don't see how anything you said is at odds with what I said.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoWell it is. Your implied opposition was that theology is based upon teleology; atheism upon a belief in physical laws. But a atheist could believe the former, and a theologian the latter. So it hardly works.
- lisper 8y ago> Your implied opposition was that theology is based upon teleology No. Not "is". Could be. Big difference.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoNot to be pedantic, but you say 'is' in both relevant clauses: 'Your assumption is that the order in the universe arises from causality and physical law. His assumption is that the order in the universe arises from purpose, i.e. he believes in teleology'
- lisper 8y agoThat's right. The OP's father assumes [1] teleology and reasons from there to theology. But I'm not saying that if you start with teleology you necessarily end up with theology, only that you can en up there without being irrational. By way of contrast, it is much harder to rationally get to theology without starting with teleology (though not impossible). So most atheists simply reject teleology out of hand, and then go on to conclude that theism must be irrational. It's not. --- [1] Of course I have no idea whether or not this is actually true. I'm just presuming. But it's a plausible presumption that is true of many religious people even if it happens not to be true in this particular case.
- carapace 8y agoI disagree, the belief system as described is strictly irrational, in the sense that its fundamental assumptions contain a inconsistency that then permits one to prove anything. (I.e. A = not A therefore anything.) It's a case of a mind trained into a kind of cul-de-sac with no way out. For some people this keeps them on the straight and narrow, for others it runs them smack into a wall. But it is certainly irrational to believe in a Divine Omnipotent Creator who plays crude tricks on you.
- lisper 8y ago> its fundamental assumptions contain a inconsistency Really? What is it?
- carapace 8y agoWell, rumcajz points out Bertrand Russell's objection, and apocalypstyx presents a fascinating aspect of the matter too, but the problem I'm talking about is the nature of implication/causation itself. Rationality rests on implication.[1] The system we're talking about literally has "GOD -> anything" as an axiom, so it's useless for reasoning. If GOD -> (A -> B) for all A, B, and "->" then you can literally "prove" that anything implies anything else, or that everything implies God, but you can't disprove anything at all. Saying that there's a part of the system that can change anything about the system is essentially saying that there's no system at all. "Black is white and you get run over at the next zebra crossing." If you believe that God will play tricks on you then you have nothing external to rely on. Again, this can be good or bad for a given person depending on their context. It's useless for reasoning, but you don't actually have to e.g. believe in Dinosaurs to reach God, so in that sense having no ability to rationalize can be a benefit if it prevents spiritual doubts. But many people instead are simply trapped in impoverished world-models. To wit: the Universe as revealed by scientific investigation redounds to the Glory of God far more than, say, the concepts of "young-earthers", or people who believe God a trickster. [1] This is actually the one article of faith at the foundation of reason and rationality: that the Universe is comprehensible in terms of causation. The OP's father's god-image is jealous of even this wane and paltry rival.
- sofal 8y agoOn the contrary, there are no additional assumptions that need to be made in order to reject the idea that the universe was created by a being. Physical laws are not assumed to be an authority that dictates how the universe works. They are just descriptions and models based on what we've observed so far, which means they can be updated based on further observations. In other words, if we were to observe evidence of a powerful being, then our descriptions and models would then need to take that into account. Until then, there is no justification for making that assumption.
- lisper 8y agoFirst of all, your introduction of "a being" is a straw man. I never said anything about a "being". All I said was that teleology, i.e. the assumption that existence has purpose, is not irrational. Second, physical laws are not "just" descriptions and models based on observation. Any finite data set is consistent with an infinite number of theories. To whittle down that infinite set you need additional assumptions. Some people choose teleology, some don't. But there's no rational argument one way or the other.
- sofal 8y agoYour comment was in defense of the rationality of believing that a god, specifically the Christian god, planted fossil evidence in order to test our ability to discount it entirely. Now you're saying that this God character doesn't follow from this "purpose" and that invoking that idea is suddenly a straw man outside of this discussion? Purpose is not something that exists outside of the minds of creatures that can harbor intent. It is inherently subjective, and is often intersubjective. We generally agree on the purpose of the specialized tools we create, but not because the purpose is an inherent property of the tool. Even if the universe was created by a race of gods or pixies or what have you, the purpose they had for it would not necessarily be shared by us. Actually physical laws are just descriptions and models. To whittle them down you must remove additional assumptions, not add. The fewer assumptions needed to explain the evidence, the better the model. There may be additional data out there that ends up poking holes in our models, in which case we respond by revising the model. Some of the better models we've come up with have actually made surprisingly accurate predictions. It is rational to base your beliefs on consistent and verified observations, rather than our fanciful imagination.
- shrimpx 8y agoIf this is rational, it's based on a useless logic: a logic that allows arbitrarily introducing new facts and rules. e:True for arbitrary e. This is why arguing with christians is mostly a fools errand.
- lisper 8y ago> it's based on a useless logic It helps a lot of people deal with existential despair and thereby get through the day. That's not useless.
- sofal 8y agoIt's useless for figuring out what is true. You are right that not everyone cares about that, in which case logic has no real use for them.
- lisper 8y ago> It's useless for figuring out what is true. Only if teleology is false, which you cannot prove rationally. If teleology is in fact true, then assuming it is true can be very useful for figuring out what is true.
- sofal 8y agoBeing rational is not about proving every fanciful idea false. It's about not believing in things without rational justification. You can't simply propose an unfalsifiable idea and declare that the fact that the idea is unfalsifiable means it is rational to believe in it. I could believe that the universe actually runs on invisible, undetectable fart gas left over from a dead race of cosmic faeries, and just as easily can declare, "If my fart gas theory is true, then assuming it is true is useful." Generalized: "If my wild idea about X is true, then assuming it is true is useful for figuring out what is true." This is the definition of irrationality. If you want to be rational, you don't start with your conclusion and work backwards from there.