2 ms·
> Authors and public figures in fields as diverse as Complementary and Alternative Medicine and progressive politics (including Deepak Chopra, Rupert Sheldrake,
by pessimizer 8y ago
> Authors and public figures in fields as diverse as Complementary and Alternative Medicine and progressive politics (including Deepak Chopra, Rupert Sheldrake, Gary Null, John Pilger, and George Galloway) have complained of persistent negative coverage on Wikipedia despite the site’s vaunted neutrality and the promise that “Biographies of Living Persons” are held to the highest standard.
Don't bother to continue reading if you think that a "diverse" range of failings are going to be discussed; it's really just about alternative medicine hucksters and left-wing journalists and politicians.
1) I'm happy that Wikipedia doesn't cover health scams as if they were reality based, and
2) As a person on the left-wing, I understand that we are attacking the most powerful elements in modern society, and I don't have the unattainable standard for a publicly-edited encyclopedia to somehow manage to be neutral on those people who are attacking those powerful elements. All of the types of sources that encyclopedias should use will be filled with attacks against the left-wing on a constant basis.
Superficially, both classes of people seem the same (health scammers and left-wing reformers), because they face a similar challenge - attacks by the corporate mainstream media. I hold the same standard for both types of cases: that factual misstatements be promptly removed (which I think will do good things for the left, and bad things for alternative health practitioners.) I do not expect Wikipedia to remove the editorial biases of its sources. Somebody trying to find out more information about Jill Stein in an encyclopedia might actually be trying to discover the nature of the slanders directed at her, or the content of a particular slander; I'd like it to be there and well sourced.