3 ms·
My stance on that: ex-bloc countries have that¸ I tell you as one who did part of my high school in Russia. Weak students cheat, strong students cheat, and only
by baybal2 8y ago
My stance on that: ex-bloc countries have that¸ I tell you as one who did part of my high school in Russia. Weak students cheat, strong students cheat, and only few cranky principled oddballs reject the system and shout "Hey you, ex university prof, throw whatever you want at me, I'll solve it and shred it to pieces" - those being universally hated for "making life harder for everybody"
My mom once had fun listening to shitty talks from parents of other students along the lines "hey, can you tell your boy to quiet down a bit, he raises the plank to high for the rest of the class"
You can understand weak students' reasons: they simply can't do it otherwise. But why do strong ones cheat? That what dazzled me about Russians, and Russia in general. What that was is the gigantic, monstrous, totally pathological fear of failure that permeates country's "socially endowed classes."
And secondary to that is the element of social pact: when pupils with excellent marks begin cheating and copying from one another, they begin to embrace the "omerta" created by this, sealing their social contract with their peers.
Most rich, powerful people in Russia teach their children very intentionally to behave along the lines - get close and sycophantic with others privileged people. And you know, to infirm young minds, the reasoning that any privilege one gets in life is through joining some "exclusive social clubs" of other privileged people, is hard to challenge, especially when this comes from their parents.
And after some time, their children become completely accustomed to not to taking upon any challenge straight, because they genuinely believe that even simplest things in life are not doable without tricks, cheats, and favours from other power powerful people. This is the culture in which social elites in Russia grow up.
After being around mainlanders for 11 years while working in electronics, I feel it is very much the same for them. For both of above reasons, people from both nations are extremely afraid of challenge, and more so when you deal with people higher up on the social ladder.
- markvdb 8y agoThank you for this comment. Useful analysis, even if a bit overly broad. One can only speculate how much for the former USSR this has to do with the trauma of the crazy nineties.
- baybal2 8y agoNineties has nothing to do with it, that's more of Brezhnev's doing, and some extend Stalin's. Whenever there is a talk of socially endowed classes, that pretty much means ex-communists, and officials' families. The amount of genuine self-made men who got to any level of prominence in society is so small, they never influenced the societal dynamics in any perceivable way. Such are still being looked at as if they are some kind of space aliens by regular people.
- markvdb 8y agoOne certainly could see continuity between this behavior in the Soviet era and the nineties. In the Soviet days, I guess not seeking connection meant a less interesting social position. In the post-Soviet days, if I hear my friends from the former USSR, it could mean getting close to startvation.
- baybal2 8y agoCan't say the same, my parents were ones of few people making 6 digits in early Russia. Mom working in one of first foreign banks in Russia as a de-facto CTO, and father having a trade company. Opportunities were there, no way to deny that. People who report stories of near starvation genuinely "had to work hard" to get to that near starvation point. Even dockers and labourers in my father's company in Vladivostok had few hundred buck net per month salaries in 1996. Ones who got to that point probably were commies themselves, or were the type of people "sitting around and waiting money to suddenly fall upon then from nowhere just for that, and a nice diploma they had" as they did back in "good ol soviet times"...
- markvdb 8y ago> Can't say the same, my parents were ones of few people making 6 digits in early Russia. Mom working in one of first foreign banks in Russia as a de-facto CTO, and father having a trade company. Opportunities were there, no way to deny that. People who report stories of near starvation genuinely "had to work hard" to get to that near starvation point. Even dockers and labourers in my father's company in Vladivostok had few hundred buck net per month salaries in 1996. Good for them. > Ones who got to that point probably were commies themselves, or were the type of people "sitting around and waiting money to suddenly fall upon then from nowhere just for that, and a nice diploma they had" as they did back in "good ol soviet times"... That sounds like a generalisation with very little empathy. The people I have in mind are not ethnic Russians. They didn't live in Russia. One of them had their parents deported to Siberia by the Soviets. Neither of them were in the Komsomol. One of their children was born in 1990. The only serious employer in their city stopped paying wages for months on end. If/when paid, they received 120€/month (early 1997) - for skilled masters degree work. They simply didn't have any buffer to escape the mess. They were definitely not the only ones...