3 ms·
I agree with that. There's some of the latter going on in science academia lately. Pay used to be Fog Creek style, determined almost entirely on a mixture of ye
by _delirium 16y ago
I agree with that. There's some of the latter going on in science academia lately. Pay used to be Fog Creek style, determined almost entirely on a mixture of years of service (civil-service style) and rank. An Associate Professor with 8 years of experience got a certain salary; a Distinguished Institute Professor holding a Prestigious Chair got the salary associated with that position. Pay and raises were fairly easy to figure out (approximately) because they were entirely tied to these public ranks. There was still a lot of politics, but the ranks at least have some social legitimacy: people are willing to accept that the Named Chair of Particle Physics should be paid more than an Associate Professor of Physics.
As things have become more market-like, it's become a lot more flexible (mainly in science/engineering). A junior professor might get offered more than a more senior and prominent professor because the school is trying to lure her away from elsewhere, or really wants to fill a particular hole, or just because of competition (if someone has offers from three schools, yours has to be in the same ballpark). At private schools, this is sometimes handled classic corporate style, but it's not that private, because sometimes faculty votes are involved in the decision making.
At public schools, this combines with sunshine laws that make any state employee's salary viewable in online databases (in some states). This causes all sorts of shenanigans. Now you have professors realizing that they're paid $90k while someone much less accomplished in the same field is paid $110k, due to the histories of who got hired when. So they're going to need to be offered $120k, or else they're going to threaten to move (and there's a whole bluffing and bluff-calling game in that). This also creates the perverse incentive that people who move around a lot, or at least interview around a lot and solicit external offers on a semi-regular basis, are generally paid more than those who focus their energies on one university's research/education programs.
Overall I don't think it's been a good change for there to be both: 1) disparity in pay that is not tied to clearly public things like Distinguished Professor versus Associate Professor; and 2) that pay disparity to be public, so colleagues know who makes more than who.
- bobf 16y agoAs a brief anecdote, I was completely shocked by what some professors earned at the public university I attended. I had several standard professors in finance and accounting who made ~$150-200k/year plus freelance consulting at $500+/hr. If more people knew of the salary potential of being a professor, universities might get more quality applicants.
- eitally 16y agoThese high salaries -- medical/law/architecture/business/etc are the same way -- are required in order to lure the superstars into academia and away from private practice. The highest paid professors at my public university were paid $500k+, with the top handful being at $1m +/-$100k.
- _delirium 16y agoThat's definitely the reason, but I'm not sure it's always worth it. The fact that someone can earn $1m in the private sector doesn't automatically mean that they'll provide $1m worth of value to any university that hires them; the skills aren't identical. Might be less true in areas where being prominent is a ticket to bringing in a ton of grant money; some famous medical researchers essentially pay their own salary out of grants, in which case from the university's perspective they're free.
- joeyo 16y agoThis is a because a professor of finance or accounting also has the credentials to be a CFO (or even CEO). They're in demand and that's the price that the market will bear. There is probably a similar effect in computer science, engineering, medicine and related fields.
- bobf 16y agoOf course. Most people just don't think you can earn that kind of income in academia.