2 ms·
And yet again this only makes the duopoly of Facebook and Google trackers even stronger. There cookies will never be removed, while every other network that off
by manigandham 8y ago
And yet again this only makes the duopoly of Facebook and Google trackers even stronger. There cookies will never be removed, while every other network that offers potential competition suffers.
It's rather interesting how these browser makers consistently ignore any cooperation with the industry and keep making naive mistakes.
Here's a simple answer that would solve everything: all browsers offer a single anonymous Advertiser ID that is randomly generated and available to any JS via API. It can be regenerated anytime and limited to per-domain.
Instantly that would remove 90% of the pixels and improve performance everywhere, make recommendations more accurate for those who care, make it simple to opt-in or out of preferences, and would prevent this continuous arms-race.
- tomc1985 8y agoUntil the mainstream learns how to work those controls, and as a result of uptake adtech develops something that works independently of Mozilla's system
- manigandham 8y agoThis is a universal system design, not just for Mozilla. The mainstream is already blocking ads and cookies so it's not like we aren't already there, instead this is a way to get back to a good equilibrium on both sides while protecting privacy for those who want it.
- pdkl95 8y ago> while every other network that offers potential competition suffers. Good, that's the goal. > And yet again this only makes the duopoly of Facebook and Google trackers even stronger. It takes time to break entrenched monopolies. If you want to speed this up, antitrust enforcement would help a lot. > browser makers consistently ignore any cooperation with the industry and keep making naive mistakes. The the User Agent isn't obligated to help any particular industry. What you are calling a "naive mistake" is really just "fulfilling the needs of users who do not want to be tracked". > anonymous Advertiser ID That isn't possible. Make whatever random number you want, but the first time someone browses to Google (or anybody else) it will forever be associated with their (personally identifiable) Google account. Regenerating it just makes Google store a few more values in the account. > Instantly that would remove 90% of the pixels ... and would prevent this continuous arms-race. History suggest this would have little effect on that "arms-race". Advertisers have demonstrated many times that they only increase surveillance. The only effect your "Advertiser ID" would have is to make surveillance even easier. > make it simple to opt-in or out of preferences, It's naive to think anybody that already ignore the DNT header would respect a future redesign of the same flag.
- manigandham 8y agoBreaking up a monopoly via government pressure is completely separate from browser and internet privacy, and hurting potential competition only helps the monopoly. Google and Facebook wouldn't use the Advertising ID because they already have 1st party cookies so they know who you are. The User Agent is just software that happens to be called that, it's not a moral statement, and this feature would help solve many issues on both sides. DNT is actually respected by far more than you may think, but the lack of an ID to go along with it is the problem. Having an easy ID system would let ad networks use native APIs, reduce network calls, and build up profiles that only last as long as a user is willing to keep the same ID. Let people change it per hour if they want, it maintains privacy will keeping a browsing session relevant and not overloaded with the same ad shown 20 times. You know what's actually naive? It's refusing to listen to the industry that moves 100s of billions in ad spend every year and is full of smart people trying to have rational discussions instead of constantly fighting emotional tirades that put everyone in this mess in the first place.
- pdkl95 8y ago> The User Agent is just software that happens to be called that This is impressive rationalization. It's the User Agent because it's the software the user is running as their agent on their own computer. The only "moral statement" involved is basic property rights. The user gets to control their own computer (including the browser) for the same reason you get to control how the products you own are used. > DNT ... but the lack of an ID to go along with it is the problem You don't need to have an ID to not track someone's browsing habits. What, exactly do you want to do that 1) needs a tracking ID, but 2) isn't some type of tracking? > Having an easy ID system would let ad networks [...] That's nice. That isn't the user's job. > and build up profiles that only last as long as a user is willing to keep the same ID See? That's exactly the type of tracking we're trying to prevent. Surveillance is still surveillance even if you delete later. > not overloaded with the same ad shown 20 times. Again, not the user's problem. > You know what's actually naive? The surveillance-based businesses that are driving us straight into a surveillance state without any care for the risks and damage they are creating? > It's refusing to listen to the industry that moves 100s of billions in ad spend every year You should realize that many people see this as a bad thing. Those billions could have been spent on something useful. Of course, I don't expect you to understand this if your salary currently depends on not understanding the harm created by the ad industry. > trying to have rational discussions instead of constantly fighting emotional tirades You're sense of entitlement is amazing. People get emotional when people try to use their property without permission. There is no "rational discussion" here. If you are tracking people, you are the enemy. One day, when the databases of everyone's behavior starts to cause real damage (Cambridge Analytica was only a tiny preview), you will understand this. Until then, I suggest at least talking to the average person about what they think about having their activities tracked.