6 ms·
> And even before landing on the moon there were many flights prior to that. And SpaceX can (and does!) use the knowledge from all those missions, including th
by mschuster91 8y ago
> And even before landing on the moon there were many flights prior to that.
And SpaceX can (and does!) use the knowledge from all those missions, including the various rovers and other Mars missions.
That's partially a reason why SpaceX can work at all. They have access to all the knowledge that NASA and ESA spent billions and billions of dollars on, and the flexibility of being private and not bound to usual molasses-slow government processes as well as changing administrations with changing desires.
SpaceX as a result has both a higher rate of development and higher focus, as they can keep R&D/construction/ops concentrated and not spread around the whole US for "political" (aka senator money coffers) reasons. NASA always has to take politics into account, SpaceX can freely allocate funds wherever they believe is best for progress.
- computerex 8y agoYou are absolutely correct in that SpaceX has access to tons of research conducted by NASA/ESA and other space agencies. However, BFS is fundamentally different than what Apollo did. Arguably, developing a rocket capable of providing the required amount of delta-v to achieve free return trajectory around the moon or Mars is the easy part in a crewed mission. Hell, the BFR in the proposed specs is only slightly stronger than Saturn V and that was half a century ago. The hardest part is man rating the whole thing. That takes a lot of time.
- tigershark 8y agoSeriously? 61.8MN is just “slightly stronger” than 35.1MN? I guess that no one would call something almost twice as powerful “slightly stronger”, but looking at your other comments you are here just to spread misinformation about space x.
- computerex 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BFR_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BFR_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_V https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_V You realize that BFR is much heavier than the Saturn V stack, right? The thrust means nothing. Look at the effective payload weight. Yes the thrust is higher, but it weighs nearly 1.5 times more so it can't haul as much payload. Notice how the payload to LEO is less than the Saturn V. I am not spreading misinformation. I'm here to educate.
- mikeash 8y agoFor an apples to apples comparison, you need to include the BFS itself in the “mass to orbit” number. Or subtract the mass of Apollo from Saturn V’s.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe payload is such an interesting comparison that there is a word for it. The wikipedia articles give 100,000 kg for the BFR and 140,000 kg for the Saturn V. For hundreds of missions, the BFR strategy of refueling to leave orbit probably makes sense, but it's pretty clear which rocket puts more payload in a 90 mile orbit, a very direct comparison of launch capability. And of course, BFR may exceed projections (or fail to meet them).
- mikeash 8y agoWikipedia’s number for the BFR is payload other than the BFS itself. BFR puts up a gigantic spaceship, and a huge payload inside it. Saturn V did not do this. Apollo (or Skylab) was the payload.
- computerex 8y agoThe BFS is part of the whole stack, it is the second stage. It is unclear because of lack of technical specification from SpaceX but at the moment it seems unlikely that the BFB will fly without the BFS. So you can't look at the BFS as a separate thing as you are implying, it is a core part of the architecture. It'd be like saying that the Saturn V can haul x amount of payload in addition to its second stage.
- mikeash 8y agoYou can’t ignore it either. The BFS isn’t a useless hunk of metal once it’s in orbit, it’s still very useful. Consider a past example. The Space Shuttle’s payload to orbit was many times smaller than Saturn V’s. Yet the Shuttle could do missions over two weeks long with seven crew, far more than Apollo could. How is that possible? Because the orbiter didn’t count as part of the “payload”. BFR is going to send 8 people on a trip around the moon. Saturn V couldn’t do that, even though it could orbit more “payload.” It all depends on the mission. If you just want to put satellites in orbit, Saturn V is more capable (ignoring costs). If you want to send people somewhere, BFR is way more capable. BFR can put a lot more mass into orbit, it’s just that a lot of that mass is taken up by mandatory stuff. If that stuff is useful for you then it should count. If it’s not then it shouldn’t. And that brings us back to my original point, way up there, that BFR is major overkill for a satellite launcher, but makes perfect sense for a Mars mission.