3 ms·
Three, the posit that there is life elsewhere in the solar system, which if it is the case, would be a good enough reason alone to explore the solar system. Th
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
Three, the posit that there is life elsewhere in the solar system, which if it is the case, would be a good enough reason alone to explore the solar system.
This is the most interesting one because it begs many questions such as:
Assuming we find life, then what? The purpose ostensibly would be to study it to understand our place in the universe better. But what if it doesn't want to be studied, or we don't have the scientific capacity to study it? What is gained?
Why are humans, as opposed to robotic systems, the absolute right path to discovering other life forms?
Is it even possible for humans to get anywhere worth investigating within reasonable distance in a human lifespan?
I think the answer to all of these is, "Human spacetravel is the solution looking for the problem" because biologically, we aren't built or suited to multi-planetary existence in any kind of scenario where we would be effective.
Musk, says it himself: He needs a reason to get up in the morning [1]. That's pretty much the primary answer for everyone I've ever seen make any kind of reasonable argument for manned travel to Mars.
In other words, in the long run our engineered systems (robots etc...) will be more efficient at answering off-world questions than we are. That's not sexy or exciting so people don't argue it.
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/16/elon-musk-on-inspiration-and-success.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/16/elon-musk-on-inspiration-and...
- sargun 8y agoOh, I don’t have a strong opinion that we need to send humans, but I foresee that the goal of putting more humans driving better, and more robots in space. Don’t you think that the discovery of life outside of earth would have a profound effect on the people of earth, and how they operate? They might have new methods of agriculture, to grow things in the the soil of Mars that are applicable to Earth. They might have lots of things we can learn.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoDon’t you think that the discovery of life outside of earth would have a profound effect on the people of earth, and how they operate? Maybe. Depends on what kind of life. Finding a single cell amoeba on Titan won't do anything for the millions of Americans working two or three jobs trying to make rent. I'd argue finding an intelligent society or entity etc... wouldn't change much for them either. They might have new methods of agriculture, to grow things in the the soil of Mars that are applicable to Earth. Again, maybe, but this is a very anthropomorphic view. There is nothing that suggests that there are things outside of our atmosphere that can materially and positively impact humanity.
- sargun 8y agoYeah, you present a good point about all those unemployed Americans. I really don’t think that we need to stop all progress across everything to help them. What do you propose we do to help them instead, and if it involves reallocation if government spending, where would you take it from?
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoWhat do you propose we do to help them instead, and if it involves reallocation if government spending, where would you take it from? I'm not prepared to answer this in this format. To start with though, I'm unsure it can be directly solved, only mitigated. I don't think there are any solutions that don't have massive trade offs and unknown outcomes. Largely though, I'm not a fan of state interventions.