4 ms·
It's the "last conversational taboo"? Isn't it really just no-one else's business if you don't want to share that info? Most people keep their bra size, weight,
by petercooper 16y ago
It's the "last conversational taboo"? Isn't it really just no-one else's business if you don't want to share that info? Most people keep their bra size, weight, penis length, or preferred sexual kinks a "secret" too, and pay is just as personal and private to most people as those things.
- roc 16y agoThat's all 'taboo' means. It identifies things we don't talk about openly, regardless of why. Personally, I think the social disinclination to talk about salary is as manufactured for private gain as the whole diamond engagement ring 'tradition'. The practical effect of secrecy in compensation is that employers have a massive advantage in negotiations and end up paying far, far less for labor. Perhaps I'm just cynical, but in my personal experience, effects like that are never accidental.
- petercooper 16y agoThat's all 'taboo' means. Sure. My point was mocking how it can't be the "last" conversational taboo since there are other, far more private things we don't tend to discuss in public either. Indeed, discussing salary isn't a "taboo" at all from my POV since so many people do it in public nowadays anyway.
- roc 16y agoI've had far, far more conversations that included all those other personal details than I've had that included compensation.
- petercooper 16y agoYou've had more conversations about your sexual preferences and anatomical details than about money you've earned? Sounds fun but I suspect that puts you in the minority ;-) At least on HN where "I made $X yesterday!" type comments and posts seem to be reasonably common.
- kscaldef 16y agoThere's only one person I've dated who knew my salary, and vice versa.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 16y agoI think the important question is what if you _do_ want to share that info, and other people are interested in hearing it, why aren't we talking about it? BTW, I'm always willing to share, and the result is usually that people are eager to share with me (to varying degrees of precision, of course.) I don't have any issue with it because I never confuse my salary with my worth as a person. It's my worth to the company commingled with my ability to negotiate. When workers share salary information with each other, it smooths the last part out. I'm not going to stop doing it until competing companies are required not to disclose the prices of their products to each other - and I see difficulties in the implementation of that:)