4 ms·
> If the latter, then why not just write the contract on paper from the start since courts have well established traditions for dealing with paper contracts? P
by derefr 8y ago
> If the latter, then why not just write the contract on paper from the start since courts have well established traditions for dealing with paper contracts?
Presumably because paper contracts don't scale; nor do they arbitrate machine:machine interactions without human proxies on both sides.
- ttul 8y agoShow me a few practical reasons you’d ever need a smart contract for this, instead of just some code and an actual agreement between parties to place nicely together?
- antidesitter 8y ago> an actual agreement between parties to place nicely together What does this mean?
- derefr 8y agoAssume you have a two-sided markets of interacting agents who each only interact once, like buyers and sellers. Without any middleman, this doesn't work, because the parties are in a prisoner's dilemma, rather than an iterated prisoner's dilemma—nobody can effectively punish the other party in a future transaction, so there's no incentive to not screw the other party over. Without smart contracts, what you need here is a "marketplace owner"—a legal agent where both sides have a legal agreement with them. This changes the situation so both sides are playing an iterated prisoner's dilemma with the marketplace owner, who can punish a user on either side for what they did to a user on the other side in a previous one-off transaction. But this marketplace-owner role is also known as a "middle man." Their role in punishing defection is valuable enough that the market doesn't disappear if they extract rent from both sides—and so they usually do. Ideally, we would have an alternative where everything still works out, but where rent cannot be extracted. With smart contracts, the marketplace-owner role is performed by, essentially, the buyers and sellers all automatically voting on whether a given transaction was legitimate. The smart contract is just the specification both sides have agreed to, in a given case, for judging the legitimacy of a transaction; and the blockchain is just a database which all parties doing this auditing synchronize amongst themselves, containing copies of both 1. those specifications, and 2. all the data required to validate any new transaction against them (which, in the case of a ledger-like transaction, is usually "all the valid transactions executed so far"). There still needs to be a human-level legal recourse for disputes—but those disputes would only ever be disputes about the specification of transactional legitimacy being wrongly specified, which are much rarer than disputes of the form of "he defected!"/"no I didn't!", to the point that the service of arbitrating such disputes would not be seen, at a human level, as valuable enough to justify rent-extraction.
- landryraccoon 8y ago> Assume you have a two-sided markets of interacting agents who each only interact once, like buyers and sellers. Don’t we already have this? Street markets and retail shops and one off websites and millions of other agents making up modern markets? It seems to work fine.
- derefr 8y ago> Street markets and retail shops In cities with police forces. Purchases at street-markets don't devolve into robbery because police forces disincentivize that. The municipality taxes you for that service, and so is effectively a middleman and rent extractor for these transactions. Also, in cases where you've decided to trade using cash rather than to barter, you're being protected from your counterparty paying with counterfeit currency, by the state coming down rather harshly on counterfeiters, keeping counterfeit currency out of the market. That's a service they provide in exchange for state-level taxes. So, another middleman and rent extractor in your transaction. > one off websites When this works, it's because the payment processor (Stripe, PayPal) is acting as the middleman and rent-extractor. Even without a payment processor, you can usually seek redress from your credit card company (another middleman and rent-extractor.) Also, a search engine probably acted as a matchmaking agent to lead you to reputable services (and so is also acting as a rent-extractor in a round-about way, with sponsored ads and such.) Without these parties in play, the Internet is not a safe place to transact. 99.99% of credit card input forms on the internet (by volume) are those of phishing domains. That's what a non-iterated prisoner's dilemma looks like.
- ItsMe000001 8y agoDo I read this right - and this is a genuine question, not a rhetorical one - "smart contracts" as tool to not have to rely on the state? Because to me it seems tools like these are exactly the ones that need a strong state (or a strong mafia - when there is no state those with power create one for themselves). I admit I have a hard time understanding what your point actually is.
- sparkie 8y ago"paper" here could be used loosely to refer to traditional contracts enforced by the state, in any form. They can still be electronic, but the databases will obviously be administered by the state, rather than being immutable on a blockchain. They'll be more efficient, but given the historical record of government database systems, less secure.
- derefr 8y agoI'd be fine with this for regulatory compliance. But one nice thing about contracts (the objects of civil law) is that the state doesn't actually get involved in them except in the breach. You can create as many contracts as you like, as often as you like, with whomever you like, without any sort of filing cost or delay, and they will require no resources to maintain until someone on one side or the other thinks the contract has been violated. I can't imagine the same being true if all contracts essentially worked like deeds, having to be notarized and filed at a government office (even if electronically) to have force, and needing to pay upkeep fees to keep them filed there lest their force lapse. Also: a blockchain is nice because it allows people in different sovereign jurisdictions to create a contract. There's no legal contract I can make, as a US citizen, with e.g. a Cuban or Iranian citizen. But I can transact with them through a smart contract.
- xchaotic 8y agoSmart contract do not override existing law os if there's sanctions for say selling PS3s to Iranians, even if smart contract could let you do that, it wouldn't be legal. In any case the existing case law in the US and UK already has it that a contract does not have to written down to exist so if you're pretty sure things are going to go well - say mowing the lawn, you can go ahead and just enter the contract with nothing written down (an no need for smart contract either)
- derefr 8y agoI'm not really talking about overriding sanctions; just an absence of trade/treaty relations between two countries. You can't have an iterated prisoner's dilemma on an international level without an extradition treaty. (Well, you can, using the sort of arbitrary state-to-state gifts that international diplomatic incidents are resolved by, but that doesn't scale.) > already has it that a contract does not have to written down to exist so if you're pretty sure things are going to go well - say mowing the lawn, you can go ahead and just enter the contract with nothing written down Yeah, but there's a reason people do write contracts down rather than... not doing that, when they want to actually have them be enforced in the breach. Personally, I don't even really want smart contracts to "do" anything on their own; all they would need to be useful is to be predicates—executable code running on a distributed computer that automatically detects a breach of contract, so that legal measures can be taken. That, by itself, is much more useful than a regular two-party written contract that devolves into "burn down their office to get out of the contract", or the regular three-party (you, them, a lawyer) written contract that costs $500/hr to facilitate.