4 ms·
This is a really terrific and accessible introduction to QM math. If you get to the end, it is worth noting the similarity of the tensor product and the join o
by lisper 8y ago
This is a really terrific and accessible introduction to QM math.
If you get to the end, it is worth noting the similarity of the tensor product and the join operation in a relational database.
- hamad 8y ago"the tensor product and the join operation in a relational database." can you elaborate more. very interesting!
- lisper 8y ago> can you elaborate more Hope, you'll have to figure it out for yourself. It's not hard. If you just look at the details of how these two operations are defined it should be obvious.
- gunnihinn 8y agoAs a PhD in mathematics who converted to development, please, go into the details of what you mean. I know tensor products. I know SQL joins. I see superficial similarities between the two, but no unifying underlying principle. The world has had quite enough of nonsense thrown around because it's "obvious". Put your money where your runaway mouth is.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lisper 8y agoUm, can we tone this down a notch please? I didn't intend for this to be a deep insight, just the observation that both the tensor product and the join operation involve taking all possible pairs of the components of the input data. The only formal difference between the two is that the components of the tensor product are ordered while the components of a join are not (they are a set).
- kgwgk 8y agoThe tensor product is not exactly like the Cartesian product because not all the elements of the tensor product of the Hilbert spaces representing each qbit can be written as the tensor product of the individual qbits. In the cross join case, all the elements are pairs of elements from the original tables. In the Hilbert space of a composite system only the separable states can be written as the tensor product of states of the subsystems. "Observation 3.6.5: Interesting two-qubit states. Not every 4-dimensional vector can be written as a Kronecker product of two 2-dimension vectors, e.g., you can have a two-qubit state |Ψ⟩ such that: |Ψ⟩ = ̸= |ψ⟩|φ⟩, for any one-qubit state |ψ⟩ and |φ⟩ These types of states (called entangled states) are very intriguing and play a fundamental role in quantum mechanics."
- lisper 8y agoInterestingly, I was just about to edit my original comment to say exactly that: there are tables which are exactly analogous to entangled states in that they cannot be written as a cartesian product of two other tables. But I have to stress that I do not intend this to be a deep insight, just an interesting (IMHO) observation.
- kgwgk 8y agoIt is interesting that the basis of the tensor product of the spaces can be constructed as the tensor product of each possible combination of the basis of the spaces. Among other things, it makes clear that the dimension of Hilbert space for the composite system is the product of the dimensions of the Hilbert spaces. But this can distract us from the most interesting part, which is that the space spanned by these basis vectors is much larger than the simple cartesian product. Focusing on superficial similarities is a two-edged sword: anchoring on a familiar concept can help or make things more difficult. And it's guaranteed to annoy people! (I'm mostly getting over it, but I still dislike the use of the word "tensor" to refer to multi-dimensional arrays. Tensor has a meaning in geometry and tensor algebra is not about doing linear algebra on 2-d slices of a larger-dimensional object.)
- eapriv 8y ago
- monktastic1 8y agoIf one column contains the basis vectors of one space, and another column contains the basis vectors of another space, then their cross join will contain all pairs of basis vectors. If you were to take the tensor product of each pair you'd end up with a basis for the tensor product space. This is because the Cartesian product shows up in both places. I'm not sure if this is what the parent comment is getting at, and I'm not sure I see anything deep lurking there, but that could just be me.
- mathgenius 8y agoThis line of thought is very interesting indeed. Understanding the similarity/contrast to the join operator is really at the heart of what quantum is about. It comes down to, what do you mean by "and" ? Check out the breezy writing in this paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.07618 https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.07618 Also, the Rosetta stone paper (more advanced): https://arxiv.org/abs/0903.0340 https://arxiv.org/abs/0903.0340