5 ms·
I am not sure where you saw that banks are not using deposits to fund loans. For instance if you look at lloyd's balance sheet [1]: loans
by cm2187 8y ago
I am not sure where you saw that banks are not using deposits to fund loans. For instance if you look at lloyd's balance sheet [1]:
loans 482,752
cash and afs (liquidity pool) 100,619
trading assets 163,878
other 64,860
total assets 812,109
Deposits 447,928
trading liabilities 50,877
wholesale funding & capital 140,828
Insurance liabilities 103,413
other 69,063
total liabilities & equity 812,109
I believe the trading assets, trading liabilities and insurance liabilities must have to do with their insurance business and sort of net each others. What is left is basically 450bn of deposits and 140bn of capital and wholesale funding, funding 480bn of loans and 100bn of liquidity.
Now cash is fungible, and you cannot point to a particular asset and say that a particular liability is funding this asset. But overall, deposits are funding loans.
[1] https://www.lloydsbankinggroup.com/globalassets/documents/investors/2017/2017_lbg_annual_report_v3.pdf https://www.lloydsbankinggroup.com/globalassets/documents/in...
- stephen_g 8y agoOnly 1) the Basel framework of bank regulation which has been internationally adopted, and 2) explanations from the Bank of England (linked above) which categorically states that this is actually how banks work. The Deutsche Bundesbank has also published something to this effect, and the Governer if the Reserve Bank of Australia talked about it in a speech the other day [1]. 1. https://www.rba.gov.au/speeches/2018/sp-ag-2018-09-19.html https://www.rba.gov.au/speeches/2018/sp-ag-2018-09-19.html
- cm2187 8y agoI don’t want to get into some ad hominem attacks but I don’t think Basel 3 says that. Anyway, this is simple arithmetic, Lloyds could not have such a large loan book if it wasn’t funded by deposits. There are simply just not enough wholesale funding and capital liabilities. And the liquidity requirements are only a fraction of the deposits, particularly for retail deposits which are assumed to be sticky.
- stephen_g 8y agoIt absolutely does say that. The whole of part 1, "Minimum capital requirements and buffers" is 100% based on capital, and deposits don't factor in to any of the definitions of Tier 1 capital. The leverage ratios also factor entirely from capital that doesn't include deposits.
- cm2187 8y ago100% is the conversion of a loan balance to leverage exposure. The capital requirements vary between banks and regulator, but they are typicaly 3-5% of the leverage exposure. A leverage ratio requirement of 100% would make lending uneconomical. To achieve a return on equity of 10%+, you would have to charge over 10% on your loans.
- cuboidGoat 8y agoMy understanding is that deposits are really just a manifestation of a promise that a trusted party holds, so that the party making the deposit can make more promises to other parties. So, in banking a promise is often just as valid as holding a deposit. They aren't really lending you value, they are lending you verification of value.
- cm2187 8y agoThey are unsecured liabilities. But like all liabilities the bank received an asset when it issued it (cash or else), and like all liabilities the bank must have sufficient assets to pay it back on demand. The bank may not have the necessary liquidity to pay back all deposits at once (some of these assets are 30y mortgages) but it has an asset (otherwise is not solvant).
- neilwilson 8y agoWhen lloyds creates another loan it automatically creates the matching deposit. You get both a mortgage debt and a credit asset when you take out a loan. You then transfer that credit asset to somebody else to pay them. But it is the loan that creates the credit asset in the first place. Deposits have no quantity control function on lending. It's only ever a pricing issue.
- cm2187 8y agoWhen you lend to someone, he is free to transfer the money immediatly to whomever, who may or may not be a customer of that bank. The loan must have been funded for the bank to be able to afford to transfer the deposit away. Now you may get some deposit back that same day but the funding decision has to be made before. Anyway, neither funding or pricing determines the amount of lending these days, capital ratios are the limiting constraint.
- stephen_g 8y agoThe bank needs liquidity to settle inter-bank transfers after they've lent, some of that is deposits but they can also just borrow reserves from other banks if they need to do that. The lending itself created new bank credit, it was never "funded". If the bank has capital adequacy, they make the loan.
- makomk 8y agoAh, but when they transfer that money, it'll be to some customer of some bank whose loan customers will also be transferring money in the other direction. This means, in practice, that the main constraint on a bank's ability to lend money is how willing all the other banks are to lend money at the time. The Bank of England paper linked earlier in the thread explains why this has undesirable economic implications that are missed by the incorrect money multiplier model.
- neilwilson 8y agoWhen the deposit is transferred away essentially the target bank becomes the depositor in the source bank. That's effectively what 'interbank lending' is. The central bank system then centralises that peer-to-peer processes. Deposits are swapped for capital in the same way.