6 ms·
> I will further assert that there is probably a lot of low-hanging fruit for #2 and #3 Hmm...that low hanging fruit in #2 may not be quite as low or quite as
by mpweiher 8y ago
> I will further assert that there is probably a lot of low-hanging fruit for #2 and #3
Hmm...that low hanging fruit in #2 may not be quite as low or quite as tasty as you think.
See "The Early History of Smalltalk", by Alan Kay[1], where early successes in teaching this stuff led to great optimism that was quickly dashed by reality.
"[The adults] were able to get through the initial material faster than the children, but just as it looked like an overwhelming success was at hand, they started to crash on problems that didn't look to me to be much harder than the ones they had just been doing well on. "
"They couldn't even come close to programming it. I was very surprised because I "knew" that such a project was well below the mythical "two pages" for end-users we were working within."
"Finally, I counted the number of nonobvious ideas in this little [2 page] program. They came to 17. And some of them were like the concept of the arch in building design: very hard to discover, if you don't already know them."
"Looking back, this could be called another example in computer science of the "early success syndrome." The successes were real, but they weren't as general as we thought. They wouldn't extend into the future as strongly as we hoped. "
"They can answer any question whose answer requires the application of just one of these tools. But it is extremely difficult for them to answer any question that requires two or more transformations"
[1] http://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#smalltalkAndChildren http://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#smalltalkAndC...